Back to Books & Culture Donate to Books & Culture
Subscribe to Books & Culture
Subscribe to Books & Culture

 

Main  |  Archives  |  Contact Us
Site Search

HOLIDAYS & EVENTS
Related Channels
Christianity Today
  magazine

Christian History &
  Biography

Small Groups





Home > Books & Culture > September/October

Sign up for our free newsletter:


Where Did They Go?
The curious history of the Ten Lost Lost Tribes.
Philip Jenkins | posted 9/04/2009



The Ten Lost Tribes: A World History
Zvi Ben-Dor Benite
Oxford Univ. Press, 2009
320 pp., $29.95

I confess to a personal interest in the subject of this book. As my roots are impeccably Welsh, I proudly claim a Hebrew heritage, a connection that is well attested in the Bible. According to Genesis, Noah's son Japheth was the father of Gomer, who in turn begat Ashkenaz. As generations of Welsh and Breton scholars have shown over the past four centuries, these patriarchs were the ancestors of the Celtic and Germanic peoples. Gomer's name is commemorated in the name of the Welsh people, Cymry, of the land itself, Cymru. The Welsh language, Cymraeg, is intimately related to Hebrew, and may represent a primal or archetypal form of the biblical tongue: QED.

Lest the reader be alarmed, I say immediately that I do not accept a word of these claims. Yet I know enough Welsh history to recognize that such a pseudo-history must be treated as far more than loopy rogue antiquarianism, and a similar respect attaches to the many other peoples around the world who, through the centuries, have likewise tried to write themselves into the biblical story. Such assertions particularly characterize small or marginal nations anxious to secure themselves on the global stage. Taken seriously, the claims provide a basis for pride in nation and culture, and often justify writing in a language that might otherwise be regarded as a poor relation of Latin or Greek.

Imaginative pseudo-Hebraism might actually be an essential stage in the construction of national identity and patriotism, and that applies to large nations like the English as well as their smaller neighbors. After the Reformation, as more Christians read the Bible in their own tongues, they sought to graft their own local experience and geography onto the master narrative of the Old Testament, which constituted the gold standard of historical authenticity. As William Blake proclaimed, "Adam was a Druid, and Noah; also Abraham was called to succeed the Druidical age … . All these things are written in Eden." In the 19th century, British theorists sought their roots in the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel, and proudly traced the name of their nation to the Hebrew word brit (covenant) and ish (man). And once you believe that your nation is chosen and covenanted, once you accept that the threats and promises of the Old Testament are directed toward you personally, that creed profoundly shapes your social and political vision, for good and ill. Mythologies have consequences.

As Zvi Ben-Dor Benite shows, the Lost Tribes constitute a mythology that is both potent and enduring. The basic biblical story is familiar enough. Jacob's twelve sons spawned the twelve tribes whose history is that of ancient Israel. Between the 8th and 6th centuries BC, Assyrian and Babylonian kings conquered both the northern and southern kingdoms, massacring and deporting many Israelites. By the time of the Babylonian return from exile, ten of the tribes had effectively vanished from history. Some presumably integrated into nations or kingdoms far removed from Palestine, while others merged with the more famous tribes. Such mergers and acquisitions were a common place feature of ancient warfare and empire-building.

But the missing tribes—Manasseh, Zebulun, Gad, and the rest—were not destined to fade away among history's many other lost peoples. As descendants of the Patriarchs, they also were heirs to all God's promises, while the number twelve continued to symbolize the fullness of the Israelite people. At the end of days, God would gather them in and restore them to the land, and such a restoration would be an indispensable prelude to the End of Time. Isaiah, Ezekiel, and Jeremiah all promised an ingathering of all the children of Israel. Centuries afterward, Jesus chose twelve apostles. According to the gospel source Q, he promised them that, when he came into his glory, they would sit on twelve thrones, judging the full and proper complement of twelve tribes of Israel—not just two or three. Revelation likewise depicts the servants of God who are to be sealed before the final planetary catastrophe as being drawn equally from each of the twelve tribes, which presumably would need to be restored as a prerequisite of that event. And even if the Judgment was not actually at hand, it would be wonderful to track down such lost peoples who might be invaluable allies to God's peoples in time of crisis. Jews indulged in fantasies of contacting the tribes to seek help against persecutors; Christians hoped for allies against Muslims.


Books & Culture
Home  |  Archives  |  Contact Us

Try an Issue of Books & Culture
Free!
Subscribe to Books & Culture
Name
Street Address
City/State/Zip
E-mail Address

No credit card required. Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only. Click here for International orders.

If you decide you want to keep Books & Culture coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive five more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The trial issue is yours to keep, regardless.

Give Books & Culture as a gift

Buy 1 gift subscription, get 1 FREE!

Free Newsletter
Sign up today for the ChristianityToday.com Books & Culture Newsletter
   RSS Feed   RSS Help






XMLRSS Feed












Free Newsletter
Sign up today for the Books & Culture newsletter:





ChristianityToday.com
Home CT Mag Church/Ministry Bible/Life Communities Entertainment Schools/Jobs Shopping Free! Help
Books & Culture
Christianity Today
ChristianityTodayLibrary.com
Christian History Back Issues
Church Law & Tax Report
Leadership Journal
Men of Integrity
Your Church
Church Finance Today
BuildingChurchLeaders.com
ChristianBibleStudies.com
Christian College Guide
Christian History
Christian Music Today
Christianity Today Movies
ChurchLawToday.com
Church Products & Services
ChurchSafety.com
ChurchSiteCreator.com
Kyria.com
PreachingToday.com
PreachingTodaySermons.com
ReducingtheRisk.com
Seminary/Grad School Guide
Christianity Today International
www.ChristianityToday.com
Copyright © 2009 Christianity Today International
Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Advertise with Us | Job Openings