Church Leadership
Does Attracting A Crowd Make Discipleship Harder?
Going along with the crowd has never been the Jesus way. Standing apart from the crowd? Now that sounds like Jesus.

Drawing a crowd to church may not be the best way to start people on a path to discipleship.

In fact, I’m beginning to think that it may hurt our discipleship efforts more than help them.

For at least a generation now, the predominant thinking in most of the pastoral training I’ve received has gone like this:

  • Do whatever is needed to attract a crowd
  • Use the opportunity to preach the gospel in a compelling way
  • Know that a significant percentage of the crowd won’t come back, but...
  • If the crowd is big enough, the small percent who stay will be enough to grow your church
  • Those who stay can be discipled

I used to believe that method was the best way to build a strong church. I’m finding it harder to believe with every passing day.

Drawing a crowd may not just be unhelpful in discipleship, but possibly counter-productive to it.

When a person’s first encounter with the gospel (and their second, and their one-hundredth) is as a member of a crowd, they can get a twisted perception of what discipleship means. They start to think that Christianity is about being a passive observer, consumer and judge of religious content.

That perception, once established, is almost impossible to dislodge.

Jesus And Crowds

Leveraging a crowd to recruit a handful of converts/disciples has so many problems with it. But maybe the biggest one is this: it’s actually the opposite of what Jesus did.

Jesus didn’t start with crowds, then winnow them down to a core group. Jesus called a core group, discipled that group and turned that group loose into the world.

Jesus drew crowds. But not because he was trying to. The evidence suggests he was trying not to.

Sure, Jesus’ teaching drew crowds. But not because he was trying to. The evidence suggests he was trying not to.

For instance, as I wrote in The Grasshopper Myth, “The reason Jesus had to perform a miracle to feed the 5,000 was because they were in a ‘remote place’ (Mark 6:3-40) where Jesus had gone to escape the crowds.”

But if Jesus’ mission was to seek and save the lost, wouldn’t he want to draw as many people as possible? And shouldn’t that mean the bigger the crowd, the better? That’s just logical, right?

Apparently not.

Jesus seems to have considered a crowd as a hindrance to discipleship, not as a desired starting point.

Going along with the crowd has never been the Jesus way. Standing apart from the crowd? Now that sounds like Jesus.

Support our work. Subscribe to CT and get one year free.

February 22, 2018 at 3:00 AM

Join in the conversation about this post on Facebook.

Recent Posts
Include results from Christianity Today

Read More from Karl

Follow Christianity Today

Free Newsletters

More Newsletters ...