Jump directly to the content
Jump directly to the content
Why Jesus Isn't Your Boyfriend: A Critique of Dating God

Why Jesus Isn't Your Boyfriend: A Critique of Dating God


Jun 25 2012
Christian women need a better framework for relating to God amid their singleness.

It's no secret that marriage is on the decline in the United States. The most recent Census revealed that 32 million Americans are now in single households, and that married people are no longer the majority. Some are single by necessity or life circumstances, others by choice or career aspirations. And then there those who are functionally single but married to themselves. Yes, I'm talking about self-marriage, complete with marriage ceremony, commitment papers, and vows. A recent CNN article points to a segment of single people who are choosing to "marry themselves" rather than another person. These are hardly lonely, disconnected people who simply cannot find a spouse. Instead, they are choosing self-marriage to show how happy they truly are as singles. As one woman put it, marrying herself allowed her to see that all the love she needed was inside herself. "I started discovering that the love I need, it's in here," Nadine Schweigert said, pointing to her heart.

As the article states, this is hardly a developing trend. It is doubtful that people will begin seeing "Karen and Karen Are Getting Married!" invites arriving in their mailbox this summer. But before we begin writing these people off as a fringe movement in self-love, we should note that Christians just as easily embrace false notions of what it means to be single.

My mom once told me about a girl she knew in college who would pluck petals off a flower, slowly reciting, "He loves me, he loves me not, he loves me." On the occasion that she would end with "he loves me" she would exclaim for the entire dorm to hear, "He loves me! Jesus loves me!"

Jesus, in her mind, was her boyfriend.

It was not uncommon at my conservative Christian college to overhear girls say that Jesus was their "boyfriend" until God brought the right man along. I once had a girl tell me she could not hang out on a Friday night because she had a "date" with God. In our churches, many of our praise and worship songs border on the "love song" language, leading many girls to equate those warm and fuzzy feelings that come with attraction with Jesus. This is a dangerous place to be. Not only is it an incomplete picture of who our Christ is, it also sends the message that the girls (and women) who are truly devoted to Jesus equate contentment in him with a romantic relationship with him.

Just as self-marriage misses the mark for what God designed marriage to point to, "marriage" to Jesus misses what his work accomplished. Marriage to Jesus while waiting for a husband can often trivialize our Savior in a way that makes him more like a sweet boyfriend who takes us out on dates, rather than the God-man who paid for our sin on the cross. Jesus did not accomplish redemption to marry us individually. He died for the church corporate, of which we are apart. His death accomplished something much greater than simply meeting our deep-seated desires for a significant other. That is what Paul is getting at in Ephesians 5:22-33 when speaks of the mystery of marriage.

Related Topics:Dating; Doctrine
From: June 2012

Comments

Displaying 1–10 of 73 comments

Nicole VM

March 12, 2013  2:23pm

How in the world can you connect the article you based this on in any way with a single woman being content in her singleness? Maybe I'm reading it wrong, maybe you're just trying to get a dialogue going? I'm single, divorced, & at this point I don't think I'll ever be married again. I'm fine with that & I'm also fine with people not being fine with it. It took me a few years, some mistakes, some great conversation & studying & praying before I finally FINALLY recognized that yep, God does indeed fill every need I have. He is my provider, He is my friend, He comforts me, He loves me, He IS the perfect "husband" & that's scriptural. And, by the way, even when I was married all those things were true. Creepy?? I guess you'll have to work that out with God yourself. Sexual? Um, no, although He does help me when I'm tempted (as He promises). Am I "trivializing Jesus"? No, quite the opposite. I have peace & joy & contentment & I know I'd have none of that without Him.

Report Abuse

Jess west

February 01, 2013  12:55am

I know that Jesus has the kind of love for me that I want from a boyfriend/ husband. He loves the me that he created, the real me that is beautiful and perfect. He loves it when my heart sings for him, when I take the joy and love in my heart and spread it to other people so that they can feel it, too. Doesn’t he think that is beautiful? Yes, he does. He loves me like that- is it so wrong to love that love? Is it so wrong to, when I’m feeling down and worthless and ugly, look at that love and look at my savior and be reminded that I’m worth something and that someone loves me and thinks I’m beautiful? And no, I’m not talking about my eyes or my hair or my body. I’m talking about inner beauty. So is it so bad? Is it so bad to love Jesus like that?

Report Abuse

Doreen Ashley

December 01, 2012  4:41am

Dear Katelyn, You're preaching from your own opinion. Self-marriage and a relationship with Jesus are SO COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. The title doesn't fit the content, at all. It's very scattered. p.s. Your article confesses that you value a mere earthly marriage more than the unfailing, never-ending, soul-satisfying relationship with Jesus. Know who were the expert critics? Pharisees. Go read your Bible.

Sabrina Messenger

November 29, 2012  3:46pm

Finally, the article is an insult to those Christian people who for centuries did indeed willingly give up everything, including marriage, to live for God most fully. There were countless saints and holy men and women of God who did just that. Some were priests, monks, nuns...some were leaders like Queen Elizabeth I, and some were just everyday people. Some were missionaries, some were martyrs. ALL of them knew that God comes first and that marriage is not the end~all~be~all of our lives. It wasn't until Martin Luther came in there and pushed this idea that everyone had to be married. His way of thumbing his nose at the Catholic Church. Even in Eastern Orthodoxy, marriage isn't viewed as some vehicle of social mobility. It's considered a martyrdom. There's more ways to view this thing from the narrow Evangelical Protestant North American way.

Report Abuse

Sabrina Messenger

November 29, 2012  3:40pm

Seeing Christ as your boyfriend/spouse doesn't not eschew earthly marriage. It does say in Scripture marriage is honorable, but it doesn't say it's the ONLY way for someone to live. Our first love, married or unmarried, should be God. Anything else is idolatry.

Report Abuse

Sabrina Messenger

November 29, 2012  3:35pm

Also, maybe we need to question the way we've distorted the ideas of love and marriage and manipulated them to fit our own selfish ways (the overemphasis on sex and romance), then you'll see why some here are rejecting the idea of Christ as our heavenly Spouse. Men shouldn't feel the least bit threatened by this idea. It's not like you think. St Symeon the New Theologian wrote of Divine Eros and how it means getting lost in God and His love. Eros doesn't just mean some sexual idea. It's also a deep sense of intimacy and trust. I think that sort of thing has been lost in Western Christianity, particularly Protestantism.

Report Abuse

Sabrina Messenger

November 29, 2012  3:31pm

This is for those of you posting offensive things and mocking the idea of Jesus being a single woman's boyfriend. You are totally misunderstanding of the concept. No, Jesus isn't my "boyfriend" in the sense of an earthly partner whom I can hug and kiss and flirt with. He's so much more than that. Jesus is my HUSBAND! In fact, if you are a Christian who has been saved, he is ALL of our Husband. How's that? Christ is the husband to the Church (and this goes for all Christians/The Church, male and female). It says so right in Scripture in several places, particularly in Ephesians 5 as well as in Isaiah 54. In Sacred Tradition in the Orthodox Church, as well as in Scripture Christ is referred to as The Bridegroom. Check out the parable of the five wise/foolish virgins for more on that. I don't take that relationship with Christ lightly. The relationship of Christ and His Church is profound and special and enduring and it is FOREVER, and it should never, ever be trivialized as to be made into some limiting secularized romantic thing that can be put aside at any given moment like a human partner often is. Earthly marriage is supposed to be a reflection of the relationship between Christ and the Church, and if people understand that better they wouldn't say the rude and decidedly anti-Christian things they are saying. Just FTR, I do have "dates" with Jesus, they're called prayer and attending worship services. I go to All Night Vigil at my church each Saturday night and I do refer to it as my steady Saturday Night Date. I'd much rather be there than on any worldly date, and I don't think there is anything wrong with it or anything to laugh at or mock. If more single people attended services, prayed, and put GOD first instead of making a god of romance, dating and marriage they would be much better off. It's the non-believing or lukewarm "Christian" who need to wake up...as it says in Scripture. The Bridegroom comes as a thief in the night, and you need to decide whether or not you'll be like the wise virgin who is ready or the foolish one who is not. As for that you need a living person (in a romantic way) to make you happy, that is definitely untrue. No one can "make" you happy. You have to find that happiness with or without a significant other. There are many, many people who don't marry or date and they do have happy and fulfilled lives. Some of them were monastics/nuns who were actually hermits because that is what God called them to be.

Report Abuse

Galimex

November 09, 2012  6:58am

Oh,these people thinking they are dating God!Wake up!God can only be in our mind and soul,not by our side.Saying you are dating God is like saying you are dating an alien!Great artcle!

Report Abuse

Epilare

November 08, 2012  8:34am

I can think of so many reasons to explain why thinking God is your boyfriend is wrong.You can't really feel happy only with God.You need a living person to make you happy.Great article!

Report Abuse

Alexir

November 07, 2012  4:42am

Ok,you are single and happy.What do you need God for then?How does he makes you happy?Don't you need a real person to feel love?I'm not saying that loving God is wrong,it's wrong if you think you're dating God.

Report Abuse

 *

1000 character limit

* Comments may be edited for tone and clarity.

See All 73 Comments
To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register
More from Her.menutics
Stay Sexy or Else? Well, Please Forgive These Mommy Hips

Stay Sexy or Else? Well, Please Forgive These Mommy Hips

When the joy of sex gets replaced by the fear of not being sexy enough.
Desperate for Their MRS. Degrees

Desperate for Their MRS. Degrees

Pressure to put a ring on it can distract from other pursuits and callings.
'The Office' Shows Even TV Romance Isn't Picture-Perfect

'The Office' Shows Even TV Romance Isn't Picture-Perfect

How Jim and Pam's struggling marriage saved the show's final season.
The Double Shock of Unexpected Pregnancy

The Double Shock of Unexpected Pregnancy

How faith meets this scary, stressful, but ultimately divine surprise.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Include results from Christianity Today
Browse Archives:

So Hot Right Now

Are Women Really Saved through Childbearing?

Mother's Day, infertility, and redemption.

Follow Us

What We're Reading

CT eBooks and Bible Studies