The recent prolonged firefight in Jersey City left six people dead and raised again the ugly specter of anti-Semitism in America. One of the two assailants who attacked a kosher supermarket was said to have written anti-Semitic posts and has been part of an organization known as the Black Hebrew Israelites that spreads anti-Semitic teachings.
This is the second time this year when the group has come to public attention. The first occurred when a video went viral showing Covington Catholic High School student Nick Sandmann in conversation with Nathan Phillips, a Native American activist, at the Lincoln Memorial. The Washington Post eventually discovered that both Sandmann and Phillips had been goaded and preached at by “a small band of Hebrew Israelites.”
This group, despite and perhaps because of their hate-filled rhetoric, reveals some of the complexity of black-Jewish relationships in America today. My own Christian faith and black identity have made me grasp these tensions even more deeply. And it’s not just me. A recent study conducted by Lifeway Research shows the same.
A Common Heritage—and Divergence
I appreciate the common ground my black community shares with the Jewish community. Both have endured a history of oppression and a history of resisting the evils of prejudice and discrimination. In many ways, the horrors of the transatlantic slave trade and the Holocaust, as well as the racist and anti-Semitic narratives that drove them, frame our imaginations. In addition, black Christians resonate with the God of the Hebrew Bible (what Christians call the Old Testament) and hope in the same stories of faith and liberation.
Years ago, as a student at the University of Pennsylvania, I participated in a group, Alliance Understanding, which brought together black and Jewish students for dialogue and cultural exchange. Our immersive learning experience culminated in a trip to the main Hasidic synagogue in Crown Heights in Brooklyn and the historic, black Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem, which fostered conversations that I’ll never forget.
At the same time, relationships between blacks and Jews have not been without tensions. I have found at times that the points of divergence are more apparent than those of convergence. Sometimes the rush to claim or assume “sameness” of my black experience prevented my Jewish friends from appreciating our historical differences.
The Israel-Palestine conflict is not the primary measure of the state of black-Jewish affairs, but it is significant marker. The Lifeway study, sponsored by the Philos Project, an organization committed to “promoting positive Christian engagement in the Middle East,” found that 7 out of 10 black people “sympathize equally with the hardships Israelis and Palestinians face.” dship. And 42 percent of those surveyed responded “Not sure” to statements like “Israel denies Palestinians basic human rights.” At the same time, 42 percent of African Americans surveyed viewed Israel in a “positive way” while 32 percent were unsure.
Such findings reveal not only the diversity of views within the black community, but also uncertainty about issues facing Israel and Jews. Historically, blacks and Jews have had a close and productive relationship as minorities in the United States. But the relationship has also been fraught with tensions. It’s a complexity I have experienced personally as an African American who lives in Crown Heights, where the two major demographics are ultra-orthodox Lubbavitch Jews and Afro-Caribbeans, and where tensions between the two flared up over 25 years ago.
Historically, if you were critical of Israel, especially if you believed that Jews had disproportionate influence in the US, you were considered anti-Semitic. However, in a racialized society that privileges whiteness, “disproportionate influence” can often be more an expression of race. And yet, it’s without question that antagonism toward Jews and resistance to a Jewish state has a long history. In Nehemiah 2:10 we read:
When Sanballat the Horonite and Tobiah the Ammonite official heard about this, they were very much disturbed that someone had come to promote the welfare of the Israelites.
It’s a pattern we unfortunately witness throughout the centuries and tragically has re-emerged recently in terrorist attacks. At the white supremacist march in Charlottesville in 2017, organizers chanted, “Jews will not replace us!” This legacy of anti-Semitism spreads with a sinister twist today in the teachings of many of the sect known as the Black Hebrew Israelites.
Kendrick Lamar’s highly acclaimed 2016 album, DAMN, became a watershed moment in awareness of this group. Its teachings were featured in the album’s interludes and lyrics, bringing national awareness to the previously obscure group that had been known mostly in New York City. While Lamar himself has not identified himself with this sect, the album caused urban ministers like myself to respond.
In their just pursuit for dignity, members have pressed the black identification with the Jewish people too far. They make the controversial, provocative claim that more or less goes like this: “Not only can Black people draw inspiration from the Jewish people in the Exodus, we are the people of this story, the real Jews.” The Black Hebrew Israelite claim is not simply that some Jews were of African descent (which is true), but also that modern-day Jews descending from Europe (and white people more broadly) are despised Edomites, the hated rivals of the Jewish people in the Old Testament. Black Hebrew Israelites accuse most Jews (especially those who are white) of being impostors, who stripped the true Jews (the African Diaspora who suffered from the transatlantic slave trade) of their identity.
This group is growing, though its social media and internet presence is disproportionately larger than its actual population. Lifeway recorded that 4 percent of the black people it surveyed identified as Black Hebrew Israelites. That would make their population 1.6 million. It’s hard to extrapolate like this based on one survey, but urban apologists like former Hebrew Israelite Muhammad Tanzymore and author Vocab Malone (who wrote a primer on the topic) have shown that this group is one of the fastest-growing sects in the black community. It represents a vocal minority of black people whose appropriation of Jewish identity poses a unique challenge to black-Jewish relationships.
The Palestine Issue
Another unique factor in all this is black identification with Palestine.
In January 2019, civil rights icon Angela Davis was recognized by the Birmingham Civil Rights Institute for her lifetime of civil rights activism. The institute later revoked the award after facing backlash from Jewish communities in light of Davis’s support of the Boycott, Divest, Sanctions (BDS) movement, which staunchly criticizes Israel for its treatment of Palestinians. After a backlash to the backlash, the institute restored the award to Davis.
Footage of unrest in Israel and Palestine resonates with black viewers because it reflects antagonisms between law enforcement and impoverished communities that they have experienced. Davis, like many other progressive blacks, claims that direct parallels can be drawn between racial injustice in the United States and what we witness between Israel and Palestinians.
While there are some similarities, I’ve discovered divergences as well. Until I visited Israel and Palestine, my own views were shaped primarily by what I saw on television; I didn’t have a more nuanced appreciation of the existential threat to their existence that both Jews and Palestinians feel. On my last trip to Israel, I was subjected to increased screening by Israeli security in Tel Aviv. The questioning intensified once I handed over my American passport and they saw my very Arabic name: my Muslim origins caused the flight to be delayed. It is impossible for me to ignore my own experience. And yet, I also learned how the legacy of anti-Semitism and a history of terrorism has required a vigilance of a nation surrounded by political enemies. I left with more questions than answers.
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s words and images are too often employed disingenuously to support a myriad of causes and perspectives, usually without nuance or precision. Pro-Israel advocates can quote from a letter he wrote to the Rabbinical Assembly in 1968 shortly before his assassination:
Peace for Israel means security, and we must stand with all our might to protect its right to exist, its territorial integrity. I see Israel as one of the great outposts of democracy in the world, and a marvelous example of what can be done, how desert land can be transformed into an oasis of brotherhood and democracy. Peace for Israel means security and that security must be a reality.
And at the same time, Michelle Alexander, author of the best-selling The New Jim Crow, referenced King in her strong critiques of Israel in an article in The New York Times earlier this year. She quoted King’s consternation in 1967 when he shared with his advisors his ambivalence about going to Israel:
I just think that if I go, the Arab world, and of course Africa and Asia for that matter, would interpret this as endorsing everything that Israel has done, and I do have questions of doubt.
He ended up canceling his trip. His hesitancy to “endorse everything that Israel has done” is juxtaposed to King’s insistence that “Peace for Israel means security and that security must be a reality.” King’s consternation is one that I often share.
That tension reflects the essential complexity of the black-Jewish relationship in America.
In 2017, I joined a group of pastors invited to experience Israel with the Philos Project. We traveled to Palestine and Israel, heard lectures from Jewish and Palestinian ambassadors about the conflict, and were able to engage in discussion with each other.
One highlight was meeting a community of Ethiopian Jews who made aliyah (immigrated to Israel). They traced their Jewish heritage back to King Solomon, and shared both enthusiasm and frustration about the opportunity to live in a place they had dreamed about. They said, for instance, that they often experienced discrimination—something I could relate to.
While in Jerusalem, I learned about Purim, the Jewish festival celebrating the saving of the Jews as recorded in Esther. When I returned to Crown Heights, I decided to give my Hasidic Jewish neighbors a gift to celebrate when Purim rolled around. As I knocked on their door, I faced the fears that a black man knows when knocking on a white stranger’s door, as well as the awkwardness of a Gentile intruding on an ultra-orthodox home.
As the door opened, I said “Happy Purim” and offered my gift. A gregarious, rotund man with a white beard, white shirt, and black slacks greeted me. The reaction was priceless: shock and confusion. Then he extended his hand and pulled me into his house. He gave me a big bear hug but said he was touched and perplexed by my visit.
I told him that I learned about Purim when I went to Israel. And then he gave me a bigger gift than the one I gave him. He welcomed me as a neighbor.
The Lifeway study revealed that 50 percent of black people don’t have Jewish friends or much engagement with Jewish people. Perhaps the beginning of a more dynamic relationship starts not with tackling the complicated issues of geopolitics, but simply knocking on a neighbor’s door.
Rasool Berry is the teaching pastor at Bridge Church in Brooklyn, serves with Cru, and lives in Crown Heights, Brooklyn.
Find hope and historical insight. For a limited time, explore 60+ years of CT archives for free!
- Daily devotions from Timothy Dalrymple during this pandemic.
- Hundreds of theology and spiritual formation classics from Philip Yancey, Elisabeth Elliot, John Stott, and more.
- Home delivery of new issues in print with access to all past issues online.
- View the complete archive.
- Join now and get print issues access to archive PDFs.