/lyris/music/archives/01-30-2008.htmlIf this page is not displaying correctly, please click here

ChristianityToday.com
ChristianMusicToday.comChristianMusicTodayRadio.com 
Keeping You in Tune with Today's Music
Wednesday, January 30, 2008


 The Idol Lie

This past weekend I was finally able to catch up on the new episodes of American Idol—six hours in less than three hours time, thanks to fast-forwarding through all the commercials. Though it's already shaping up to be an intriguing competition this season, it's still too early to tell. After all, the show is still in its sideshow phase.

Sigh … the sideshow. It's one of the saddest things to watch. I'm certainly not speaking about the talented contestants who give it their best shot; they know enough about responding rationally to success or failure from a tryout. And the jokers who show up dressed like Princess Leia singing the Pussycat Dolls? Well, they're just begging to be mocked on national television; I say give them what they want.

No, my heart weeps for the other kind of misfit—the ones who don't know any better, consumed by the idea of becoming the next Cinderella-story superstar. These are the ones who audition without a clue that they've no sense of pitch or performance skills. They walk in yearning to become a "somebody," dreaming of leaving their lonely existence behind, only to walk out feeling like a "nobody." Their unrealistic dreams are dashed by reality.

Some quick math. Each season features six cities with approximately 8,000 to 10,000 auditioning in each. Of all those, less than 200 are chosen to go to Hollywood. From there, it whittles down to 12 finalists, and then one—and only one—is declared champion. The odds of winning aren't great.

Take it even further: How many American Idol winners/finalists are enjoying successful careers today? Just a couple of weeks ago, two champions (Taylor Hicks and Ruben Studdard) and one second-place finalist (Katharine McPhee) were dropped from their record labels due to disappointing album sales. After six seasons, I count just a handful of winners and finalists who still matter today. Let's face it—as entertaining as the show is, not many lives are radically changed by it.

Yet how many tone-deaf contestants continue to walk in with delusional dreams? The thing is, it's not just Idol. Even in my own little world, I can't tell you how many e-mails I receive from people dying to change their lives and become Christian recording artists. Several have even sought me out personally, begging me to listen to their demo and give it a positive review (as if that's a guarantee for success).

It isn't wrong to have hopes and dreams, but too many put their hope in the wrong place. How do we know we've put our hopes in the right place? By the affirmation of others who admire our work, and by continuing that good work … even if it never leads to stardom. And it's really all about having a humble heart driven by passion, perseverance, and a desire to serve others with the best of our God-given abilities. Anything less than that is, well, just another sad sideshow.

Our site this week features an interview with Ryan Clark of hardcore metal band Demon Hunter, explaining what they're all about and why Christian heavy metal is not a paradox. We've also got a new edition of The DVD Experience, with info on recent videos from Switchfoot, MercyMe, Red, Marvin Sapp, David Phelps, Myron Butler, and more. Reviews this week include gospel from The Blind Boys of Alabama and The Brooklyn Tabernacle Choir; solo projects from long-in-hiding Sarah MacIntosh (Chasing Furies) and Jesse Butterworth (Daily Planet); and a new worship series from the Portland-based Generation Unleashed youth conferences.

God bless,
Russ Breimeier
Russ Breimeier
ChristianityToday.com

To reply to this newsletter: music@christianitytoday.com


advertisement
Click HerePeople of Faith—Stories of Hope

Be inspired as you read about everyday people living out their faith in today's world. Request a FREE trial issue today!

 This Week's Reviews

Down in New OrleansThe Blind Boys of Alabama
Down in New Orleans (Time-Life)
New Orleans-styled gospel

I'll Say YesBrooklyn Tabernacle Choir
I'll Say Yes (Integrity)
Contemporary gospel

The Waiters, The Watchers …Sarah MacIntosh
The Waiters, The Watchers … (Horizon Music)
Alternative pop/rock

Illuminate - LiveJesse Butterworth
Illuminate - Live (Overlake Christian Church)
Contemporary/modern worship

Generation UnleashedGeneration Unleashed
Generation Unleashed (Maranatha! Music)
Modern worship

| more reviews |

 New Features

Not a Safe Band
That's what lead vocalist Ryan Clark says about his band Demon Hunter—but in reference to their gospel message and varied influences, not their heavy metal persona.


The DVD Experience (Winter 2008)
A look at recent concert video releases from the likes of Switchfoot, Myron Butler, Red, David Phelps, MercyMe, and Marvin Sapp.


The Scoop
Prodigal Michael English Comes Home; gospel greats unite for Grammy performance; news on the next Passion album; and more.


 Recent Features

Catching Up With … Kathryn Scott
The Irish singer/songwriter discusses the role that mentoring has played in shaping her artistry and outlook as a worship leader.


The Scoop
Salem Publishing discontinues CCM Magazine; Leigh Nash says Sixpence None the Richer will reunite; Third Day to play for troops in Persian Gulf; and more.


 Good Buys

Good BuyAnother Time, Another Place, CD
Avalon's harmony-rich renditions of favorites like "For the Sake of the Call," "El Shaddai," "Basics of Life," "People Need the Lord," "Testify to Love," and more.
Good BuyPeace Like a River, CD
Chris Rice returns to his roots in this collection of favorite hymns. Savor the timeless beauty of "It Is Well With My Soul" and "O Love That Will Not Let Me Go."
Good BuyThe Triptych, Special Edition CD/DVD
Enjoy the metallic energy of the chart-topping Demon Hunter album, dynamic footage of a live show in L.A., behind-the-scenes documentaries, bonus songs, and more.
Good BuyLive From Portland, CD/DVD
This adrenaline-charged concert features Kutless classics and songs from their release Hearts of the Innocent, including "Better Is One Day," "Troubled Heart," and "Run."

In Association with Christianbook.com
Search: 
Explore the Music Channel
Artists | Reviews | Interviews | Praise & Worship |
Music Store | Upcoming Releases




Christian Music Today Newsletter
Delivered free via e-mail to subscribers each week. We encourage you to distribute this newsletter freely and ask only that you not change its contents.

Copyright © Wednesday, January 30, 2008 ChristianityToday.com, Christianity Today International
465 Gundersen Drive, Carol Stream, IL 60188
All rights reserved.



Click Here

https://w1.buysub.com/servlet/OrdersGateway?cds_mag_code=LIF&cds_page_id=29674&cds_response_key=I9NC11Ignite Your Faith
Subscribe Now!
SAVE 44%

Get a Free Trial Issue

Give a Gift Subscription

Manage My Subscription



Click Here
Click Here


 Ready-to-Download Bible Study

Buy NowTake Care of the Earth
Use this guide to explore what it means to respect God's creation, and to understand and enact our responsibility as Christians to protect our planet.
—from ChristianBibleStudies.com

Click here to order a copy for yourself, your small group, or your Sunday school class.

» New Bible Studies from
   ChristianBibleStudies.com

 Recent Reviews
Margaret Becker
Air

Twila Paris
Small Sacrifice

Number One Gun
The North Pole Project

Olivia the Band
Where We Come From It Never Snows

The Glorious Unseen
Tonight the Stars Speak

J.R.
Life By Stereo

Noelle Garcia
Meet Me Where I Am

 Other Features
Hosanna, Montana!
Kids and critics are singing the praises of Hannah Montana, starring Billy Ray Cyrus and his teen daughter Miley. Here's how they keep faith, family, and fame in perspective.

Return of the Singer
The oft misunderstood Kevin Max has mellowed his artistic persona, focusing on his new life as a husband and father, as well as expressing his love of gospel music on The Blood.

Michael McDermott
The troubadour's latest project is a musical testimony of his continual struggles with temptation and the faith that sustains him through dark times.

  Updated Artist Pages
Kathryn Scott

Twila Paris

Matthew West

Go Fish

  Coming Next Week …
Edison Glass

Andy Gullahorn

How Great Thou Art

Passion

Jonathan Nelson
 This Week's Poll
Do you believe Christian music and heavy metal are incompatible?
  • Yes, heavy metal's dark/angry sound is incompatible with the Good News.
  • Yes, heavy metal is the Devil's music.
  • No, heavy metal is no less compatible than any other genre.
  • No, heavy metal is perfect for expressing a soul's heart cry to the Lord.
  • I'm indifferent because I'm not a fan.
Vote here, and see how your answer compares to others'.

 Results of Last Poll
What's your response to the news that CCM Magazine is shutting down?
  • I'll miss it because it's got a lot of history to it: 35%
  • I'm indifferent, since I rarely/never kept up with the publication: 25%
  • I'll miss it as my primary source for Christian music news: 23%
  • I won't mind because the magazine has disappointed me in recent years: 15%
 Also @ ChristianityToday.com

http://blog.preachingtoday.com/Iron Sharpens Iron!
Pastors, join your peers on the Preaching Today Blog.