Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
May 16, 2012

Home > 2010 > March (Web-only)Christianity Today, March (Web-only), 2010
SoulWork
Love of Unimaginable Proportions
What to do when you find yourself praying to the quid pro quo god.




A couple of recent conversations suggest how hard it is to exorcize the quid pro quo god. Quid pro quo is a Latin phrase meaning "something for something." The quid pro quo god is one who does something for us if we do something for him, and the one who refuses to do something for us, or even punishes us, if we fail to do something for him.

Put this way, it seems impossible that anyone in their right mind would believe in such a god. The rub, of course, is that none of us are in our right mind—that's one of the effects of sin. And one reason we're attracted to the quid pro quo god is that he's a god we can get our minds around. He makes sense. He seems reasonable and fair: We do our part, he does his, and all will be well.

The problem is our part, which we tend not to do well at all. And when repeated efforts at doing our part fail, we discover that the quid pro quo god turns out to be a demon. Naturally, we try to exorcise this demon without success.

For example, I received a moving e-mail from a reader who, though she recognizes how distorted her view of God is, cannot shake off the distortion. She says that she suffers from obsessive-compulsive disorder; her obsession is a fear that every secular enjoyment is a sin and, she says, "unless I give them up, God will surely discipline me." By "secular enjoyment," she means things like listening to classical and country music, and collecting classic fashion magazines (Vogue, Harper's Bazaar).

Then she writes, "My husband passed away a few years ago and, to this day, I cannot get out of my head that God took him because I could not get rid of the above things. … You cannot imagine how I fear that perhaps God took the most important person in my life to discipline me for idolatry."

In fact, I can imagine it. Because I think we're all disciples of the quid pro quo god to one degree or another.

A friend—with no obsessive-compulsive bone in his body—told me recently that he feels he is stuck in a job he doesn't like because of the quid pro quo god. He likes many parts of the job, but there are some areas he despises, and he simply avoids doing them. He feels a stirring within that he should be doing something else with his professional life. But he feels that the quid pro quo god is not opening up new opportunities for him because of his failure to perform well in those despised responsibilities.

Then there is the pastor friend who feels that his small church will never grow because he battles on and off with pornography.

And on it goes. Every one of us has a secret sin and a private fear about that sin—that it's the cause of some hardship or the reason we're not being blessed in some way.

Most of the time, we realize this is a demonic lie. As Jesus said, God sends rain on the just and the unjust—that is, whether rain happens to be a blessing or a curse, it has nothing to do with our behavior. This is one of those biblical ideas that daily life verifies.

Think about the megachurch pastors who didn't merely look at pornography but carried on affairs and who nonetheless were blessed with mega-growing churches.

And what about those of us who have gotten promotions or job offers that were a definite step up in the world—and yet we recognized we were not really qualified for the position! And we took it anyway!

And what about the many loving, godly spouses who have lost a partner.

And finally, what about that fellow from first-century Galilee, who by all accounts did everything right and absolutely nothing wrong, who abided by all the dictates of the quid pro quo god and still ended up dead in the prime of life.





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 44 comments

A Person

March 15, 2010  9:30am

I have experienced "love" given out of obligation, duty and responsibility; it's what the 'loving' person is supposed to do so they choose to do it (sigh-because they "have to"). I have experienced acceptance given when I am good enough, smart enough, pretty enough, got-it-all-together enough. That is not love; it is not acceptance of me as a person of value and dignity, worth staying with, fighting for and walking beside. I have seen very rare glimpses of love given - with eyes lighting up, full of joy to be with me, not out of obligation or duty, but given freely. I have (thank God!) had a couple of people in my life over the years who have not turned away from me when I am not good or smart or together, but have walked beside me through doubts, fears, struggles and just normal human life stuff. I think that is when I've seen a glimpse of God. I know that is when I have wanted to know Him/love Him/follow Him more closely. So-which is God like?

Bob Garbett

March 13, 2010  5:22pm

Thank you, I needed so much to 'hear' this, All my life I have carried this deep suspicion about the 'goodness' and or ‘love’ of God, (maybe our Calvinist theology has played some part in this) and feel very often that I don't ever do enough or measure up and/or fail in so many areas of my life and that my own private sins somehow exclude me from this love. I think we all want desperately to believe in this love, but find it hard at the same time too. We are so conditioned in terms of looking for 'hidden clauses' that to embrace God's love completely (not that this is possible) is at the same time somehow to expose ourselves to disappointment and loss. I believe in God’s love but paradoxically brace myself at the same time each day it seems, for some great revelation that will finally prove my long held suspicions. Crazy stuff! I know, but as the Mark Galli pointed out we are not in our ‘right’ minds.

Julie D

March 12, 2010  2:24pm

Well said, Lee! I think there are believers who fear that if we focus too much on God's lavish grace, we are somehow giving people a license to sin. But I honestly believe that believers who understand their idenity in Christ and His extravegant love for them will struggle far less with sin, because they will not want to grieve the One who loved them enough to die for them.

Lee V

March 12, 2010  1:23pm

And why do they feel like they have to perform in order to earn God's blessings? Could performance-based sermons, study guides, etc., have something to do with that? It feels like a losing battle sometimes. I read my Bible, I begin to believe that nothing can separate me from the love of Christ, and then I go to church or hang around other Christians. And there are all these things I need to DO. I need to learn to pray better, study harder, not do this, do that..... I will NEVER measure up to a holy and perfect God on my own. I need Jesus. I want to learn to be more open and honest before Him, which makes me need more, not less, of His grace as I walk on with Him. If my relationship with God is quid pro quo and dependent upon me holding up my end of the deal, I might as well quit right now because I can not do it. So, again, which is true?

Julie D

March 12, 2010  12:50pm

I am sorry to have offended you, Another Reader; my intention was not to be condescending but to honestly state my feelings about this issue. I happen to feel sad when those of us who profess Christ are unable to enjoy His blessings without thinking we have to earn them somehow. I am speaking as someone who has spent a good part of my Christian life struggling against my own tendency to view God as an ogre ready to punish me for the smallest infraction, so I guess I was being condescending to myself as well (I also found that many who criticized the article were quite condescending in their own remarks, especially one reader who accused the author of abusing God's grace).

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



When the Unsinkable Sank

When the Unsinkable Sank

Leadership lessons from the deck of Titanic

Faith that Sticks

Faith that Sticks

Intergenerational connections and parental involvement give kids a faith that lasts beyond high school.

more | current issue

Small Groups

Let God's Love Overflow

Small groups can serve...

Kyria

Sloth

One of the "seven deadly...

Preaching Today

The Spiritual Importance of Becoming an ...

Key issues to address...

Building Church Leaders

Dealing with the Big Questions

Allow interns opportunities...

Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper