Jump directly to the content

Nine 'Manipulated' Bishops Agree Not To Help Breakaway Episcopalian Congregations

Conservative-leaning leaders unhappily 'express regret' but don't admit wrongdoing.

(RNS) The Episcopal Church has a new commandment for its bishops: Thou shalt not assist former Episcopalians who are trying to take the church's assets.

Church leaders have reached an agreement with nine bishops who had supported breakaway congregations in Texas and Illinois court cases. Courts have been sorting out who controls properties and other assets when congregations leave the denomination.

Under the terms, the nine bishops "express regret for any harm" to the Dioceses of Quincy (Ill.) and Fort Worth (Texas) as a result of their actions, which included filing amicus briefs that were sympathetic with the breakaway groups.

The bishops also pledged to stop supporting breakaway groups in court cases, at least until the church's General Convention addresses the matter in 2015. They also agree to help defray costs incurred by the church in reaching the accord.

The accord is billed as an outcome of "conciliation," which is a step in the church disciplinary process. But tensions remain unresolved.

Conciliation "doesn't achieve full reconciliation," said Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori. "It is a step in that direction."

The Episcopal Church has lost hundreds of congregations over the past decade as conservatives left in protest of new blessings for gay bishops and same-sex couples, among other issues. As congregations have departed and ensuing property disputes have landed in court, bishops from dioceses that are not involved in the litigation have sometimes weighed in to help interpret church rules and organizational structures.

The bishops who signed the accord did not admit to any misconduct or wrongdoing, according to a recent blog post by Bishop Daniel Martins of Springfield, Ill. Nor are the named bishops content with the disciplinary process.

"All nine of us are processing some degree of anger and are feeling substantially alienated from those who brought the charges against us," he wrote. "We feel manipulated and victimized. We are nowhere near happy about this outcome, even though we stand by our decision to accept the Accord."

Church leaders were briefed on the accord during the House of Bishops' recent meeting in North Carolina. They received the report with minimal questions and didn't focus on it during the retreat, according to Bishop Todd Ousley of Eastern Michigan.

Signatories to the accord, meanwhile, have no plans to reconsider what they've told the courts.

"We have made our point about the polity of our church in Texas and Illinois courts. Those points are now matters of public record," Martins said in his March 10 blog post. "There is no more reason for us to intervene as we did to protect the truth about (the Episcopal Church's) polity and interests of our own dioceses."

The nine bishops named in the accord were:

Bishop John W. Howe (retired, Diocese of Central Florida)

Suffragan Bishop Paul E. Lambert (Diocese of Dallas)

Bishop William H. Love (Diocese of Albany)

Bishop D. Bruce MacPherson (retired, Diocese of Western Louisiana)

Bishop Daniel H. Martins (Diocese of Springfield, Ill.)

Bishop James M. Stanton (Diocese of Dallas)

Bishop Maurice M. Benitez (retired, Diocese of Texas)

Bishop Peter Beckwith (retired, Diocese of Springfield, Ill.)

Bishop Edward L. Salmon (retired, Diocese of South Carolina)

Related Topics:None
Posted:March 22, 2013 at 11:12AM
Gleanings aggregates what others are reporting. Learn more.

Leave a Comment

Use your Christianity Today login to leave a comment on this article.
Not part of the community? Subscribe now, or .
Recent Posts
Mosul's Last Christians Flee Iraq's Hoped-For Christian Stronghold
Historic community comes to 'a real end' after ISIS ultimatum tells Christians to convert, pay tax, or die.
China May Free Gao Zhisheng, Christian lawyer, on Aug. 7
More than 151,000 signed petition for his release.
New Movies to Highlight Friendship Between Creators of Narnia and Middle Earth
As Hollywood works its way through dramatizing the fantasy novels, several hope to tell a more historical tale of real-world friendship.
Muslim Sues Kenya's Catholic Bishops for Discrimination
Bishops sued as they lobby for peace amidst coastal violence.
Christianity Today
Nine 'Manipulated' Bishops Agree Not To Help Breakaway Episcopalian ...