No Humbug

A Christmas Carol remains the quintessential holiday story, but why?

Before Miracle on 34th Street, before It's a Wonderful Life, even before "The Nutcracker" ballet, there was A Christmas Carol. Charles Dickens published his "Ghostly little book" in 1843, just in time for the holiday shopping rush, and it became an instant runaway hit. The tale has never lost its momentum. It has been filmed some 200 times, with actors as varied as George C. Scott, Bill Murray, Patrick Stewart, and Scrooge McDuck playing the leading role. Why is this story so popular?

1. It resonates.


Dickens was in some ways a literary pioneer, for instance revealing the awesome commercial potential of the serialized novel, but he did not invent the storytelling craft. A Christmas Carol echoes medieval morality plays, in which otherworldly beings attempt to influence a human protagonist toward good or evil. Such plays often featured accounts of unhappy death to scare the main character—and the audience—straight.

Medieval Europeans cared much about dying well. Dickens's readers thought comparably less about the afterlife, but they, too, confronted death—from untreatable disease, from childbirth, from dangerous work and squalid living quarters—regularly. For contemporary readers and viewers, it may be Scrooge's bald materialism that provokes chills of identification. Whatever the cultural climate, the "Carol" works. 

2. It's Victorian.


Most of what we think of today as "traditional Christmas" hails from the nineteenth century. Sure, some European cultures have awaited Saint Nicholas or Sinterklaas for centuries, but the jolly old elf we all know and love was invented less than 200 years ago by poet Clement Clarke Moore and illustrator Thomas Nast.

Moore's "'Twas the Night Before Christmas" first appeared in 1823, a year after Britain's ...

Subscriber access only You have reached the end of this Article Preview

To continue reading, subscribe now. Subscribers have full digital access.

Tags:
December
Subscribe to CT and get one year free.
Christianity Today
No Humbug
hide thisAccess The Archives

In the Archives

December 2002

To continue reading, subscribe now for full print and digital access.