Jump directly to the content

Richard Dawkins Has Reason to Fear the Fairy Tale


Jun 10 2014
How the realm of make-believe can bring us toward God.

As I child I dreamed often of flying.

What made these dreams deliciously haunting – the sort that linger pleasantly in the mind well after you've awakened – was how mundane everything else had been, save the surprising ability to fly. Upon waking, I'd lie in bed a few minutes, uncertain of the borders between the reality of my bedroom and the flights my imagination, in repose, had allowed me.

Years later, I had occasion to chat with one of my professor's daughters, then eight or nine, who would later stand as flower girl at my wedding. She clutched her white stuffed toy owl – a replica of Harry Potter's Hedwig – and chattered about her dreams:

"Sometimes, when I have dreams about flying, I wake up and still think that I can really fly!"

"Tara, are you talking Rachel's ear off?" a parent admonished.

"No," I replied quickly. "We're having a great conversation."

"That happens to me, too," I told her. "And it's my favorite kind of dream."

She smiled. "Have you read the third Harry Potter book yet, Rachel? What's your favorite?"

Why do I remember this conversation 12 or 13 years later? Perhaps because it was a moment all too rare in my (pre-parenthood) experience – when a child and an adult can meet as equals in the discussion of something deeply of interest to both, each treating the other's experiences and enthusiasms with utmost seriousness.

In his delightful little essay, "On the Three Ways of Writing for Children," C.S. Lewis observes:

Once about every hundred years some wiseacre gets up and tries to banish the fairy tale. It is accused of giving [children] a false impression of the world they live in. But I think no literature that children could read gives them less of a false impression.

Last week, the British newspaper The Telegraph reported that Richard Dawkins, the evolutionary biologist well known for the missionary zeal of his atheism, remarked at the Cheltenham Science Festival that reading fairy tales to kids might be harmful. Dawkins, whose famous skepticism seems to have been particularly precocious, claims to have debunked the Santa Claus delusion at the tender age of 21 months.

He later backtracked on the question of fairy tales, allowing as how they may function as a sort of testing ground for cultivating skepticism: If we let kids have their fairy tales, when they later discover that it's impossible for a frog to turn into a prince, they'll be less inclined to place any trust in whatever religion is taught to them.

Support our work. Subscribe to CT and get one year free.

Comments

To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.

orSubscribeor
More from Her.menutics
A Lament for Louisiana After the Floods

A Lament for Louisiana After the Floods

As I grieve the tragedy in my home state, I’ve found solace in a surprising place.
Let Them Bake Cakes

Let Them Bake Cakes

The Great British Baking Show teaches me about offering and receiving friendship in a fractured world.
Why I’m Not a World-Changer

Why I’m Not a World-Changer

In my middle-age years, I’ve traded revolution for good old-fashioned faithfulness.
Our Bodies Are Imperfect Temples

Our Bodies Are Imperfect Temples

God dwells in us whether we’re Olympian-level muscular or morbidly obese.
Include results from Christianity Today
Browse Archives:

So Hot Right Now

The Truth About Living with an Invisible Illness

God sees me and my pain even when others cannot.

Follow Us

Twitter

  • RT @AndreaPalpant: This one's for you @roddreher: A Lament for Louisiana After the Floods (@Tish_H_Warren you'll like) https://t.co/JJ3hN2t2026
  • RT @aliciacohn: Josh Harris, author of a best-selling abstinence manifesto, is sorry. Kind of. Maybe. https://t.co/EYSQ5Q4ME5 via @slate
  • Church ladies for the win d83ddc4a https://t.co/r3SZU0geqI
  • RT @Image_Journal: Why nuanced female characters in movies help us develop empathy: https://t.co/Dou5Yl504F
  • RT @LoveLifeLitGod: I'll be there in person speaking about arts, and women engaging the culture. You can join from home Thurs and Fri: http2026


What We're Reading

CT eBooks and Bible Studies

Christianity Today
Richard Dawkins Has Reason to Fear the Fairy Tale