Jump directly to the content

Already a subscriber?

Home > Issues > 2008 > Summer > Body Politic

Is the church distracted from its mission by seeking to influence politics? Or has it not been engaged enough? Three leaders, from three generations, debate the role church leaders should play.

Homespun wisdom says that neither religion nor politics should be discussed in polite company. But what about religion and politics? This incendiary mix was the focus of a three-way discussion at the most recent National Pastors Convention in San Diego. While the conversation was polite, the panelist's divergent perspectives made for an at times tense engagement.

Seeing Charles Colson, Greg Boyd, and Shane Claiborne together (p. 21) illustrates their differing positions on faith and politics. Colson, in coat and tie, is a model of establishment propriety. Boyd, in blue jeans and a blazer, is informally relevant. Claiborne, in frayed dungarees and dreadlocks, places himself on the social margins.

Here are excerpts from their conversation, moderated by Krista Tippett, host of "Speaking of Faith," a program produced by American Public Media and broadcast on National Public Radio.

* * *

Chuck Colson: The cover of Newsweek called 1976 "The Year of the Evangelical." The evangelical vote was actually decisive for Jimmy Carter in that election. Christians had been in the fundamentalist hinterlands through most of the twentieth century. They stayed out of the political limelight. They didn't want to contaminate themselves, which was wrong. I don't think you can leave your moral convictions behind when you enter the voting booth. It was the abortion issue among other things that suddenly riveted the attention of Christians onto the public arena.

But things dramatically changed from '76 through the mid-eighties. I think now we're maturing. I think we've gotten out of that adolescent stage of being a power bloc or a special interest group. We're taking a much more sophisticated look at what it means to be a Christian in public life today.

* * *

Greg Boyd: In the early nineties, I went to a megachurch celebration on the Fourth of July. They sang patriotic songs. They displayed a cross and a flag together, and then they showed a video with patriotic music and a military general describing how God had given the U.S. the victory in the first Gulf War. At the end, four fighter jets in formation flew over three crosses. It freeze framed there and "God Bless America" appeared. The crowd stood up and cheered. I started crying. Then before the 2004 election, I was getting an unprecedented amount of pressure, as I think most pastors of large churches were, to steer the flock in a certain way politically. So I did a six-part sermon series called "The Cross and the Sword."

Wilberforce was fighting slavery in Parliament at the same time he was writing books about spiritual renewal and holiness.

I explained that Christians are not here to rally around America or any other country; we're to rally around the kingdom of God. I told them why we're not to jump on a political bandwagon. Good, honest, and Bible believing people can have the same values but translate them into politics in different ways. Our job is to focus on living out the kingdom. That's our one bull's eye, our one duty to God. And we should let the politics take care of itself. Some people were absolutely aghast. About a thousand people left the church, about 20 percent.

PreviousFirstPage 1 of 6NextLast

From Issue:Render Unto... Election Year Ministry, Summer 2008 | Posted: September 19, 2008

Also in this Issue: Summer 2008

One King's Money, Another King's Men

How churches can collaborate with local government agencies to serve the purposes of God's Kingdom.

Betty's Secret IngredientSubscriber Access Only

Is magnanimity the reputation of your church?

Loving SalinasSubscriber Access Only

Putting church members to work to rejuvenate a community.

Getting Men into ChurchSubscriber Access Only

Insight from "How Women Can Help Men Find God"

Subscribe to read more

Subscribe Today!

  • Monthly issues on web and iPad
  • Web exclusives and archives on Leadership Journal.net
  • Quarterly print issues

Print subscriber? Activate your online account for complete access.

Join the Conversation

Average User Rating: Not rated

No comments

Use your Leadership Journal login to easily comment and rate this article.
Not part of the community? Subscribe, or on public pages, register for a free account.
Reader's Pick
The Painful Lessons of Mars Hill

The Painful Lessons of Mars Hill

What can we learn from the collapse of Mark Driscoll's church?
Sister Sites