Guest / Limited Access /

If Chief Justice John Marshall was correct when he observed in 1819 that "the power to tax involves the power to destroy," then the power to take money out of a church offering plate by court order has the same destructive potential. That is what federal appellate courts will be considering this fall in two unprecedented cases arising in Illinois and Minnesota. At stake is the financial security and autonomy of every church, parachurch ministry, and secular charity in the nation.

The first case involves fraudulently obtained money that was donated to religious organizations. Michael Douglas, something of an expert in bilking investors, was at least charitable enough to donate more than $1.5 million to 16 religious charities. When he was sent to prison for mail fraud, however, investors started looking for ways to recoup their losses. This summer they convinced a federal court in the case of Scholes, Receiver v. World Vision to order the ministries to pay back the amounts donated by Douglas. Seven Christian ministries have appealed that order. It is essential to understand that at issue is not that the funds were tainted by fraud, but rather that the donor was insolvent. Under the ruling, when an insolvent donor gives money to a nonprofit organization, the church or charity has received a "fraudulent conveyance."

The case of Christians, Trustee v. Crystal Evangelical Free Church does not involve tainted donations but rather a generous Christian couple in Minnesota who faithfully tithed to their church. When they filed for bankruptcy relief, the trustee representing their creditors sued their church for repayment of all offerings received from the couple during the year prior to the bankruptcy filing. The church has appealed ...

Subscriber access only You have reached the end of this Article Preview

To continue reading, subscribe now. Subscribers have full digital access.

Read These NextSee Our Latest
RecommendedIs It Robbing God to Tithe on Your After-Tax (Not Gross) Income?
Is It Robbing God to Tithe on Your After-Tax (Not Gross) Income?
The Israelites were never subject to withholding upward of 15 percent.
TrendingMelinda Gates: ‘I’m Living Out My Faith in Action’
Melinda Gates: ‘I’m Living Out My Faith in Action’
One of the wealthiest and most controversial women in the world believes that all lives have equal value. She’s willing to spend $3.6 billion a year to prove her point.
Editor's PickMeet the Filmmaker Exposing Planned Parenthood
Meet the Filmmaker Exposing Planned Parenthood
How a 26-year-old founded the undercover operation to take down the abortion giant.
Comments
Christianity Today
EDITORIAL: Uncle Sam Wants Your Tithes
hide thisOctober 3 October 3

In the Magazine

October 3, 1994

To continue reading, subscribe now for full print and digital access.