Sign up for our free newsletter:

THE AMERICAN EVANGELICAL STORY: The History of the Movement by Douglas A. Sweeney Baker Academic, 208 pp.; $17.99

Martin Luther King Jr.'s 1963 "Letter from Birmingham Jail" still jolts the church today. "I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro's great stumbling block in his stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen's Counciler or the Ku Klux Klanner," King wrote, "but the white moderate, who is more devoted to 'order' than to justice. … Shallow understanding from people of good will is more frustrating than absolute misunderstanding from people of ill will."

No doubt King targeted many good white Christians with his damning critique. Shared faith could not overcome social conventions like segregation. Ever since white Baptists faithfully preached the gospel among black slaves, spiritual unity has mostly eluded the races in America. Even those first efforts were often tainted. Many slave owners worried that spiritual liberation would encourage slaves to pursue economic freedom. To reassure the owners, some evangelists made an unfortunate promise: The gospel they preached would not promote social change. Yet while many 19th-century evangelicals condoned slavery, other evangelicals led the way in treating slaves as spiritual equals.

Douglas Sweeney, associate professor of church history and the history of Christian thought at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, hopes that a better understanding of history can cause today's mostly white evangelical movement to confront the sins of its past and soothe the divide between black and white evangelicals. Race relations is only one of many topics covered in his short primer to evangelical history, The American Evangelical Story: A History of the Movement (Baker Academic, 2005). In addition to challenging his readers, he seeks to encourage them with stories of repentance, sacrifice, and courage. As he explains in his preface, "My hope and prayer for the chapters that follow is that they … might be a memorial, a compilation of stones selected from the riverbed of our history that testify to God's faithfulness among us."

From "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God" to praise songs
Sweeney's first chapter takes a stab at defining evangelicalism and concludes, "Evangelicals are a movement of orthodox Protestants with an 18th-century twist." Sweeney then starts his story with that twist, which suits his expertise in colonial American history, particularly Jonathan Edwards. He explains how the Great Awakening paved the way for an evangelical movement: "This was certainly not the first time the church had seen revival, but it was the first time that Protestants worked so well together; transcending their narrower, ethnic, regional, and denominational interests for the sake of cooperation in mission."

But when evangelicalism began reaching out from its American context, Sweeney argues that the movement lost some of its integrity in translation: "Many patriotic Christians who loved the American way of life-and who prided themselves on the blessings of their nation's 'righteous empire'-often neglected the crucial task of distinguishing biblical Christianity from the rest of American culture."

No matter the era, evangelicalism has always imbibed some of American culture. Sweeney extends his survey to the contemporary era, where he explains trends that include the "mainstreaming" of charismatics and Pentecostals. He touches on groups like Calvary Chapel and Vineyard and shows how casual dressing and pop music eventually claimed a significant following among noncharismatic evangelicals.

Of course, no survey of evangelical history would be complete without a strong dose of the fundamentalist/modernist debates of the early 20th century. But Sweeney believes that evangelicals can no longer achieve unity by defining themselves against the extremes of fundamentalism or theological liberalism, as the neoevangelicals did. "In our own day, when most evangelical scientists support a form of theistic evolution and most evangelical Bible scholars practice higher criticism," Sweeney writes, "it may be difficult to imagine the fears of those who bucked these trends."

Looking ahead
Sweeney clearly aims The American Evangelical Story toward college and seminary students who need a quick primer in evangelical history. Knowing theology outpaces history at most seminaries, Sweeney assumes some doctrinal fluency on the part of his readers, such as a basic knowledge of competing eschatological viewpoints.

The suggestions for further reading direct interested students toward other valuable resources. In one such note Sweeney calls Mark Noll's American Evangelical Christianity: An Introduction the "best scholarly survey of American evangelical history" and praises Noll's attention to politics, science, and culture. Perhaps this is why Sweeney reserves only one footnote for significant political developments from the last 25 years.

As a proud evangelical worried that the movement will fragment along secondary theological lines, Sweeney writes not only to inform readers about the past but also to speak to today's historical moment. He scolds some Calvinists for caring more about their own theological distinctives than evangelical cooperation. He chides evangelicals for not building enduring institutions and for neglecting black and Pentecostal believers.

"Many despair over the likelihood of bringing evangelicals together, projecting a bear market for evangelical futures," he concludes. "Some analysts are calling for a major disinvestment. And the founding neoevangelical leaders are passing away. The question remains whether others will arise to take their place, finding a way to choreograph this massive, motley Christian movement without requiring its members (futilely) to march in single file." According to Sweeney, confronting the sins of our past and rejoicing in God's faithfulness over time can grant us incalculable wisdom and courage to face the next challenges.

Collin Hansen is an associate editor of Christianity Today.

				Subscribe to Christian History & Biography Free! Name Street Address City/State/Zip E-mail Address No credit card required. Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only. Click here for International orders. If you decide you want to keep Christian History & Biography coming, honor your invoice for just $24.95 and receive three more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The trial issue is yours to keep, regardless. Give a gift subscription | Buy past issues

FREE Newsletter Sign up for Christian History & Biography's e-mail newsletter. Come backstage and meet the historical Christians whose experiences and insights stand behind the limelight of today's news stories.    RSS Feed   RSS Help