Jump directly to the content

Why Melissa Rogers Signed the Health Care Workers Document


Apr 13 2009

Dozens of religious leaders met in Washington with members of Obama's administration last week to go over policy issues. Right before the meetings began, the White House also announced the full Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships. One of those members included Melissa Rogers, director of the Wake Forest University School of Divinity Center for Religion and Public Affairs, who joined the council to make sure partnerships between faith-based groups and the government would be constitutionally sound. I recently asked her about the council and why she signed the statement on conscience protections that Katelyn wrote about last week.

Why did you sign the statement urging the Obama administration on conscience protections for health workers? Do you think it will be effective?

First, a bit of background. There are specific conscience protections for health-care workers in federal statutory law. These statutes will continue to exist no matter the outcome of the administrative process - an administrative agency cannot undo federal statutes. The administrative process asked whether a Bush regulation dealing with these issues should be rescinded or retained.

Our statement did not ask the Obama administration to retain or rescind the Bush regulation because we could not agree on that issue. What we agree on is that if the Obama administration rescinds the Bush regulation, it should educate the stakeholders about existing federal statutory protections for the rights of conscience. We also argued that the administration should work with Congress to strengthen the religious accommodation provisions of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, provisions that are broader than the federal statutes that simply address conscience protections in the health-care arena. We believe these Title VII provisions should be amended so that they offer more robust protections for those who seek to have their religious needs respected in the workplace.

As we said in the comments, this should not be a zero-sum game. We should make every effort to honor the rights of conscience while providing access to lawful health-care services.

How is this office different from the one that President Bush established?

The Obama White House has said that ensuring that these partnerships are in compliance with the Constitution is a priority, as is making sure that they are effective and sensibly arranged for both providers and beneficiaries. It has said it won't measure success by how many religious groups or secular groups get government money, but by whether its policy goals (like bringing about an inclusive economic recovery) are being achieved through these partnerships.

Support our work. Subscribe to CT and get one year free.

Comments

To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.

orSubscribeor
More from Her.menutics
Why We Want to Return to Stars Hollow

Why We Want to Return to Stars Hollow

The weirdest part of the Gilmore Girls hometown? How they did community right.
My Toddler Survived Brain Cancer—Here’s What I Learned

My Toddler Survived Brain Cancer—Here’s What I Learned

7 things you should know, from a mom who’s been there
Don’t Just Pray Alone

Don’t Just Pray Alone

The world is desperate for people to pray with.
In Defense of Clutter

In Defense of Clutter

What to do about privilege, poverty, and piles of stuff.
Include results from Christianity Today
Browse Archives:

So Hot Right Now

My Son’s Autism Changed Everything—Even Our Church

I came to see special needs families as an unreached people group.

Twitter

  • #GilmoreGirls, the early Christians, and neighbors who don2019t knock https://t.co/kvd8TcfTeo
  • Probably the first time a CT article has ever used the phrase "throws shade." We see you, @CTLocalChurch. https://t.co/4PluOePH1v
  • If you're ready for more talk about #LEMONADE, hear @ZakiyaNaemaJack on all things Beyonc00e9 https://t.co/lQUhaWVmzy
  • RT @LoveLifeLitGod: Honored to have a guest post about creativity today at The Mudroom: Lifting the Veil 22c6 The Mudroom https://t.co/yb2Hy5b2026
  • RT @bwitt722: Great thoughts from @CarynRivadeneir and @MarlenaGraves. In Defense of Clutter via @CT_Women https://t.co/XLmNv1EdKx


What We're Reading

CT eBooks and Bible Studies

Christianity Today
Why Melissa Rogers Signed the Health Care Workers Document