The Main Way We're Failing Small Churches (And How To Start Succeeding With Them)
Pastoring a small church is not a penalty for doing something wrong. It's a specialty – and it's worth doing well.

Small congregations are the backbone of the church.

Over 90 percent of churches are under 200 people. As many as half of all Christians attend a small congregation.

But if you take a look at the dominant teaching about church leadership, you might think that all those churches are broken, and all those fellow believers are doing something wrong.


Because we're constantly making one big mistake when teaching them about church health and effectiveness. And by making that mistake, we're failing them.

Here's our mistake:

We're not helping small churches be strong, healthy and effective at the size they are now.

We're not helping small churches be strong, healthy and effective at the size they are now. Instead, we're giving them the impression that they need to get bigger first.

Help Small Be Healthy

Think about it. How many books, conferences, podcasts and articles are focused on breaking the 200 barrier without even giving churches under 200 the smallest hint about how to be effective at the size they are currently?

When so much of our teaching is aimed exclusively at pushing small churches to get bigger, we leave good, but struggling churches and pastors with the unintentional impression that there's nothing they can do to be healthy and effective right now.

Small Isn't Broken

To be clear, I have no problem with teaching about how to break growth barriers. Growing above 200 in average attendance is an especially challenging step, and churches need all the help they can get to navigate it successfully.

But the failure in so much of our "breaking barriers" instruction is that we're not just teaching, "if you want your church to break through to the next size, here's how." It feels more like "if you don't break through to the next size, there must be something wrong with you, your church and your leadership."

Certainly, there are many small churches that are stuck, stubborn, and refusing to change. But that's not the case for the majority of them.

Most churches (and certainly most pastors) want to be more healthy and effective. Most want to grow numerically. But when we constantly bombard small churches with a message of "here's how to get bigger", without also encouraging and helping them understand "here's how to be healthy at the size you are now", we're failing them.

Being Great While Small

About the only time most small church pastors hear about the dynamics of how a healthy small church functions is when we want them to drop that style of leadership so they can adapt leadership more appropriate for a larger size.

Pivot is a part of CT's Blog Forum. Support the work of CT. Subscribe and get one year free.
The views of the blogger do not necessarily reflect those of Christianity Today.

February 25, 2019 at 1:00 AM

Join in the conversation about this post on Facebook.

Recent Posts

Read More from Karl

Follow Christianity Today

Free Newsletters