Pagan Christianity (Part 2)

A final editorial interjection into a heated discussion.

Many of you have requested a more formal review of Pagan Christianity, and I feel obliged to provide one. It should be said, however, that Out of Ur is not usually a place for reviews. We offer snippets and opinions and let you guys do the talking. However, this is an important topic, and it deserves a response (in the absence of a true review).

My concern with this book is that it is not what it claims to be. Viola argues that he has presented a careful and thorough exploration of Scripture and Church history. He simply hasn't.

In the chapter "The Pastor," Viola's entire biblical argument against the modern pastorate is based on the fact that the word "pastor" appears only once in the New Testament. He does reference (in parentheses) several other passages, as some of you have noted. But he does not interpret them and allow them to challenge his conclusion. Consider the following (Look these up; I can only list them):

o James 3:1

o 1 Timothy 3:1; 5:18

o 1 Peter 5:2

o 1 Corinthians 9:9

Taken ...

Subscriber access only You have reached the end of this Article Preview

To continue reading, subscribe to Christianity Today magazine. Subscribers have full digital access to CT Pastors articles.

Homepage Subscription Panel

Read These Next

Related
The Wright View of the Resurrection
The Wright View of the Resurrection
Does this theologian indict or vindicate the teaching that goes on in our churches?
From the Magazine
Paul’s Most Beloved Letter Was Entrusted to a Woman
Paul’s Most Beloved Letter Was Entrusted to a Woman
Meet Phoebe, the first interpreter of Romans.
Editor's Pick
How Culture Shapes Sermons
How Culture Shapes Sermons
Recent books on culturally distinct preaching challenge misconceptions and equip diverse pastors to better address a multiethnic world.
close