Jump directly to the Content
Jump directly to the content
Doctrine in the Desert: How Religion Informs the Immigration Debates

Doctrine in the Desert: How Religion Informs the Immigration Debates

Ananda Rose's new book explores the religious motivations of Southwest groups on opposite sides of the immigration question.
Leer en Español

This summary demonstrates one of the two primary contributions of Showdown in the Sonoran Desert. First, Rose's book serves as an introduction to some of the major voices and issues in the immigration debate; Rose writes well, and the mix of personal stories and commentary make for an attractive read. The second contribution is the space given to reflecting on deeper matters of motivation and vision. Groups turn to specific biblical mandates—New Sanctuary Movement, to Numbers 35:11; Humane Borders, to Isaiah 49:10—but the call to be hospitable to the stranger runs through all the groups who serve migrants. Other biblical justifications are found in the image of God, the command to love the neighbor (Lev. 19:18, 33), and the Parable of the Good Samaritan (Luke 10).

A Moral Project

Rose observes that different organizations appeal to diverse texts to base their commitments, and therefore, what matters is not "the full exegetical truth of a given passage's context" but rather "the effect those interpretations have on the larger public stage" (her emphasis). This stance seems to minimize a fundamental challenge among Christians on such matters: the need to evaluate appeals to Scripture on ethical matters. Additionally, Rose's most extensive deliberations on the Other are drawn from a Robert Frost poem, Freud, Sartre, William James, and Emmanuel Levinas—all quite removed from the biblical framework of those interviewed. So while these musings are interesting, there is a philosophical and religious disconnect with her interviewees and the border context. It would have seemed more constructive to explore other Christian theological resources on hospitality and the border, of which there are several of substance.


Rethinking the $3,000 Missions Trip

Rethinking the $3,000 Missions Trip

When I learned that kids in my city couldn't swim, I started to rethink how much I'd invested in overseas missions.
Furniture Fit for the Kingdom

Furniture Fit for the Kingdom

For Harrison Higgins, building beautiful furniture is not simply a steady job but a sacrament unto God.
Faith in a Fallen Empire

Faith in a Fallen Empire

Detroit's list of maladies is long. But some Christians' commitment to its renewal is longer.
'Daddy, Why Do People Steal from Us?'

'Daddy, Why Do People Steal from Us?'

How I answered the question would prove crucial to addressing racial divides in our D.C. neighborhood.

Comments Are Closed

Displaying 1–1 of 1 comments

Jason Lee

September 12, 2012  9:08pm

Jack i thought that was the legal immigration process, where many who want to come to the US have to wait? But good idea about salary being allocated to social security and any other programs. Only question would be if we allow this, how many more "Illegal/Undocumented" individuals will come to this country?


Make a contribution to help support the This Is Our City project and the nonprofit ministry Christianity Today.Learn more ...


RT @MissionYear: A great collection of articles from @ct_city @CTmagazine http://t.co/OLmjHvUIfr

In honor of Kim Newlen, a friend of @ct_city who died Saturday, we share our story of her battle with cancer: http://t.co/S3FGKhVDuo

RT @CTmagazine: After three years, hundreds of stories, thousands of readers, our tribute to This Is Our City: http://t.co/Gz35NhAdqc @ct_c2026

The top 10 stories of @editor @KatelynBeaty picks her favorites and reflects on lessons learned in 3 years: http://t.co/BQxYdaoyD9

"As a community we have to do a better job of rescuing these young people." The newest (and last) City video: http://t.co/vZL0cRKO7H #RVA