
The Health Care Ruling and the God of Salvation

Auditing America's Political Integrity

Yesterday the Supreme Court announced its ruling on the controversial health care reform law passed in 2010, which held most of the law constitutional. Despite broad support for some of the individual provisions in the Proustian legislation, public opinion has been more strongly opposed to than in favor of the law as a whole. The ruling sets the stage for a particularly contentious conclusion to the election season. How might Christians, whose opinions on the law are no less diverse than the rest of the country's, respond to the ruling?
Regardless of what we think about the law or the court's decision, those who follow the God of the Bible are united in the belief that the world began as a good creation that overflowed from the love of the Trinity; that sickness and death marred and corrupted that good creation as a result of sin; that God came to earth in the person of Jesus to pay the penalty for sin, restore humankind's relationship with him and each other, and usher in the restoration of the world; that one day Jesus will return and we will all be bodily resurrected to enjoy eternity with the triune God in a new heaven and new earth in which the curse is no more.
That is the unifying conviction of the church throughout history and the world. And it is important to remember in a moment when national affairs can loom so large. The men and women leading our country, powerful as they may seem in the moment, are not our saviors. They, too, are both part of God's good creation yet subject to the corruption of sin—and that extends to every work of their minds and hands. We should not put undue hope in them and what they aim to accomplish, yet neither should we despair too greatly at the advance of strategies we may disagree with. God is still in control, and his ultimate plans for creation are unchanged by the events of yesterday morning.
Further, Christians should not look to our health care system, whatever it may become, as the permanent cure for sickness and death or an exemption from our obligation to care for widows and orphans, for the sick and needy. Jesus alone has overcome the grave, and it is in his victory that our hope should ultimately rest, not medical, technological or systemic advances, though God may certainly work for good through those changes.
Whatever our future health care system may be able to do for those who previously had no care, it does not permit us to abdicate our responsibility to care for the needy and vulnerable in our midst. Over and over throughout the Bible, God calls his people to this work. Although the church has sometimes emphasized care of the soul over that of the body, Isaiah 58 describes worship and obedience as intimately intertwined with material compassion:




How marriages can survive deployment—with some help from the church.
Shannon Polson sought healing from her father's death by retracing his fatal journey into the Alaskan wilderness.
Examining the lies that sex is worth nothing or sex is worth everything.
Cultivating ideas and thinking deeply can be spiritual acts of love.
Love compelled our church to get involved with the immigration issue.
Why this task can't continue to be an afterthought for leaders.
Is it legal to transfer the pastor's title to his home to our church?
How to succeed at a church renovation project, despite two painful realities of construction.
Why 20something Katie Davis traded her suburban Nashville life for the Savannah-and a great big family-in Uganda
Learning to accept the unthinkable
Q&A with Constance Rhodes
© 2013 Christianity Today
About Our Ministry | Blog | Partner With Us | Careers | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Ad Choices

Comments
Displaying 110 of 73 comments
See all comments
Tam
Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you could be a great author. I will always bookmark your blog and will come back later in life. I want to encourage one to continue your great work, have a nice afternoon!
JEAN M ASKEW
I am appalled and embarrassed, as a Christian believer, that this article could inspire so much misinformation, so much arrogance about what the Bible "says," so few comments displaying thoughtful knowledge, so many wild-eyed claims & predictions, so little regard for accuracy. Paranoia, ignorance and conspiracy theory are alive and well in The Church to its detriment.
Dan from Georgia
Hi David. I don't know much of the details of the health care law that passed, but I too am astonished at the hyped-up fear and paranoia surrounding the bill. I am not a fan of President Obama, and I did not vote for him, and I don't plan to, and that has everything to do with his politics and nothing, I repeat, NOTHING to do with the fear here amongst many Christians that he is a Muslim, the anti-christ, etc etc etc blah blah blah. Time will tell whether the health care law will be good or bad for the American society. There seems to be alot of Christians (and conservatives for that matter) here in America that think that anything Obama (or any democrat) does is bad, and it is the beginning of the end times, the mark of the beast is coming, it's the downfall of America (and by default civilization as we know it because the world centers around America you know), etc. I am aware that the issue is a bit more complicated than the "liberal/democrat bad-republican/conservative good" mindset. However, as Tim stated long ago in a post above...THE SKY IS NOT FALLING.
David
As a Canadian Christian I read many of these comments with fascination and incredulity. There is such a pervasive paranoia and misinformation about public health care that it is hard to know where to begin. I am in my fifties and nearly my entire life has been lived in our socialized medicine system which was brought into being by a Baptist minister turned politician who saw the suffering of the poor and disenfranchised. I have no doubt he believed in Christ's eternal promise. In the meantime he wanted all Canadians to have access to decent health care. I have a health card in my wallet along with my driver's license, and a number of others. There is no 666 prefix to my number and I am still waiting for the government to suggest that I have some mysterious chip implanted. As a clergyperson for over 30 years I have kept vigil and prayed with many undergoing serious health issues. Not one that I can think of has died because of slow access to medical care. Our system is imperfect and frustrating at times, but the people I know, including my aging mother, thank God for the level of care we receive. Bye the way, Canadians have greater longevity than Americans, a lower infant mortality rate, and score better in most other indicators. And no one goes bankrupt here because they are sick. I hope Americans come to the place where they thank God for what happened last week.
Suzanne
That's where you and I differ, Linda. I don't believe God has any grand plan for this country above or beyond any other country. God doesn't love Americans any more than anyone else. Your rant against healthcare reform being bad because it was put forth by those you consider bad reminded me of the scene in Gone With the Wind in which Melanie took money from the local Madam (yes, that kind) to help the wounded soldiers. Melanie's focus was on what would help the soldiers, not that the woman giving it was less than pure. The healthcare bill may not be perfect, but at least it's something. Maybe you don't know anybody without insurance. I do. These are not slackers, not people who don't work, not people who are lazy, not welfare cheats with multiple children, but people who have been laid off when a business closed or decided they were no longer needed human capitol. Or young people out of college but unable to find a job that includes healthcare. Or people with a full time job that offers a healthcare plan that, if taken, would not allow enough take-home salary to live. So the church can care for the poor, and will continue to do so. However, my church is having trouble affording healthcare for the paid church workers. I can't imagine how we could take on the healthcare costs for even a handful of others who don't have any. I know churches that don't even provide healthcare for their own church workers because it is too costly. So how can we hope to pay for all those others?
Linda Fisher
I am not going to write a tome here like some have done, although I have lots to say like everyone else. Just this: American Christians in particular and conservatives in general did not deal with the healthcare issue when we had the chance, and we are now suffering the consequences. But many of us are extremely involved in serving the poor and have given our lives to it, so I am tired of hearing liberals, Christians in particular, say the Church doesn't care for the poor. We do have far too many poor people in the US, but this is partly because of the entitlement programs that make it far too easy for people to willingly settle into the "poor" mentality. There is abundance here, but you have to be willing to work and strive to participate in it. I am all in favor of healthcare reform. But not authored by people who are willing to lie to get their way and sneak to get it passed; who base their philosophy on the right to kill millions of unborn babies, fund a lifestyle God calles an abomination and which holds millions of people in bondage, and puts a finite government in the position of making invasive decisions about our personal lives. God help us all...whether the Healthcare Bill becomes law or not. With or without it, we are far from the country I believe God wanted us to be.
Kate
I just tried to post and was given a message "You have posted too many messages in a short period of time." I believe you may have a glitch, because I had not posted any items. What I did post was this: I lived in Canada for 7 years and while the health care system is convenient, there are flaws in the system. However, Canada's limits on malpractice liability are significant and necessary. Tort reform in the US is essential to decrease and contain medical costs in this country. While we may pat ourselves on the back for joining other countries in universal health care, we need to be responsible for paying for it also. To saddle our children and their children with debt of this magnitude is irresponsible and tantamount to financial slavery.
Kate
I just tried to post and was given a message "You have posted too many messages in a short period of time." I believe you may have a glitch, because I had not posted any items. What I did post was this: I lived in Canada for 7 years and while the health care system is convenient, there are flaws in the system. However, Canada's limits on malpractice liability are significant and necessary. Tort reform in the US is essential to decrease and contain medical costs in this country. While we may pat ourselves on the back for joining other countries in universal health care, we need to be responsible for paying for it also. To saddle our children and their children with debt of this magnitude is irresponsible and tantamount to financial slavery.
Kate
What a fascinating article and group of responses. I lived in Canada for 7 years under their single-payer system which has flaws of which many Americans are unaware. A major difference I see between our two countries approaches to universal health care is the method of paying for it and tort reform. I don't believe saddling the next generations with the kind of debt that this administration has chalked up (nearly triple that of the previous administration) and the ACA debts (which are not fixed and still being calculated by the Congressional Budget Office) is responsible or Christian regardless of your politics. In fact I believe it is a kind of fiscal slavery that we are placing our children and their children into if we let this law go forward without modification. It is a shame that many liberals feel uncomfortable in churches which do not share their political beliefs. I have had similar experiences since my husband is a professor and we do not share the liberal values espoused by secular universities and many of his colleagues. I will pray that our political differences will not allow divisions between sisters and brothers in Christ as I hope you will also. Blessings and peace.
Hutchbilly
I guess healing and access to health care is the devil's idea so it must be opposed at all costs, even if it results in people losing coverage for pre-existing conditions, children not being covered, and seniors not being able to afford the medications that keep them healthy and alive. to me, those actions are the work of the devil. I saw complaints that the bill was not read before bing passed, a talking point, but it has been shown that when people read what is in the bill, they like it more and more than when they just look at the cover. I believe there is a proverb about it being foolish not to hear the entire argument before making a judgment. This is the same type of stuff thrown up in the air when Social Security was formed that was the greatest removal of people from poverty in our history, and the development of medicare that gives coverage to the seniors and disabled, and medicaid which protects the poor (which we will have with us always, someone said). Is it written somewhere in the bible that these things SHOULD NOT be done by the governemt?
*