COMMENTARY
A Mountain of Replies
We received a huge response from readers to our review of Brokeback Mountain, the controversial new Ang Lee film depicting a gay relationship between cowboys.
Christine Hawkins | posted 12/20/2005
 1 of 4
Our review of Brokeback Mountain, a film depicting a gay relationship between cowboys, prompted an avalanche of responses from readers. In our weekly newsletter, we asked readers whether they thought we should review such films in the first place, despite the controversial subject matter. Most of the more than 100 readers who replied said yes, we should review such films because it helps them make informed decisions about what movies to watch. But many readers also said no, for various reasons. And some took us to task for giving Brokeback 3 stars, despite our clear explanation that a high rating does not constitute an endorsement or a recommendation—of either the film itself or the lifestyle depicted therein.
We've compiled some of those reader responses, which represent quite a wide spectrum of attitudes and sensitivities concerning film reviews and homosexuality—and a Christian response to both.
I think you should review movies like this. Be in this world, not of it, right? In order to be in this world, we need help to navigate it successfully and to steer clear of potholes. Thanks for keeping us informed.
No, I don't think you should review it. I don't want you or anyone else exposed to graphic sexuality, homo or otherwise. I think you should just "black flag" it and let the perverts have it to themselves.
You should definitely review movies that are receiving high critical acclaim and attention. I depend on your reviews to give me guidance in deciding whether or not to see a movie. Even if I know I will not see it, I value the review given from a Christian perspective to help me understand more what the movie is about and how to discuss it with others.
You shouldn't review such films. To devote so much attention to it participates in the titillation, the hype and worse. You may in fact be guilty in part of promoting it for some simply because of the attention and the manner in which it is done.
The film is gay propaganda. It promotes adultery and a sinful lifestyle making it worthwhile for their mutual pleasure. Movies like this should be labeled by the filmmaker with a disclaimer of not endorsing these activities. You should not do any less in your movie review.
Your review was thoughtful, respectful, and yet true to God's Word in its discussion questions and disclaimer. After reading about a pastor who protests at gay people's funerals with signs that read "God hates fags," I realized how a thoughtful, loving approach is so crucial to reflecting both the love and truth of Christ. Thank you for doing so with your review.
Yes, you should review it, but it shouldn't warrant anything close to 3 stars, because its content is despicable,and is a clear, ideologically inspired attempt to drag the culture down even further. CT readers want a different perspective.
I think it is responsible and necessary for Christian publications to review all films—no matter what they depict. Christians are called to be light in the darkness. If we don't know what we are fighting, we can't effectively go to the places or speak logically/rationally about the darkness we are trying to overcome. If we speak out against something without understanding about what we are speaking of, we come off as brainwashed and unable to think for ourselves.
Browse More Movies
CT Movies Home Page | Now Showing | New on Video | All Reviews
Coming Soon | Discussion Guides | Interviews | Commentary
News & Misc. | Special Sections | About Us
Your Feedback | About Us | CT Mag Home Page
| |
|
Printer view
