Jump directly to the content

Feature

What Did Paul Really Mean?

'New perspective' scholars argue that we need, well, a new perspective on justification by faith.

Pick up any recent Bible commentary or theology textbook, and you will read about something called the "new perspective on Paul." Seminaries have buzzed for decades about how they might apply to Paul the new light shed on Judaism. Some advocates of the new perspective conclude that the Reformers have led Protestants to misunderstand the all-important doctrine of justification.

As a result, the new perspective has stirred more than a little controversy. Ligon Duncan, former moderator of the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA), said new perspective theology "undercuts the certainty of believers regarding the substance of the gospel message." In June, the PCA General Assembly said advocates of the new perspective should report themselves to presbytery courts, because their teaching does not accord with the Westminster Standards.

Leading new perspective theologian N. T. Wright has repeatedly responded to his critics. Talking in 2004 with James D. G. Dunn, who named the new perspective, Wright faulted his critics for producing websites that "are extremely rude about the two people sitting on this platform tonight for having sold Paul down the river and given up the genuine Reformed doctrine of justification by faith."

So is this merely a squabble among Reformed theologians? Certainly not—some new perspective scholars also teach that Martin Luther's preoccupation with the Roman Catholic Church has led all Protestants astray. Do we now need to reframe our preaching and teaching to be truly biblical? British scholar Simon Gathercole takes on that question in this article.—CT Editors

For nearly 30 years, a number of theologians have argued for a "new perspective" on the apostle Paul and his doctrine of justification. Advocates ...

Article Preview

This article is currently available to CT subscribers only.

To continue reading:
LoginorSubscribe

More from Christianity Today
Sidelining the Stigma of Mental Illness

Sidelining the Stigma of Mental Illness

Amy Simpson challenges the church to step up its ministry to a vulnerable population.
Starting a Dialogue with Hip-Hop

Starting a Dialogue with Hip-Hop

Daniel White Hodge finds signs of the gospel in the beats of hip-hop.

The Latest in Movie News, June 17, 2013

Box office returns, Shrek on your TV, casting news, and Russell Crowe.
Popcultured: It's the Thoughts That Count

It's the Thoughts That Count

Why Christians can't be careless about the consumption of popular culture.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Comments

Displaying 7–9 of 20 comments

Forrest Long

August 14, 2007  7:15pm

This article and the problems relating to Paul and justification are interesting. Unfortunately our touchstone here seems to be the Reformation, with Rome being the culprit. A whole new perspective would be to bypass the reformers and Rome and go back to the Early Church Fathers to deal with these issues. It seems the evangelical church has written off anything prior to the Reformation as a source for sound theological argument. Much could be learned from the perspective of the Eastern Orthodox Church and its rich theological heritage on this issue, which is firmly rooted in the Councils and the Fathers.

Report Abuse

Wan Chee Keong

August 14, 2007  1:49am

The article is an informative and concise survey of the NPP. Gathercole's assessment and criticisms are generally valid, in particular point 1. Whilst Sanders' portrayal of first century Judaism as 'covenantal nomism' is in the main valid, Gathercole's contention that some Jews believed obedience to the Law will be rewarded on the final day of salvation (as demonstrated in his Ph.D thesis written [surprise!] under Dunn's supervision) does provide a needed corrective to Sanders'. My criticism of the article: 1. 'Inclusion' or 'covenant membership for Gentiles thru faith' whilst not a primary component of Justification, is nonetheless an integral and important facet. This is particularly so in Galatians ('covenant' appears in 3.15,17 and 4.24). It is not merely the 'scope' or 'application' of Justification, but part of the 'content'.It is not merely the 'tail'. 2. 'Flesh' does imply also ethnic lineage,religious and national exclusivity besides carnality. 3. NPP not in Rom.16.17-20.

Report Abuse

Rev. Dr. Wally Landes

August 13, 2007  10:41am

Several somebodies need to re-read Dr. Krister Stendahl's "The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West." Therein he cautions against reading Pauline texts through any modernist lens; in particular the psychologizing and moral relativizing perspectives of modernity. Faith/Pistis? Law? Works? Sarx/Flesh? What audaciity for any of us to claim that we positively know what Paul meant by such terms in his context...given that his realm was cosmopolitan, polylingual and inter-faith! Egads!

Report Abuse
See All 20 Comments
You must be a Christianity Today subscriber to post comments
(on articles open to the public, you must at least register for a free account).
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register

Don't Miss

Want to Change the World? Sponsor a Child

Want to Change the World? Sponsor a Child

A top economist shares the astounding news about that little picture hanging on our refrigerator.
The Stand-in Church

The Stand-in Church

Sometimes we speak the gospel from the bottom up.

The New Televangelists

The New Televangelists

I had to look past celebrity ministry to learn how to really pastor.

more | current issue

Books & Culture

Writing for the Reader

Writing for the Reader

A conversation with ...

Today's Christian Woman

Kirk Cameron: Love is Worth Fighting For

Kirk Cameron: Love is Worth Fighting For...

The 1990s teen heartthrob...

Out of Ur

Tweeting the (other) SBC

Tweeting the (other) SBC

Oh be careful little...

Gifted For Leadership Blog

Habits of the Heart, Part 1

Habits of the Heart, Part 1

Why routine spiritual...

Facebook

CT eBooks & Bible Studies


Shopping