Devotional Journey—Day 6

Read as Single PagePage 1 of 1

Speaking of work and the workplace, we now have scientific proof that one bad apple can ruin the whole bunch. A recent episode of National Public Radio's "This American Life" featured researcher Will Felps, who identified three types of bad apples (below) when it comes to group dynamics. He hired an actor to play each of the parts below and surreptitiously placed him in motivated small groups working on a business project. After you've been thinking about your work today, see if any of these types sound familiar:

1. The Jerk. This person attacks others and their ideas, but offers no viable solutions. Common phrases might be, "Are you kidding me?" or "Have you taken a business class before?"

2. The Slacker. He or she does as little as possible. When collaborating on a project, they might spend their time text messaging with their feet up, eating a bagged lunch. Their phrase of choice? "Whatever."

3. The Depressive Pessimist. Someone who is negative about every idea. They keep their head down, and look, in Felps' words, as if their cat had died. "This project is dumb anyway, and it will never work."

In theory, the power of group dynamics should overcome the negativity of one member, right? Wrong. Felps' study showed that the groups who were burdened with the bad apple suffered from poor performance ? 30-40% less productivity than the groups without the bum personality. The ultimate result? Team members took on the characteristics of the bad apple, mimicking the jerk behavior, or putting their heads down, always sapping the teams of positive energy. Interpersonal relationships suffered as conflicts arose. They would plod along miserably until the group could officially be pronounced dead with an utterance of these words: "Let's just get this over with."

Contrast this with Paul's words in 1 Corinthians from today's devotional: "I don't just do what is best for me; I do what is best for others so that many may be saved. And you should imitate me, just as I imitate Christ." How does Paul's description of his approach to leadership inspire you, encourage you, or convict you? Do you recognize a little bit of yourself in any of those descriptions? If not, do you know a positive group member you can acknowledge this week? Do you view your work as a sacred trust, or just something to get over with?

January 10, 2009 at 12:01 AM

Recent Posts

Troublesome Women Preachers
We join a long legacy of prophetic witness to the gospel.
Pastor or Director: Does Title Matter?
An honest look at what our titles communicate
Leadership Without a Title
We can learn from the influential life of Sarah Edwards.
Communicate to Both Women and Men
Should we change our delivery so we’ll be heard?

Follow us


Most Popular Posts

Troublesome Women PreachersIdeas for Women's MinistryDoes the Bible Really Say I Can’t Teach Men?Pastor or Director: Does Title Matter?