Christian History Home > 2005 > Where Wesley's Followers Went Awry
Where Wesley's Followers Went Awry
Three new books by scholars of American Methodism explain why Methodists flourished in the 19th century and faltered in the 20th.
Reviewed by Jennifer Woodruff Tait | posted 8/08/2008 12:33PM
 1 of 2
"As good a church, as can be found,
Their doctrine is so pure and sound,
One reason which I give for this,
The Devil hates the Methodist.
If Satan could them all destroy,
The troops of hell would shout for joy;
I'll pray that God would them increase
And fill the world with Methodists."
For much of the 19th century, particularly in the United States, it seemed that the prayer voiced in this early Methodist hymn was well on its way to becoming reality. Numerous, prolific in publishing, and missionary-minded, Methodists may not have controlled the nation's elite discourse but they could be found at the heart of the nation's evangelical popular culture. Yet in their success could be found seeds of their pending destruction.
David Hempton's Methodism: Empire of the Spirit (Yale, 2005) outlines how a countercultural movement became a thoroughly cultural church. A native of Great Britain now teaching at Boston University, Hempton approaches the story of Methodism's 18th-century origin and 19-century dominance in two distinctive ways. He keeps the story of British Methodism in view as he narrates the American story, and he organizes the book not chronologically but topically.
Each chapter focuses on a different set of complementary forces that characterized the Methodist ethos and drove its expansion: competition and symbiosis (or mutual benefit), enlightenment and enthusiasm, opposition and conflict, money and power, medium and message, boundaries and margins, mapping and mission. The result is an energetic and breathless tour through a movement constantly in tension between the "authoritarian ecclesiology" of its top-down government and the "noisy, populist, and eclectic" lived experience of its adherents. Along the way, it collected over 9 million members worldwide by the early 20th century.
In the 20th century, Methodism did not escape the decline afflicting mainline Protestantism as a whole. Hempton rejects simplistic explanations of that decline—whether the jeremiads of insiders lamenting lost golden spiritual ages, or the "religion-inevitably-fades" narrative of secularization theory. But the decline was real, and he notes how Methodists collaborated with culture throughout the 19th century until the profoundly countercultural gap between "the ideals of scriptural holiness defined internally by the movement and achieved externally in the wider society" narrowed "to quite respectable proportions." Most powerful when most in tension with its surroundings, Methodism could not long survive harmony with a secularizing culture. Conquering the world was left to its heirs, the holiness and Pentecostal movements.
That contrast between "early" and "late" Methodism appears starkly in two other recent books, Lester Ruth's Early Methodist Life and Spirituality: A Reader (Kingswood, 2005) and Russell Richey's Marks of Methodism: Theology in Ecclesial Practice (Abingdon, 2005). (Both Ruth and Richey are professors at seminaries in the Methodist tradition—Ruth at Asbury Theological Seminary and Richey at Candler School of Theology at Emory University, where he also serves as dean.) Ruth edits and presents excerpts (including the above hymn) from poetry, journal entries, hymnody, sermons, letters, and histories of the first generation of American Methodists (1770s-1810s). He prefaces them with introductory essays that paint a vivid picture of an assertive faith characterized by "emotionalism, ecstasy, rigorousness, exuberance, and evangelism." Ruth's Methodists are energetic, disciplined, consumed by their message, and fully confident that they "pray, they sing, they preach the best."
Browse More ChristianHistory.net
Home | Browse by Topic | Browse by Period | The Past in the Present | Books & Resources
| |
|
