Cassie Said Yes, They Said No

The mainstream press unquestioningly accepted Salon.com's flimsy debunking of the Columbine confession.

Did Cassie Bernall confess her faith in God moments before Dylan Klebold shot her? Did he, in fact, even pose the question "Do you believe in God?" that allowed Cassie's "yes"?

Ever since the online site Salon.com ran an article subtitled "Everything You Know About the Littleton Killings Is Wrong" (Sept. 23) in which Dave Cullen attempted to debunk popular perceptions of the Columbine massacre, skepticism has mounted about the veracity of the alleged exchange between Cassie and her killer.

But the larger question is this: Why has Cullen's dubious assertion, based on incomplete reporting, so captured the imaginations of the media?

According to Cullen, investigators from the Jefferson County Sheriff's department encountered conflicting testimony about Cassie's last minutes. As a result, they have publicly stated doubts about whether the question was ever posed to Bernall. "A far more likely" scenario, Cullen wrote, has the story of Columbine survivor Val Schnurr "apparently misattributed to Cassie." The media seized upon Cullen's speculations, and the controversy took off.

In a Washington Postarticle (Oct. 14), Hanna Rosin took the controversy to new levels when she dismissed the encounter as a myth and then made the leap that "myth" alone is sufficient to animate the religious fervor of evangelicals, regardless of whether it is true. "It's the power of the story that counts," she wrote. "The truth is a trifle . Should believers accept the literal truth, they'd be left with a hopeless equation."Mary Schmich and Eric Zorn echoed these thoughts in the Chicago Tribune(Oct. 20). "I suspect history will ultimately ...

Subscriber access only You have reached the end of this Article Preview

To continue reading, subscribe now. Subscribers have full digital access.

November
Subscribe to CT and get one year free.
Read These Next
Christianity Today
Cassie Said Yes, They Said No
hide this
Access The Archives

Member-Only Access

Subscribe to Christianity Today to continue reading this article from CT's digital archives.