Play Ball
An Open Letter to Tim Tebow's Fans
Editor's Note: Ted Kluck's letter to Tim Tebow fans was written when Tebow was the quarterback for the Florida Gators. The now-NFL quarterback recently began starting for the Denver Broncos, leading the team to an 18-15 win last Sunday. The outspoken Christian is also the focus of a new Internet site that created the name "Tebowing," spotlighting his on-the-field prayer kneel. "#Tebowing - to get down on a knee and start praying, even if everyone else around you is doing something completely different. Love it!" Tebow posted on Twitter. "'Tebowing' becomes most predictable Internet meme in history," the NFL wrote. The athlete is also the focus of many articles on sports and faith. Christianity Today interviewed Tebow earlier this year about faith, fame and football. Here's what Ted Kluck had to say during Tebow's college fame.
Dear Tim Tebow Fans,
Congratulations on choosing your sports hero wisely. Tebow—the stellar quarterback for the top-ranked Florida Gators, who open their season this Saturday against Charleston Southern—is a devout Christ-follower who has done nothing less than win the Heisman trophy and two national titles, as well as frequently contributing to the soul-saving of prison inmates and the circumcision of children on the mission field. He has also never, to my knowledge, publicly said anything stupid, been arrested, failed a class, driven while intoxicated, been in a bar fight, or embarrassed his university.
There are already tributes to Tebow being erected around the UF campus (a plaque, containing the words of a speech he gave, hangs outside the Gator football building), and a street named in his honor is just a matter of time. The Tim Tebow Fans website refers to his "God-like" status in the Sunshine State, and there's even a "Legend of Tim Tebow" song at iTunes, with this fawning chorus:
He can do no wrong
He's even got his own theme song
He's a Superman and a real nice guy
The boy next door with a bullet-proof smile
Double threat, he can run or throw
Whooaaa Whooooaaaa Tim Tebow
He's also a joy to watch. It has been written that Tebow plays quarterback like a linebacker, which is a compliment, but he also plays it like the best of quarterbacks—leading his team to victory with his arm, his feet, and the loyalty of his teammates. And he hasn't shown anything that would lead me to believe he won't do it in the pros.
That said, I think we need to give him a break.
In the time-honored tradition of evangelicals going berserk over the latest God-mentioning teenager in cleats, anxious to be led, inspired, entertained, and instructed by him, we are in danger of burning this kid out, or, perhaps more realistically, burning ourselves out on Tim Tebow. And while all signs point to (hopefully) Tebow continuing to have a successful career and a vibrant ministry, we need to give him the grace and the space to be a young man in his early twenties, which is to say occasionally imperfect. A sanctification work-in-progress, like the rest of us.
And we need to be there for him when the world tires of the novelty of a devout, successful Christian athlete. At some point the media will decide it's finished with stories of mission trips and prison visits and begin to find fault. And if Tebow is anything like the rest of us (maybe?) there is probably some fault to be found. My favorite Tebow moment, for which he took a little bit of grief, was the Gator chomp in the face of an opponent during last year's national title game, in the heat of the moment. It was a moment that showed passion and, perhaps more importantly, humanity.
Play Ball
From 2005 to 2007, "Play Ball" examined the relationship of sports and faith: sports is important precisely because it is a form of play, that is, a manifestation of the Sabbath. Contributors included Mark Galli, Collin Hansen, Mark Moring, and others.
- An Open Letter to Josh Hamilton
- An Open Letter to ESPN the Magazine
- An Open Letter to Brett Favre
- An Open Letter to Donte Stallworth
- Sports, for Him

The 'Handicap Icon' Gets New Life

Sidelining the Stigma of Mental Illness














Join the Conversation
Displaying 15 of 22 comments
See all comments
Sad2See
Dave and Andrew, You read these comments and make fun of the commentators. Just because you want to prop up your friend, Ted Kluck, you put down the people who read and comment on his article. Maybe you could learn something from Tim TEbow - be nice to others.
uga7
Goooooooooo Dawgs sic em.
The Lembrights
Teddy, good bit o' writing and CT will miss you! One of my favorite quotes from the comments, "Tebow can both throw a pigskin and cut a foreskin!"
Dave
Wow. Ted, the people who comment on your article are absolutely unbelievable. In some cases, no offense intended, they are funnier than your column, although to be fair, I don't think they are trying to be funny. As far as what you wrote goes, this is your best open letter yet. Brilliant.
Frank OHara
The problem with Tebow is that his Christian ministry and his circumcisions of young boys is in direct conflict. Circumcision is a very anti-Christian act. Start reading at the Feast of Tabernacles and finish at Paul's speaking to the Galatians and you will have the story. After Christ was crucified, the Pharisees came to the disciples and offered to take them into Judaism with a condition. They had to submit to circumcision. If they had accepted this offer, all recorded history or Christ's life would have been destroyed and there would be no Christianity today.