“We need to stand together with people of faith.”

A former Canadian federal cabinet minister received a warm round of applause from the studio audience when he flourished this line during a national radio broadcast.

Others who heard him were not so sure. The idea of a moral consensus based on a common religious framework has a long history in a North America, one dominated by Christians who recited the Lord’s Prayer in public schools and insisted on Sunday closings to facilitate Christian worship.

At least since the middle of the last century, this consensus widened (in sympathetic reaction to anti-Semitism both home and abroad that was evident around the time of World War II) to include Jews. “Judeo-Christian” thus emerged in the 1940s as an adjective its users hoped would describe everyone—except die-hard atheists.

“People of faith” more recently took over as an even more general and inclusive phrase that means “people who see the world mostly as we do, at least in broad terms.” With the religiously motivated violence of 9/11 fresh on our minds, however, and in the shadow of religiously motivated persecution around the world, surely we have learned anew not to treat “faith” as ever and always a good thing.

Bad Religion

Sociologist David Martin (among many others) has demonstrated that religion is rarely the main cause of violence. Land, wealth, security, prestige, and vengeance are the perennial motives for war. Yet religion has frequently been deployed as a validation, fuel, and rewarder of violence on the grand scale.

As any friendly neighborhood atheist also will gladly tell you, religion has been used to legitimize sexual abuse, justify financial scams, and bless the oppression of entire classes of people—women, ethnic and sexual minorities, slaves, children, and more.

The Bible has some fierce things to say about alternative religions when they militate against the will, and the people, of God. One might fairly conclude, in fact, that the primary lesson of the entire Old Testament, learned by the people of God only after suffering centuries of oppression, famine, and finally exile, is that “religion” is a bad thing unless it centers on the one, true God. Mere “faith” of any sort cannot possibly be the sole ground for cultural cooperation.

We of Little Faith

The great historian of American Christianity Martin E. Marty has often pointed out that unlike so many other countries, America has not suffered “shooting wars” over religion. He suggests that this enviable record is due in part to the fact that in a complex democracy, alliances shift as the debates change. Yesterday’s idolatrous papist, for instance, becomes today’s Roman Catholic co-belligerent standing with evangelicals against abortion or same-sex marriage. Likewise, yesterday’s appalling secularist becomes today’s ally standing with Christians against the legalization of polygamy or the institution of religious courts among ethnic enclaves, whether Orthodox Jewish tribunals in New York or Shari‘ah courts in London.

Consider that most of the atheists and agnostics in North America are what I call “Christian atheists and agnostics,” shaped by the values of a culture deeply rooted in Christianity.

We can be glad for the many respects in which our values overlap with theirs. Poll after poll shows a general moral consensus about, for example, the illegitimacy and immorality of plural marriage, extra-marital sex, and child marriage, or about freedom of religion, freedom of speech, and the rest of the guarantees of the Bill of Rights (or Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms).

May
Subscribe to CT and get one year free.
From Issue:
Read These Next
Also in this IssueStop Calling Everything a Bible Study
Stop Calling Everything a Bible Study Subscriber Access Only
Why it matters what churches call their classes.
RecommendedPew: Here’s How Badly Soviet Atheism Failed in Europe
Pew: Here’s How Badly Soviet Atheism Failed in Europe
In 18 nations across Central and Eastern Europe, religion is now essential to national identity.
TrendingThe Theology Beneath the Trump-Comey Conflict
The Theology Beneath the Trump-Comey Conflict
How the former FBI director’s interest in Reinhold Niebuhr shaped his approach to political power.
Editor's PickWe Actually Don’t Need a Trinitarian Revival
We Actually Don’t Need a Trinitarian Revival
Attempts to teach a ‘better’ understanding of the Trinity may do more harm than good.
View this article in Reader Mode
Christianity Today
Just Who Are These ‘People of Faith’ Anyway?