How familiar are you with the show Jon & Kate Plus Eight?

Take our poll

Search by Name
 

Or use:
advanced search to search by major, region, cost, affiliation, enrollment, & more!

 1 of 2

The One Who Got Away
Saying good-bye to Mr. Close Enough was one of the hardest things I've ever done.

ADVERTISEMENT

Four years ago, I suffered the worst heartbreak of my life. I'd been dating Andrew off and on for three years, and I knew we needed either to move forward in our relationship, or move on. Despite the fact I'd met him at church on Valentine's Day, that he made me laugh and feel beautiful, that he loved God and his family, I still felt uncertain about moving toward marriage with this terrific guy.

I asked married friends what they felt before they got hitched. They all responded with some rendition of "I just knew he was the one," a feeling conspicuously absent in all my thinking and overanalyzing. I even met with a Christian counselor, who confirmed I wasn't a commitment-phobe. I prayed—no, pleaded—with God for direction. And when I was met with silence and a lack of peace for months on end, I slowly, excruciatingly let this relationship go.

Without a tangible reason for the breakup, it's been easy for me to question the wisdom of my decision over the past four years. There were no "irreconcilable differences" or "I want kids and he doesn't"-type issues to blame, only a vague sense that God said no. I've alternated between seasons of peace (which, thankfully, have grown longer over the years) and seasons of waning trust in God's grand plan. I haven't been obsessing, just wondering what to do with that nagging question mark in the back of my mind: Was that really your leading, God?

I was on a shopping excursion with my roommate last summer when I saw Andrew across a trendy furniture store. There was a woman with him. Even though I hadn't seen Andrew in more than two years, I failed to muster the courage to walk over and say hello.

Later, kicking myself for being such a chicken, I chatted with God about this "chance" encounter. Were you wanting us to get back in contact, God? Was it just bad timing before? The "what ifs" crept in big time, and I prayed once again for peace and direction. In the four years since the breakup, I could count on one hand the number of guys I'd dated. When I'd let Andrew go, I'd secretly assumed there would be someone even better waiting around the next corner. When that didn't prove true, I began to doubt my decision—and God's apparent leading.

I remember telling God it would almost be a relief to know the woman in the furniture store with Andrew was his wife. It would put the maddening questions to rest once and for all.

Well, about a month ago, I had another "chance" encounter, this time with a woman from my Bible study. We were chatting about work when she casually mentioned she knew Andrew. She'd even dated him briefly. She still saw him on occasion at work and knew he'd just gotten married a few weeks before.

I stood there in stunned silence, an odd mixture of grief and peace washing over me. It was the clarity of a closed door and the loneliness of an empty horizon all at once. And I stood amazed at the way God had orchestrated this answer to my prayer. While it wasn't a confirmation that the past decision to let Andrew go was absolutely God's will, it was a peace with which to look to the future. And, I've learned, sometimes that's all we can hope for.

next page... |  1 of 2


 E-mail this page   Print this article   Post a comment



Related Topics
Direction, Holy Spirit, leading, Marriage, Peace, Singleness, Will of God

More from Claire Matthews
Articles, Books, Music, Videos



  
No credit card required. Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only. Click here for International orders.

If you decide you want to keep Today's Christian Woman coming, honor your invoice for just $17.95 and receive five more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The trial issue is yours to keep, regardless.

Buy 1 gift subscription, get 1 FREE!

from the TCW store

How Green Should We Be?
PDF file

$7.95


Health Maters
PDF File

$7.95



Average Reader Rating: 

Displaying 1 - 3 of 11 comments.See all comments
Huiying Posted: February 18, 2008 11:13 PM
Hey I totally understand what you you are talking about. Indeed, give thanks that at least God is closing the door for you to keep you from hanging in the air with 'What if?' I think when the Adam in our lives appear, we will know. Free yourself from the bondage of the past and move on. David has been led into the wilderness for 40 years to learn and train, before he was ready to receive what God was preparing for him. I am trying to let go of my past too. Everything that happens today, happened because God allowed it too. Therefore, don't even think that God was not behind the reason of your breakup with that man. God is in control sister! He is always in control. Let's put our trust in him that there is something ten-folds better than what we had. He knows what we need, so let us be patient and watch him provide. It's not always easy, but you aren't alone feeling this way...I am with you..and God is with us=)

Anonymous Posted: November 05, 2007 12:29 PM
I didn't follow God therefore "almost right" left me due to my inability to commit. The pain that comes from a long term relationship is very tough and I wish I had followed God years ago when I first felt the gentle tug. Now several years later, I have not only the "what if" question but also all the history to deal with. They've moved on to another and appear to be happy while I am not. I read Psalms 73, Matthew 6:33 and Luke 18:1-8 and wonder does answer prayers. After much thought, I reflect back to my past where I've seen God's unmistakable movement in the minor areas in my life. I know that even in this, there is a plan and I must obey Him even when I feel like there will be no reward.

Njeri Posted: July 25, 2007 1:45 AM
I understand you, i broke off with a guy, despite prayer, i could not commit to him, my heart 'refused' and i felt that was not what God wanted me to do. Now years later while there is no one in my life, i sometimes wonder if it was the right thing to do, yet more often i know it was. Would we be so doubtful it was the right thing if we got a spouse soon after? i think this is faith, believing things not seen!

 








Books & Culture
Christianity Today
Church Law & Tax Report
Church Finance Today
Church Office Today
Leadership Journal
Men of Integrity
Outcomes
Today's Christian Woman
Your Church
ChristianityTodayLibrary.com
PreachingToday.com