Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
May 26, 2012

Home > 2012 > January (Web-Only)Christianity Today, January (Web-Only), 2012
Speaking Out
The Business of Religion vs. Jesus
Sorry, but you can't reconstruct a stripped down, organic, anti-corporate version of what you think Jesus should be.




A talented young believer posted a video of himself delivering a poem last week about what's wrong the Church today and the thing has gone crazy-viral. Nearly 15 million views at this point. Quite remarkable.

Obviously, the piece is connecting with people. I would guess that most are connecting positively because they're interested in seeing a better angle on their Christian faith that's different than what they've been seeing. That desire is always good.

My interest is not the thoughts or offering of the young man who posted it. (I do like that it's an offering of discipleship through art, something that has a long and beautiful history in the church.) My interest is the wild response itself.

Why the huge reaction? One can only guess. So I will.

First, I think it is centered in the wonderful, hopeful and youthful idealism that Jesus is about more than what we get from the Christian establishment.

But this is not new. It is what the Reformation was about. It is what's at the center of every new denominational founding. It was seen in the Jesus Movement, from which I came.

It is what Gandhi was saying when he said he would happily become a Christian if he ever met one.

Same with Bono: "Yeah, I'd break bread and wine. If there was a church I could receive in."

It sounds good and aspirational, but it can also be horribly arrogant. It makes very clear who gets it and who doesn't, elevating "us" over "you people." And doing that has always given us a good feeling. In fact, it was exactly what the Pharisees were about.

You see, Jesus' own circle would not satisfy either Gandhi or Bono because imperfection and short-coming are inherent in anything that involves humans. And the church is God's bride made of exactly that: humans who live between the "already" of Christ's saving work and the "not yet" of His full redemption. That's the way it is. Settle in for it until the fullness of time comes.

Now, I know the young man who posted his video poetry is not arrogant. He has a refreshingly humble and teachable heart, as demonstrated in his reaction to and interaction with Kevin DeYoung surrounding Kevin's thoughtful reaction to the post.

But I would surmise that many who have forwarded it to friends and shared it on Facebook have done so as a rage against the machine that happens to be a form of Christianity that they don't care for. It's rock throwing and all generations have done it to varying degrees. We must come to terms that if the question is "What do you think Christianity should be like?" your answer doesn't really matter. Sorry.  It's SO not about you. The question for every Christian is rather: What does our Lord desire?

Yes, the young man in the video is right in spirit, but quite wrong in many of the facts. These shortcomings are expected and somewhat excusable due to his youth, both in age and time following Christ. But his viewers—those who have forwarded the video in the millions—have a larger duty toward discernment.

So let's ask the big question. Does Jesus hate religion? Well, depends on what you're talking about, which this poem never really clarifies.

Jesus' biggest tussle was with the religious leaders of the day. The ones who thought they had God all figured out and confined snugly in their  particular box. In fact, they are the ones that had Him killed. (Matt:26:62-66).

But that's not all there is to the story. Jesus was a good Jewish boy. He went in for all the religious trappings of His faith. I like the way Kevin DeYoung puts it:





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 42 comments

Carlos Ramirez Trevino

February 03, 2012  9:48am

While some rituals are necessary for structure and continuity, isn't replacing trust in the person of Christ with liturgy or a "faith" (set of beliefs and funded rituals) what is causing many to disengage from Christian church fellowship? Isn't it just a little repulsive that the Evangelical Hymn has become "Money makes the world go around!"? Add to that the new-found Evangelical trust in Republicanism, excessive political engagement of Evangelical institutions, and Evangelical rejection of social responsibility in favor of unrestricted Capitalism as exemplified by prosperity gospelleers, and you end up with a reprehensible mixture of "the opium of the people", a "cultural mandate" and an "every man for himself" religious tyranny. In all this, the missing factor is Christ, the person. Evangelicals have committed the sins of the fathers by divorcing themselves from Christ and committing themselves to "Culture". Jesus made it clear to Nicodemus that to enter into the Kingdom of God we must be transformed in mind and disposition. But that is not the work of culture; it is the work of Christ. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if the Evangelical church returned to Christ; the Christ that died to eradicate evil from all creation? Instead the idolatrous and apostate focus is on wealth, prosperity, cultural development, power, and evangelical techniques to populate our churches. Where in the world is Jesus?

Don

January 27, 2012  2:02pm

You made a lot of good points, but, at ' Jesus was a good Jewish boy' you lost me completely. Don't you have a little bit of fear and humility? It is the Son of God you are talking about, and he never stopped being the son of god.

A Hermit

January 24, 2012  6:12pm

Religion is not "business". The greatest sin of our nation now is its service and idolatry (through 'business'), of profit and 'money'. God is a reality (actually not a reality, but Reality) that is infinite (without limited form) and timeless, beyond human intellectual comprehension, poured out through creation. Religion (through its finite, concrete, time bound forms and practices) should serve the purpose of pointing to that reality. But instead of pointing to an incomprehensible mystery, we are prone to the idolatry of wanting something concrete to serve and worship, grasp and understand. Religion itself and religious practices then become the end, rather than a means- the source, rather than the conduit. Then religion and religious forms and practices which are humanly necessary become themselves a problem. As humans grow in understanding, so must religion and religious forms, also change and grow.

john

January 24, 2012  3:59pm

Obviously an organization who benefits from tax-free income would say to enbrace the church or "her" as you said. Jesus may have brought in new rituals but he just as easily did away with formalities by preaching on hills instead of temples, by interacting and speaking to people instead of just preaching from an isolated podium. Maybe an "organic" jesus is what we need. Even as a young person its evident that the established system that is currently in use isn't as effective as it should be. Say what you want but I think its difficult for someone who isn't young to attempt to be an expert on what's reaching the youth.

D Marcum

January 24, 2012  3:24pm

the video to me was needed.....it points out many of Christianity's problems and brings light to bear on them....there will always be the backlash of "no tolerance and self righteous attitude". The truth is presented like a stinging medicine to a stubborn infection...not welcome but needed....

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



War and Peace

War and Peace

Pastor Tullian Tchividjian survived a leadership coup by finding rest in the liberating power of the gospel.

Facing Fears

Facing Fears

Max Lucado employs preaching to overcome fear.

more | current issue

Christian Bible Studies

Unbalanced Blessings

Unbalanced Blessings

The balancing act of...

Books & Culture

Quiet

Quiet

Shhh! Introverts working...

Preaching Today

NFL Star Junior Seau Searched for Peace

Small Groups

Prepare with Prayer

Prepare with Prayer

Don't leave out this...

Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper