See what's coming soon! Coming in October »

Jump directly to the content
magcover

Already a subscriber?

Home > 2013 > August Online Only > Can You Drink This Cup?

When I was nine years old, a missionary visiting our gray Foursquare church put his hand on my head and loudly prophesied that I would become a church leader. I would, he said in a voice that filled the foyer, rise to face the church's "leadership crisis," and grow up to cross oceans, leading many sheep into the fold of God.

I don't remember much more than that (I was young, probably squirming awkwardly in one of my favorite grubby turtlenecks), but those words stuck with me.

Leadership crisis. I didn't understand what he meant, but it sounded like a problem. And I, according to this man from across the sea, was going to be part of the solution.

Break down

Today, I don't know what the heck to think of his words. But I came across them again a little while back.

A new survey from Barna (referenced in "A Missing Link in Christian Leadership") finds that 58 percent of Christians in America identify themselves as leaders, but 82 percent of the same survey's participants believe that the United States is facing a "leadership crisis." What do they think is the problem? Not enough leaders.

Let that steep for a second.

Out of a church made up of 1,000 of these Christians, 580 would describe themselves as leaders. Followers are a bald minority in this hypothetical congregation, where 160 of the leaders will have to double up just to share a single follower. What do Sunday mornings look like there? Do they put the pews on stage?

I'm usually skeptical when people pull the "crisis" card. In my view, crises are mighty hard to spot until you're 5 or 50 years past them. But in this case, I think I agree. If Barna's survey stands true for the wider church, then we do indeed have a crisis of leadership. A bad one. But not the one we think.

There could be a number of reasons for the break down in our collective understanding of ourselves and the leadership landscape of the American church. I think the problem is one of perception. En masse, we have swallowed two indigestible misunderstandings. One is sociological—we've misidentified leadership as influence. The other is theological—we have largely missed the "Christ" part of Christian leadership.

We're conflicted and self-deceived. As a result we sense the gap in leadership, painting it as a crisis of numbers, when the root problem is more pernicious.

One-way equation

In a sentence sadly destined to become cliché, John Maxwell said this:

"Leadership is influence: nothing more, nothing less."

He's basically right. Leadership distilled is influence. But in our present culture, we often make a fatal swap. While leadership might equal influence, influence does not equal leadership. It's a one-way equation.

All leadership is influence. Not all influence is leadership. Advertising influences me. It doesn't lead me. If I get thirsty when I see your beer commercial, you may have influenced me. But that doesn't make you a leader.

PreviousFirstPage 1 of 5NextLast

Paul J. Pastor is associate editor of Leadership Journal.

Posted: August 12, 2013

Not a Subscriber?

Subscribe Today!

  • Monthly issues on web and iPad
  • Web exclusives and archives on Leadership Journal.net
  • Quarterly print issues

Print subscriber? Activate your online account for complete access.

Join the Conversation

Average User Rating:

Displaying 1–3 of 3 comments

Richard Pheasant

August 23, 2013  4:53am

"No, not enough leaders like Jesus." Perhaps even not enough leaders who know Jesus. Leadership is about setting the direction (objective, goal, destination) and persuading (influencing) followers (not a great word, but we have no word in English for someone who is led) to walk with you. But for the Christian leader, who sets the direction? That has to be Jesus through His Holy Spirit. So the Christian leaders is first a true servant and follower of Christ, listening to where the Holy Spirit is telling him or her the direction / destination to go. Once the Christian leader is sure he or she has heard from Jesus, then leadership involves persuading and influencing your congregation of fellow workers to go with you. If they are listening to the Holy Spirit, then that should become easier because it should be the same as you have heard. Therefore having a church or ministry where people put and listen to Jesus first should be our challenge and first focus. That, in itself, is a challenge!

Report Abuse

Brint Keyes

August 21, 2013  7:38pm

Amen. A good word, brother.

Report Abuse

Mark Carabas

August 13, 2013  8:11am

"We're conflicted and self-deceived. As a result we sense the gap in leadership, painting it as a crisis of numbers, when the root problem is more pernicious." Self deceived indeed. My question is though, as leaders are we especially prone to self deception?

Report Abuse
Use your Leadership Journal login to easily comment and rate this article.
Not part of the community? Subscribe, or on public pages, register for a free account.
Editor's Pick
Serving Immigrants Saved Our Church

Serving Immigrants Saved Our Church

How welcoming in the stranger revived a declining congregation.
Sister Sites