Jump directly to the content

Already a subscriber?

Home > Issues > 2006 > Summer > Cookie Cutter Community

FirstPreviousPage 2 of 4NextLast

Setting the charges

"We had an encounter with God that just stopped us," Carlson says. God seemed to challenge the Oak Hills leaders on two points: the products of their existing philosophy and a call to spiritual formation.

"Christian leaders have to admit this is the system we have put together. We can't build churches that advertise 'tons of ministries to meet your needs,' then be surprised when people expect us to continually meet their needs," Carlson says.

Lorraine Rothenburg, one of the leadership team, says with its seeker focus, Oak Hills had always worked on the front half of their mission statement: to reach the non-churched. "Our goal was to get nonchurched people into our seeker service; we believed God would reach them there. But we had not done a good job on the back half of the mission statement, which was to develop them into fully devoted followers of Christ," she says.

In the discussions about developing mature believers, the nature of spiritual formation arose. Mike Lueken, associate pastor for spiritual formation and now Oak Hills's co-senior pastor along with Carlson, had classes with Dallas Willard, the author and philosopher and formation guru for Protestants.

Lueken brought Willard's concepts about the kingdom of God to the table. They met a receptive audience. "It seemed to us that some of the things that it takes to keep a large church going are the very things people have to unlearn in order to go further in their life with Christ. For example, worship is not about the thrill I get, but whether I've given an offering of praise that's worthy to God."
Thus began the dismantling of Oak Hills.

The seeker-oriented service was cancelled, and the mid-week believer-oriented service was moved to the weekend. Energies and monies that had been poured into worship productions worthy of watercooler talk on Mondays were redirected to less public activities, with the goal of deepening the spiritual lives of believers.

And the zesty, enthusiastic services suddenly included quieter elements characteristic of the spiritual disciplines crowd.

"In the process, we changed the contract with the congregation," Carlson says. "Some responded, 'Well, it took you 16 years to decide you're going to center the church around Jesus; it's about time."'

Others left.

More than a thousand. Over six years, attendance dropped from 1,800 to 800; in the churn as many as 1,500 who once called Oak Hills home departed for churches offering more traditional programming and worship services. Today, Oak Hills is, almost completely, a new church.

Through the transition described by insiders and observers alike as "bloody,""painful," and "a battle," the leadership team, both staff and elders, stuck to their calling.

FirstPreviousPage 2 of 4NextLast

From Issue:iChurch, Summer 2006 | Posted: January 9, 2012

Also in this Issue: Summer 2006

Dangerous BlessingsSubscriber Access Only

A theology of God's abundance and our hunger for more.

House Churches that Complement "Big Church"Subscriber Access Only

They don't have to compete when their purpose is aligned.
Redeeming a Needy Neighborhood

Redeeming a Needy NeighborhoodSubscriber Access Only

Not all communities have too much. How one church brings the gospel to the economically distressed.

Not a Subscriber?

Subscribe Today!

  • Monthly issues on web and iPad
  • Web exclusives and archives on Leadership Journal.net
  • Quarterly print issues

Print subscriber? Activate your online account for complete access.

Join the Conversation

Average User Rating:

Displaying 2–3 of 3 comments


April 10, 2012  4:25pm

I wish I could find a church like that in my area.

Report Abuse

Pete Bristow

February 19, 2012  7:36pm

this is just what we need to hear. We're a few months into a new leadership structure and talking seriously about what comes next. With a concern to reach families some would like us to try the Seeker-Sensitive approach, others are aware of the rather publicly stated flaws in that style. I've sent the link to this article to my elders to review and pray over. Thanks for the good work.

Report Abuse
Use your Leadership Journal login to easily comment and rate this article.
Not part of the community? Subscribe, or on public pages, register for a free account.
Reader's Pick
The Painful Lessons of Mars Hill

The Painful Lessons of Mars Hill

What can we learn from the collapse of Mark Driscoll's church?
Sister Sites