Why Growth is Harder In a Small Church – And Change Is Essential
Big churches find it much easier to incorporate new people because the bigger the crowd, the smaller the impact each person has.

The smaller the church, the harder it is to incorporate new people.

The same dynamic applies to older and more established churches. Here's why.

Everyone who comes into your life changes your life.

The fewer people you know, the greater impact each person has. And the longer you’ve known your current friends, the harder it is for new friends to find where they fit.

In the same way, everyone who comes into a church changes that church.

The smaller the church, the greater impact each person has. The longer the church has been around, the harder it is for new people to know where they fit.

Welcome People, Welcome Change

This is why small churches have a reputation for being resistant to change. A reputation we must change.

It’s in the nature of smaller groups to find it harder to incorporate new people. Unfortunately, some churches make it harder than it needs to be by resisting even the smallest changes that naturally arise from welcoming new people.

Everyone who comes into our church will change it a little.

No, we should never change on foundational theology. But we need to realize that everyone who comes into our church will change it a little.

Every mature believer.

Every nonbeliever.

Every long-time church-goer.

Every wide-eyed seeker.

Mature believers will change us in some ways – maybe with greater wisdom. Seekers will change us in other ways – perhaps to be more patient and loving.

But everyone will change us.

Even Good Change Isn’t Easy

Our church learned this a few years ago when a group of college students started attending. They brought new energy, which everyone welcomed, but they also brought new ideas, new songs and new messes, which not everyone was thrilled about. And they weren’t contributing enough financially to pay for the changes (they were in college, after all).

Plus we knew that, after coming in and upending everything, they’d be gone in four years with no guarantee that another group would take their place.

We were excited by their arrival, but I started noticing some resistance, so I talked with our church leadership about it.

Our leaders acknowledged that the changes weren’t easy, but we felt they were necessary. So we talked it through with the congregation as well. God bless them, they saw that the value of having the college students far outweighed the necessary changes.

We took the leap and welcomed them with open arms. And we were right. The blessings have far outweighed the challenges. (And that first group has been replaced by new blood year after year, by the way.)

Pivot is a part of CT's Blog Forum. Support the work of CT. Subscribe and get one year free.
The views of the blogger do not necessarily reflect those of Christianity Today.

Join in the conversation about this post on Facebook.

Recent Posts

Read More from Karl

Follow Christianity Today

Free Newsletters