Jump directly to the content

Harold Camping Is (Sort of) Right

Jesus will put an end to this earth—but that is not the end of the story.

Harold Camping said something true. The media mocked him. But even Christians who disagree with the radio preacher's Rapture theology can appreciate his basic conviction.

After his May 21 prediction of the Rapture failed (but before his June 9 stroke), he said that it had been only a "spiritual coming." He then added, "It won't be spiritual on October 21st. The world is going to be destroyed altogether, but it will be very quick."

Whether the destruction will be very quick, we don't know. We are unconvinced about Camping's timetable. But in fact, the earth will pass away. Jesus said so (Matt. 24:35).

This is disturbing news for some, including many North American evangelicals. We've become successful and comfortable in advanced capitalistic societies, and most days we rather like the earth we inhabit. That's one reason we are fond of imagining heaven mostly as a problem-free earth, and that our work on earth will continue in heaven.

In the book Heaven in the American Imagination, historian Gary Scott Smith notes how socioeconomic status shapes a person's view of heaven. For example, he says, between 1890 and 1920 technological innovation "dramatically increased industrial production and agricultural output and cures were discovered for many endemic diseases." During this time, per-capita GNP increased almost fourfold, he says, and "progress abounded" in many fields.

"Paralleling these developments," he notes, "greater numbers of Christians conceived of heaven as an active realm where the saints performed varied forms of service and grew substantially in knowledge, character, and spirituality."

A century later, we find ourselves awash in technological and social advances that have multiplied our economic, material, and social goods. Evangelicals, imbued as they are with the Protestant work ethic, have been among the chief beneficiaries of all this. It should not surprise us that we are now drawn to descriptions of heaven that sound like the cushy lives we already enjoy. As Rob Bell puts it in Love Wins, "Honest business, redemptive art, honorable law, sustainable living, medicine, education, making a home, tending a garden …  will all go on in the age to come." All well and good for those who have a large measure of economic freedom and financial security. For the poor and oppressed who endure slave-like conditions doing backbreaking or mind-numbing toil for 16 hours a  day, health, the rule of law, good education, and rewarding labor are not mere extensions of the present. Such things can come only with the sharp in-breaking of God's kingdom.

The important point is that heaven is not about us. The glory of heaven is not about what we do or feel but whom we are with: "God's dwelling place is now among the people, and he will dwell with them" (Rev. 21:3).

There is continuity between this age and the age to come, but there is also great discontinuity. Now we see dimly, then face to face (1 Cor. 13:12). Marriage will be a thing of the past (Luke 20:35). Death and crying will be no more (Rev. 21:4). The kingdom will be so different that the writers of Scripture can picture it only as the replacement of the present physical earth and sky by something radically new (Matt. 24:35; 2 Pet. 3:10–11; Rev. 21:1).

This is crucial to remember in our optimistic, entrepreneurial age, when so many Christians talk about "building the kingdom of heaven," as if our good works are bricks in the foundations of the New Jerusalem. More than once we have heard pastors say that the purpose of the church is "to make the world a better place."


More from Christianity Today
Los samaritanos del día de hoy

Los samaritanos del día de hoy

Jesucristo nos muestra que bajo la piel, todos somos parientes.
The 'Handicap Icon' Gets New Life

The 'Handicap Icon' Gets New Life

New York’s revamped accessibility symbol began at a Christian college.
Sponsoring a Movement

Sponsoring a Movement

Former sponsored children like Moses Pulei pay it forward in their hometowns.
Sidelining the Stigma of Mental Illness

Sidelining the Stigma of Mental Illness

Amy Simpson challenges the church to step up its ministry to a vulnerable population.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Join the Conversation

Displaying 1–5 of 40 comments

Ivan A. Rogers

June 22, 2011  6:46pm

Imagine that! Evangelicals who teach the so-called secret Rapture of only "real" Christians are acting so uppity over Harold Camping's prediction that the Rapture was to take place on May 21st. Actually, I see very little difference between Camping and those many evangelicals who insist that the Rapture is going to happen "just around the corner" or "imminently" or "soon" or "during the next hurricane." Both Camping and Evangelicals are obsessed with dispensational eschatology . So much so that the editors of CT felt it necessary to opine that maybe "Harold Camping Is (Sort of) Right." But now we know that Camping was not even an ('itty-biddy') right -- or do we?

Report Abuse

Aid .

June 19, 2011  8:28pm

The article and picture of Camping is perhaps a bit unhelpful because the article isn't really focussed on him. In any case the theology of this article is very good.

Report Abuse

Grubal Muruch

June 19, 2011  1:50am

Mark Miwerds---You sure have a bad temper my friend...

Report Abuse

Mark Miwerds

June 18, 2011  9:36pm

Again, I have to say, 90% of those posting here just don't get it: the article IS NOT ABOUT CAMPING! Can't some of you read? He was merely a tie-in to an end-times opinion of the author's own, yet most of you use it just to sell your own (mis)interpretations resulting from your poor reading comprehension. The result is a laughable group of "little Campings." I'm now speculating that this is what the author intended. If so, it's a great "gotcha" moment, and the joke's on you. I pray every day that our churches and leaders will stress more and better Bible teaching, because what we see here is nothing short of pathetic.

Phillip Nicewaner

June 18, 2011  9:27pm

A half-truth is a complete falsehood. Being "sort of" right is of no real value when you couple it with false prophecy. Camping has predicted and backpedaled two times now and too many have followed with a "que sera sera" attitude. This mentality has led to two large, modern heretical movements gaining too much steam to be quelled. We need to abide by the black and white in the Scripture.

Report Abuse
See All 40 Comments
Use your Christianity Today login to leave a comment on this article.
Not part of the community? Subscribe now, or register for a free account.
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register

Don't Miss

Want to Change the World? Sponsor a Child

Want to Change the World? Sponsor a Child

A top economist shares the astounding news about that little picture hanging on our refrigerator.
Bumbling the Great Commission

Bumbling the Great Commission

Is our discipleship too narrow?

The Sightless, Wordless, Helpless Theologian

The Sightless, Wordless, Helpless Theologian

How our daughter's brief life showed us eternity.

more | current issue

Books & Culture

Our Lives, Our Fortunes, and Our Sacred Honor

Our Lives, Our Fortunes, and Our Sacred ...

The grand debate that...

Today's Christian Woman

The Perfect Wife Scorecard

The Perfect Wife Scorecard

I just knew I was failing...

Small Groups

Silence and Solitude

Silence and Solitude

These spiritual disciplines...

Out of Ur

Superman: Sermon Notes from Exile

Superman: Sermon Notes from Exile

Why I wrote sermon notes...

Facebook

CT eBooks & Bible Studies


Shopping