Jump directly to the content
Jul 13, 2013
Zimmerman Trial

The Verdict Is In... and We All Lost

Sanford Pastor Victor Montalvo Responds to the Zimmerman Trial |
The Verdict Is In... and We All Lost

This case is tragic. A young man is dead. Another man's life is ruined. A city struggling with an undercurrent of racial tension for decades has another gaping wound. We look for answers and all we seem to find are questions … and a whole lot of pain.

Pastoring in Sanford may give me a unique perspective. Or, maybe I'm just another guy witnessing a whirlwind. There is nothing pretty about this case. And it's not just a case. It's a horrific and tragic event that has left a young man dead, two families devastated and wounded not only a city, but also a nation.

No one likes to hear of a 17-year old being shot and killed. Unfortunately, it happens way too often.

The news initially struck the heart of Sanford in a tender place. No one likes to hear of a 17-year old being shot and killed. Unfortunately, it happens way too often. As painful as it was, there was callousness to the news. People paused for a moment and then went on with their lives, until the news came of no arrest. People started getting angry, very angry.

Schisms began to form in the city: white vs. black, pro-gun vs. anti-gun, pro Sanford PD and against. As massive marches and demonstrations took place, outsiders looking for a way into the conversation flooded our city. Entire streets were shut down, businesses were closed, and many feared for their safety. Conversations on Facebook and Twitter escalated the tension. Rumors of impending riots began permeating the city. Everyone had opinions but no one seemed to have facts. A boy was dead and we were mad.

Did the jury make the right call? I just don't know. The reality is that, above all else, this was an extremely complicated situation with both individuals involved operating from a sense of fear. Trayvon feared he was being followed and George feared another home invasion in his neighborhood. Did it all happen the way the trial painted it? We will never know. We can't really know, and that is terribly unsettling.

It's unsettling because we want to close the book. We want answers. Outsiders came looking for a story or looking for a fight. We who live here just want this to be over. We want justice served and the spotlight gone so we can begin to put the pieces of our fractured city together. As long as the nation peered into our little town they sought for one thing: a villain.

As long as the nation peered into our little town they sought for one thing: a villain.

The news, the talking heads, the activists, they just wanted a monster. They wanted someone to blame, someone to hate. They tried to paint George Zimmerman as a hotheaded, racist, wannabe vigilante. If that wasn't sticking they tried painting Trayvon Martin as a reckless, drug-using thug looking for trouble. Both were horribly wrong, but more people watched, and more people seethed.

It reminded me of one of the wide range of responsibilities I have as a father. One particular night, I was called upon to be a "tiger slayer". At three-years old, my daughter saw the Jungle Book and woke up afraid. Apparently, there was a tiger in her closet. In the wee hours of the morning I concluded that trying to explain to her the absence of the tiger would take too long and may not actually work. So, I lied. Well, I pretended. I "found" the tiger, smashed it and drug it out of the room. Afterwards, my daughter slept wonderfully.

Maybe that's what we wanted after all. We wanted a boogeyman in the closet. We wanted a young thug or a racist vigilante. We wanted someone to be evil so we could move on, feeling like there is some sense to this tragedy. Well, that just isn't going to happen. It's never going to happen. Our world just doesn't work that way.

So what do we do? We grieve. We pray. We pray for the Martin family, who is grieving the tragic death of their son. We pray for the Zimmerman family, who will never be the same after this experience. We pray for Sanford, which has a mountain of fear, distrust and racial tension to climb. We pray for our nation, who is still deeply mired in racial distrust. We pray for the Church, that we would be a beacon of hope and a shining example of Christ's desires for our world.

The Church must model the way out of this racial abyss.

The Church must model the way out of this racial abyss. As long as we preach racial tolerance we will get nowhere in remedying the racial divide we have in our churches and in our nation. At Reality Community Church, we preach racial tolerance is a farce.

Contrary to the popular saying, God is not color blind. God is colorful! He made our various differences. The diversity of our young and beautiful community of faith is a testament to this truth. This philosophy is woven throughout our entire church. Our leadership, our preaching, our music, our marketing, our activities, our outreaches and even our food are all celebrations of diversity. We miss God's plan altogether when we settle for racial tolerance. Don't tolerate racial differences—celebrate them!

It's only when our brothers and sisters of differing races sense true love and acceptance that we begin to truly trust one another. The distrust we experience is because of fear and ignorance. We immediately look to blame others for the pain in this world. So we must also pray for ourselves, that we would recognize the cause of the pain of this world and deal with the sin of our hearts that so deeply distorts everything it encounters.

We live in a world full of beauty and pain. When it's beautiful it's like a glimpse of Heaven. When it's painful, it's like the bowels of Hell. When things go awry we want someone to blame. We want to project all of our pain and the foulness of our sin upon someone or something. As long as we look to ourselves this will always be our way. However, there is another way.

We can look to Christ who took upon himself our sin and pain. We don't need a scapegoat because we have a pure and spotless Lamb. This world is pretty messed up, but we have a Savior that catches every tear, comforts every loss, crushes every sin and makes all things brand new.

Related Topics:Crime
Posted:July 13, 2013 at 8:59 pm

Comments

To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register

More From This Blog

Church Signs of the Week: April 18, 2014

Church Signs of the Week: April 18, 2014

Silly Rabbit; Come Hear Our Pastor; House Church
Love Your Neighbor by Carol Pipes

Love Your Neighbor by Carol Pipes

This week on Thursday is for Thinkers, Carol Pipes shares how God's love for us in Christ motivates us to love others.
Morning Roundup 4/17/14

Morning Roundup 4/17/14

Leading in Community; Bart Ehrman's Obsession with Jesus; 10 Key Events in 20th Century Evangelicalism
Saved from Hate: An Interview with Mark Phelps, Son of Westboro Founder Fred Phelps Sr.

Saved from Hate: An Interview with Mark Phelps, Son of Westboro Founder Fred Phelps Sr.

Mark Phelps graciously shared a bit of his story with me over the last couple of weeks.

Follow Ed Stetzer

Exchange Logo

Lecrae discusses Christian labels and if they are helpful, being missional in the music industry, and role of hip hop during this special interview with guest host Eric Geiger on this episode of The Exchange with Ed Stetzer.


Catch The Exchange every Tuesday at 3 p.m. ET EdStetzer.com

Read ED Stetzer's Books

See All

Follow Christianity Today