Jump directly to the content

books

BooksReviews, Interviews, News, Commentaries, Excerpts, My Top 5 Books, Wilson's Bookmarks, Book Awards

Is the Encyclopedia of Christian Civilization 'Too Christian'?

Publisher withdraws Christian reference work as editor alleges censorship.

It's uncertain when, or if, the Encyclopedia of Christian Civilization will reach bookstore shelves, but the delayed release of the four-volume work fueled debate about possible suppression of Christian academics by secular publishers.

Scholarly publisher Wiley-Blackwell's decision to withdraw the encyclopedia after it was printed and debuted at the annual meetings of the American Academy of Religion and the Society of Biblical Literature in November ignited the controversy.

Project editor George T. Kurian e-mailed the encyclopedia's nearly 400 contributors in February and called the decision "probably the first instance of mass book-burning in the 21st century." According to Kurian, president of the Encyclopedia Society and editor of 60 reference works, the encyclopedia was delayed because four critics called it "too Christian, too orthodox, too anti-secular, and too anti-Muslim, and not politically correct enough for being used in universities."

Kurian said changes requested by Wiley — including the removal of terms such as b.c./a.d., Virgin Birth, and Resurrection — were "the most blatant form of censorship in the history of religious publishing."

Wiley said a lapse in the project's editorial process was revealed after some contributors and editors raised concerns about the encyclopedia's content. After the book was printed, the publishing company learned the editorial board Kurian selected had not reviewed the work. The delay was made to give the board time to review it.

The publishing company said it erred in not being aware of Kurian's "shortcut" in the editorial process.

"It is indeed unfortunate that the content review by the editorial board is taking place late, but that does not negate the need to do so to ensure the quality of the work's scholarship," said spokesperson Susan Spilka. She said a decision hasn't been made about existing copies of the encyclopedia stored in Wiley's distribution facilities.

Wiley hasn't responded to Kurian's claims of anti-Christian censorship because it is the job of the editorial board to do so, said Spilka. "They are better qualified to evaluate the work and determine if revisions are necessary," she said.

Hunter Baker, a politics professor at Houston Baptist University who is familiar with the challenges Christians face in academic publishing, said Wiley's explanation is not convincing.

"You would not wait for the scholarly review until you've already printed several volumes," Baker said. "All of these issues are things that should have been worked out prior to publication. The train was already out of the station."

Prominent evangelical scholars had endorsed the encyclopedia. Mark Noll, history professor at the University of Notre Dame, had praised the book as "thoughtfully conceived." Edwin Yamauchi, history professor emeritus at Miami University, deemed it an "exceedingly valuable reference work" However, both said the basis of their reviews were only the table of contents and a handful of entries sent by Kurian.

Yamauchi said that whether or not the concerns about Kurian's book are justified, the publisher's actions were unusual. "It's rather extraordinary for a publisher to have printed a book and then withdraw it from sale," he said.

Bernard McGinn, professor emeritus at the University of Chicago Divinity School, was on the encyclopedia's editorial board but asked to be removed. He said he doesn't believe Wiley's actions are a form of censorship.

"They are only trying to be sure that their imprint is on a high-quality publication," he said.


More from Christianity Today
Grieving with the Good Friday God

Grieving with the Good Friday God

Shannon Polson sought healing from her father's death by retracing his fatal journey into the Alaskan wilderness.
Onward, Christian Couple

Onward, Christian Couple

How marriages can survive deployment—with some help from the church.

La complejidad hispana: Todo cambió en el 2012

¿Hacia dónde vamos?—Una palabra para los creyentes hispanos sobre forjar un futuro.
Jesus' Elevator Speech

Jesus' Elevator Speech

Or was it his inaugural address? There's a difference.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Comments

Displaying 1–3 of 7 comments

Dave

March 04, 2009  5:40pm

Despite factual holes in teh short quote we cannot deny there was massive perssecution of Christians by Muslims, as also tehre was massive persecution of Muslims by Christains. Also, the insertion the "Locust" anology is unprfessional for a book meant to be used in an acedemic setting, report thef acts, leave out the editoral. That is how acedemic writing is doen, you say "In this year these people did that." You don't say "These people did that so lbviously they don't deserve to live" thats not acedemic writing.

alanps

March 02, 2009  8:37am

If as the article states, the Editorial Board did not get to read the work before publication - then something went seriously wrong - aside and apart from the implied censorship.....

David Ahn

February 28, 2009  6:39pm

Clearly I haven't read the whole encyclopedia (apparently no one has), but the excerpt about the rise of Islam does strike me as more partisan than scholarly, with liberal use of inflammatory language such as "stolen," "brutal," "massacres," "locusts," etc. I'm all for accurate and unflinching articles, but as a Christian physician, I think the use of such language decreases our credibility to the academic community as well as to the unchristian world at large.

See All 7 Comments
You must be a Christianity Today subscriber to post comments
(on articles open to the public, you must at least register for a free account).
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register

Don't Miss

Forgiving Iran

Forgiving Iran

Long before I knew the true God, he helped me release my hatred.
Charles Williams, Playwright

Charles Williams, Playwright

A neglected aspect of the "other Inkling."

A Man Without Breath

A Man Without Breath

Philip Kerr’s new novel centers on the Katyn massacre.

more | current issue

Today's Christian Woman

"One Another"

"One Another"

How 12 New Testament...

Books & Culture

A Measure of Forgiveness

A Measure of Forgiveness

Memories of a British...

Small Groups

Why Small Groups Matter to Me

Why Small Groups Matter to Me

I've had a passion for...

Christian Bible Studies

Mental Illness Has a Face

Mental Illness Has a Face

What I learned while...

Facebook

CT eBooks & Bible Studies


Shopping