Jump directly to the content
Jump directly to the content
Why a Big Stomach Belongs at Thanksgiving

Why a Big Stomach Belongs at Thanksgiving


Nov 21 2012
And how my own appetite went from enemy to dear friend.

The first time I remember feeling uncomfortable from overeating was at a Thanksgiving meal at my grandparents'. Between the main course and the dessert that I still hoped to eat, I went on a walk around their property to relieve my discomfort and make room for just a bit more. Perhaps every child has such an encounter with the stomach's limits, but that meal also foreshadowed many years of struggling with food. During those years, my sense of taste seemed more curse than blessing.

By my freshman year of college, I could balance my healthy, six-foot tall father in the scales, a fact that scared me. I'd been trying to "fix" my weight since late junior high, but to no avail. Each time my latest strategy failed (whether cutting out dessert or seconds or trying to get more exercise), the high weight for that lapse inched further upward. These numbers were always in the realm of mere overweight, but seemed doomed to end in obesity. When I saw Dad's weight on my scale that day, I started to wonder how near that was.

In the panic that ensued, I bought my first, and last, Christian diet book. Though I never actually finished it, the author introduced a radical notion: God had made my body good. In fact, she said, it could tell me how much energy I needed to consume, maybe even what kind of food. But first, I would have to listen to my body.

The first several weeks of learning to listen were difficult. Before, I had always waited until I felt full to stop eating, but the author said I should stop when satisfied, a point I had never noticed and which always came too soon. Though I had no constraints on what I ate, my body never seemed to need as much as I wanted. Stopping when I was satisfied often echoed the way I felt on Friday nights that year, when I would sit alone in my dorm room, hearing the other students head out for the start of their weekends.

Gradually my newfound restraint began to pay off. After six months, I had lost about 30 pounds solely by listening. And I now felt a new freedom at the buffet line: rather than choosing based on a rule, I could eat whatever I wanted, within the limits of hunger.

Though I had learned an important lesson about how to work my body, that victory proved like every weight skirmish before: it didn't last. Over the next few years, I continued to struggle with food, often eating when I lacked a sense of control or faced negative emotions.

One day I looked at my skinny-clothes stash. Rather than pushing past them with the usual vague hope. I started to ask: Was I really going to wear these someday? What if I never could? Was I going to spend my life forestalling happiness until thinness proved attainable?

Comments

Displaying 1–10 of 11 comments

Denise

November 24, 2012  7:51pm

Great article. I've been following a diet called "The Livet," which is live with a T instead of diet with a T. I too feel a lot of freedom in what I eat. Instead of constantly agonizing over what to eat and feeling guilty about it, I listen to my body. You can read more about it http://feedingjimmy.com/the-livet/

Report Abuse

Crooked Bird

November 24, 2012  6:57pm

This is a great article--thank you! To enjoy food as a gift, and one that (like all others) is meant to be used in moderation, is really the healthy and joyful way. I love the comment about how sweet food gets associated with guilt in our culture--and shouldn't. There's nothing guilty about enjoying chocolate--why would there be? So, I grew up in France, where the food culture is a bit different from the U.S.'s. People don't talk about guilt in relation to sweets. They do sometimes turn down seconds saying "I'm watching my weight," so it's not like they don't think about it. But one big difference that I've noticed between France and the U.S. is what seems to be the American belief that certain foods are bad. That's unknown in France. The notion that I mustn't eat *that* because it'll make me fat is an American one, and what's more, it's not true. It's not the innate nature of cake that puts pounds on you--it's the amount. And it's not just the amount of cake, it's the amount of everything. That's why I agree with the notion of listening to your body--if what you're listening to is when your body is full. And Stephanie, I SO agree about fat-free foods. I would add diet soda to the list. They all taste HORRIBLE. I watched a French person taste non-fat yogurt (which seems to be standard here now) and she made a face and went "That's not yogurt! This stuff is held together with gelatin!" (Yeah, apparently she could tell that...) I think they come from that cultural "Aha, *this* food is the culprit!" attitude--and they perpetuate the other American food myth, which is that bad foods taste good and good foods taste bad, so you can pick health or enjoyment, one or the other. That's just... wrong.

Report Abuse

Stan Guthrie

November 24, 2012  1:26pm

While I agree with the idea that we should never base our contentment on circumstances (our weight, our income, our marital status, etc.), and while I am more than a little tired of our cultures obsession with both food and health, I don't think just "listening to our bodies" is the answer. We naturally crave fats and sweets because they are the best source of calories and energy because for most of human history food was in short supply while daily living require a lot of physical activity. And rather than being chided for eating those between meal sweets, I often have been told "this one time won't hurt." However, "this one time" happens all too often. Combine that with every opportunity for "fellowship" involving food (usually sweets), and it's no wonder so many people have weight related health problems. I often find I'm not looking for sweets, but when everyone around me is eating them and the food is out on display it becomes hard to resist. There has to be a middle ground between constantly denying yourself and eating whatever you want. (or crave) That's what I'm aiming for.

Report Abuse

Susan Spicer

November 22, 2012  8:09pm

Stephanie, love and couldn't agree more with your post!

Report Abuse

Kathi Vande Guchte

November 22, 2012  7:44pm

I have battled/struggled/wrestled with my weight since childhood. I've have lost large amounts of weight numerous times, using healthy, insane, structured weightloss plans. I'm at the heaviest I've ever been and am considered obese, with high BP and cholesterol, plus my knees reall hurt. This past summer I began investigating weight loss surgery. A few colleagues had undergone surgeries and were doing very well. I have continued to research and pray, and am the point where I will undergo WLS May 2013.

Report Abuse

Tim

November 22, 2012  3:56pm

Anna, thank you so much for focusing us on the good gift God gave us in providing food that is not only nutritious but also extravagantly enjoyable. I wrote an ode to my God-given taste buds on my blog today, so I am right there with you on your post here. Cheers (in more ways than one!), Tim

Report Abuse

Stephanie

November 21, 2012  3:45pm

Great article! I love food a great deal, and sort of hang around between 'healthy'/overweight BMI. I often see on Pinterest, "Nothing tastes as good as being thin feels." I loved being thin, and I like having the excuse of a 4-month-old to be a bit pudgy right now. And I completely disagree! Food is meant to be enjoyed! It's a gift. As long as I am healthy, just because I'm not a size 8 or even my ideal 10, doesn't mean I need to feel guilty about enjoying really good food. (Now to internalize that truth.) Fat-free food is gross and empty of nutrition. Keep your 100-cal packs; I will eat a real cookie made with butter or a slice of pie instead of five hundred little tasteless things. Anyway, I still struggle with not looking as good as I want to, but I'm definitely not willing to eat too differently to lose weight. And it's a choice I have to make. Our society really knows how to take good things and wreck them. (Food, sex, exercise/sports, fashion, beauty, etc.)

Report Abuse

Laura Droege

November 21, 2012  1:21pm

I meant to say "fair share". Sigh.

Report Abuse

Laura Droege

November 21, 2012  1:19pm

I appreciate what you have to say here. As someone who has battled both anorexia and bulimia (and recovered!), I have had my far share of seeing food as a source of guilt, something to be accompanied with the self-remonstrations you spoke of. I do, however, have a few questions. Would your outlook on food change if you were diagnosed with a severe food allergy or celiac disease? (Both would limit what you could eat and therefore might impact how you think about food/nourishment/enjoyment.) Second, what advice do you have for those with severe food limitations, who desperately want to enjoy food, but nevertheless know that the wrong foods might sicken their bodies?

Report Abuse

AP

November 21, 2012  12:15pm

Well said, and thank you for sharing some of your story. Considering the biblical description of a huge Feast awaiting us on That Day when all is indeed re-made, I think *God* is looking forward to having *you* over, too! :)

Report Abuse

 *

1000 character limit

* Comments may be edited for tone and clarity.

See All 11 Comments
To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register
More from Her.menutics
Angelina Jolie's Breasts and the Bravery of Letting Go

Angelina Jolie's Breasts and the Bravery of Letting Go

Refusing to let beauty become a trap.
Auditing America's Political Integrity

Auditing America's Political Integrity

The IRS scandal, Benghazi incidents, and the disappointment of dishonorable leadership.
Stay Sexy or Else? Well, Please Forgive These Mommy Hips

Stay Sexy or Else? Well, Please Forgive These Mommy Hips

When the joy of sex gets replaced by the fear of not being sexy enough.
Desperate for Their MRS. Degrees

Desperate for Their MRS. Degrees

Pressure to put a ring on it can distract from other pursuits and callings.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Include results from Christianity Today
Browse Archives:

So Hot Right Now

Are Women Really Saved through Childbearing?

Mother's Day, infertility, and redemption.

Follow Us

What We're Reading

CT eBooks and Bible Studies