Jump directly to the content
Oct 9, 2012

The Rise of the Nones: Some Reflections on the New Pew Forum Data

Today, the Pew Forum released, and USAToday's ever-vigilant Cathy Grossman reported on, another study that I think is helpful for us to understand the context in which we live. In the study, they indicate that the number of Americans with no religious affiliation (identified as the "Nones," as in "none of the above") is climbing.

I had the opportunity to look at the data beforehand, and was not particularly shocked by it, though many will likely trumpet this as a huge shift. It's not. This is simply the natural progression of what is taking place in our context.

A big part of what is happening is that the "Nominals"-- and by that I mean nominal mainliners primarily, but nominal evangelicals as well-- are shifting and becoming the "Nones." This makes sense, as the cultural currency (in other words, the value a society places on identifying as a Christian) is decreasing. And thus, we see a movement away from Christian identity as a cultural value.

I've written on multiple occasions about how the term Christian is used. Most recently I talked about "census Christians" (census Christians are those who, when filling out a form, pick "Christian" rather than "Hindu" or "Jew") and "churchgoing Christians" (churchgoing Christians considering themselves Christians because they occasionally attend a church.) I believe that this move is primarily the result of people who are "census" and "churchgoing Christians" shifting to the category of those who don't have any identification at all-- the Nones.

Furthermore, I don't think this is all bad. As I've discussed on The Exchange (see the entire episode here, as well as a short clip here), there is great opportunity in being able to speak with more definition and clarity about what a Christian is, and is not.

So, should we be alarmed? First, one of the characteristics of faiths like mine is that we tend to see opportunity in everything. Furthermore, being a monotheist, all monotheist faiths tend to see what goes around them either as the blessing of God or in some sense the judgment of God. So in other words, when the people of Israel in the Old Testament saw bad news and were in crisis, they did not believe that there was no God. They simply believed that God was disciplining them. So, in that great tradition, I think that God is teaching us something through this difficulty. I think God has a lesson here for our churches.

As such, I think it's fair to say three things:

First, we continue to lose what some have called our home-field advantage. On a growing basis, identifying oneself as a Christian is not a means to societal advancement but can actually be a means to societal rejection.

Second, the "squishy middle" is collapsing. Nominalism will go its way. I believe the future of Christianity in North America will look more like the present-day Pacific Northwest, as I have explained here.

Third, and finally, it is still a vast overstatement to see this as a collapse of the Christian faith in North America. The reality is that evangelicals have been relatively steady as a percent of the population over the last few years, however there is still great cause for concern here-- and for action.

For me, it is both a concern and an opportunity.

I am concerned that people are moving away from any religious memory that so many churches, particularly seeker churches, could appeal to. In other words, you can't bring the Nones back to church-- they simply don't find it appealing.

I see an opportunity for churches to clearly state what a Christian is, as others are no longer claiming that title as frequently. Furthermore, teaching believers to live on mission in their contexts, rather than just to bring their friends to church, is how we will reach the Nones.

So, as society moves away from Christian identification, let's meet them on the road and say, "We did not believe in that expression of Christianity anyway. Let me tell you about Jesus and how he changes everything."

Related Topics:None
Posted:October 9, 2012 at 12:00 am

Comments

Please read our comment policy before you weigh in, and then feel free to comment on Facebook.

More From This Blog

Saturday Is For Seminars: CAPACITY and AACC Mega National Conference

Saturday Is For Seminars: CAPACITY and AACC Mega National Conference

Join me for a conference in Georgia or Texas, or on a Sunday morning at one of the churches I am preaching at in the coming weeks!
Weekend Edition - August 26, 2016

Weekend Edition - August 26, 2016

Four places of human flourishing, surviving cancer, learning from failure, church signs, and more!
Reconciling Witness And Worship: Six Ways To Begin

Reconciling Witness And Worship: Six Ways To Begin

Imagine a church that considers its’ surrounding ‘neighbors’ and the future majority of our country in developing practices of worship.

Follow Ed Stetzer

Exchange Logo

Dr. John Sorensen, President of Evangelism Explosion International, a ministry that has trained millions of Christians around the world to share Christ, discusses the state of evangelism, research on evangelism trends, as well as myths and methods of evangelism.

Cast: Ed Stetzer

Read ED Stetzer's Books

See All

Follow Christianity Today

Christianity Today
The Rise of the Nones: Some Reflections on the New Pew Forum Data