Weblog readers may have picked up from other publications a notion that evangelicals don't like Bush's plan to allow faith-based charities and organizations to compete for federal grants. In fact, Weblog believes most of these concerns have been mischaracterized as criticisms, rejections, and rebukes to the plan when in fact "critics" like Pat Robertson, Jerry Falwell, Richard Land, Marvin Olasky, and others have all repeatedly supported Bush's plan. Still, the mainstream media has been busy characterizing religious conservatives as united in opposition. This week, evangelicals did unite, and actually came out supporting the concept of charitable choice—the underlying framework behind Bush's faith-based initiative. The resolution came out of the National Association of Evangelicals (NAE) annual convention, which wrapped up in Dallas yesterday.
Also attending the NAE gathering was John DiIulio, head of Bush's Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives, who was apparently doing some damage control. DiIulio spent most of his time answering critics of his plan. "With all due respect, and in all good fellowship, predominantly white, exurban, evangelical and national parachurch leaders should be careful not to presume to speak for any persons other than themselves and their own churches," he said in a sharp response to some of his religious critics. "It's fine to fret about 'hijacked faith,' but to many brothers and sisters who are desperately ministering to the needs of those who the rest of us in this prosperous society have left behind, such frets would persuade more and rankle less if they were backed by real human and financial help." Many churches have already demonstrated the plan can work, he said. "Urban African American and Latino faith communities have benevolent traditions and histories that make them generally more dedicated to community-serving missions, and generally more confident about engaging public and secular partners in achieving those missions without enervating their spiritual identities or religious characters."
In the most detailed presentation of what the Bush plan will look like, DiIulio explained that the federal government will likely move to a two-tier system, with direct grants going to some religious organizations that feel they can separate evangelism from social ministry, and a voucher system for those that feel they can't.
"At one end, the least problematic end from a church-state perspective, you have, say, faith-based organizations that do housing rehab work," DiIulio explained. "They mobilize their volunteers from churches. They park their lumber in the church parking lots. They may pray for good weather when working outdoors, but it's all about faith-motivated good works in the form of hammering and plumbing. And, at the other pole of the continuum, there is, say, a faith-based drug treatment program that is all about urging each beneficiary to accept Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior. The indivisibly conversion-centered program that cannot separate out and privately fund its inherently religious activities, can still receive government support, but only through individual vouchers."
Olasky, who sat on a panel with DiIulio, later told The New York Times that he's wary of the voucher idea. "That seems to me to be discriminatory and wrong. There already is so much suspicion in the evangelical community about government activity, and this will only intensify it." Expect Olasky to have a piece in this week's World magazine (which will likely be posted on Friday afternoon) further detailing his concerns, and whether he's still five-sixths in support of the faith-based initative.
More on Bush's faith-based initiative:
- Faith and parking (The New York Times)
- Defending 'faith-based' plan | White House to argue charities can separate religious, secular (The Washington Post)
- Religion goes with the soup | The establishment of an office to pump federal money into religious charities has brought a uniform reaction from across the spectrum of churches and civil libertarian organizations, left to right. The only problem for the president's plan is that most of that response has been negative. (Dan K. Thomasson, The Cincinnati Post)
- As Buddhas fall | We should remember that one man's faith is another's heresy, that religion is sometimes a variant of madness and the cause, not the cure, of what ails much of the world. (Richard Coen, The Washington Post)
- Leaps of faith | Quotes from "Face the Nation" (CBS News)
- Religion, politics and the weight of history | The moderator of the Reed-Dershowitz debate speaks her mind on Bush's faith-based initiative (The Seattle Times)
- Heart and soul of the faith-based debate | Waiting for details of the president's plan (Larry Eichel, The Philadelphia Inquirer)
After NewYorkTimes article, USAID will closely monitor Samaritan's Purse
Yesterday's Weblog discussed a New York Timesarticle accusing Christian relief organization Samaritan's Purse of "blurr[ing] the line between church and state as its volunteers preach, pray and seek converts among people desperate for help." Weblog concluded that the organization had made a convincing argument that the newspaper blew the story, but there's still no correction, clarification, or apology in the Times corrections page. However, the Associated Press reports that the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) is taking steps to ensure that Samaritan's Purse has "adequate and sufficient separation between its prayer sessions and its USAID-funded activities." The agency is "warning the organization that it cannot mix evangelism and government-funded assistance," the AP reports. But Samaritan's Purse says it never did so anyway.
- Don't confuse self-indulgence, sacrifice (Susan Cheever, Newsday)
- Catholic Church renews emphasis on Lenten discipline (Religion News Service/Chicago Tribune)
- Lent: 40 somber days | Explaining the numbers and customs behind the Christian church's doleful remembrance of Christ's passion (UPI)
- Church services cut to limit foot-and-mouth risk | Christian leaders ask for prayer and unity during outbreak (The Times, London)
- Attracting young adults to a relevant church taxes Christian ministers (The Denver Post)
- Church blesses a coffee icon | Starbucks debuts in Munster, Indiana's Family Christian Center, making its first foothold in a church. (The Boston Globe)
- Seeking a wider view of a church's identity | A Columbia congregation explores its faith and how to express it in everyday life. (The Sun, Baltimore)
- Management: For one church, divine intervention isn't enough | St. Bartholomew's in Manhattan hires an outside accountant to turn finances around (The New York Times)
- Spiritual drama on 'Road' to ruin | Nothing in the Billy Graham Crusade's World Wide Pictures film Road to Redemption is remotely plausible, but the characters here are merely cogs in a well-oiled machine meant to espouse a religious message. (Associated Press)
- Makers of LeftBehind:TheMovie say they were naïve about distribution | But makers stand by strategy of releasing video first (The Ottawa Citizen)
Politics and law:
- Illinois hate crimes bill hits a wall | Committee rejects it, fears legislation would make churches liable (Chicago Tribune)
- National Right to Life Committee, ACLU, Christian Coalition, labor unions, find something to agree on | Interest groups oppose campaign finance reform bill (Associated Press)
- McCain seeks to reverse limits on low-power FM (Reuters)
- State reneges on paying for faith-based recovery efforts | Some groups rebuilding houses damaged by Hurricane Floyd will not be reimbursed for construction costs. (The News & Observer, Raleigh, North Carolina)
- Ten Commandments: Historical or religious? | City Hall in Grand Junction, Colorado, latest battleground(The Denver Post)
- Lawyer hopes to challenge Christmas in high court | District court and federal appeals court have rejected case against honoring December 25 as public holiday (The Cincinnati Post)
- End is near in Greater Ministries International trickery trial | Church officers accused of bilking Christian investors (The Miami Herald/Associated Press)
- Dreamer or con man? | He preached the good news of profits (The Cincinnati Post)
- Grenadian archbishop face charges | Courthouse crowded as Baptist leader stands trial for killing 15-year-old girl. (Associated Press)
- Prosecutor asks Missouri high court for access to alleged church confession (Associated Press/Beliefnet)
- Repeal of Caymans' anti-gay laws strains 'partnership' with Britain | Religious outcry over imposed reform is a complex testimonial to the territory's conservative culture and dependence on Mother England. (Los Angeles Times)
- Religious groups hoist red flag over pink rand | Churches call for resignation of Cape Town tourism director (Business Day, Johannesburg, South Africa)
Changes in the Church of England:
- Remarriage ban lifted (The Telegraph, London)
- Queen to loosen grip on Westminster Abbey (The Times, London)
- Commons paves way for priest MPs | The Removal of Clergy Disqualification Bill aims to reverse a 200-year-old law that prevents some current and former ministers of religion from serving in Parliament. (BBC)
Catholicism and the Internet:
- Bishops go online to take the Catholic pulse | Laysurvey.org asks Catholics for feedback on preaching, worship, and other areas of church life (Detroit Free Press)
- Internet's proposed saint may prove to be a godsend | While Isidore looks like a sure thing, groups still lobby for alternates (Chicago Tribune)
- Battling forces of church, state | Some decry the dominance of the Mormon faith as a hindrance to free speech. (The Sun, Baltimore)
- Salt Lake City wrestles with its Mormon roots (The Christian Science Monitor)
Copyright © 2001 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.
See our past Weblog updates: