Christian History Home > 2000 > "Kill Them All"
"Kill Them All"
The medieval church was deadly serious about heretics like the Cathars. Author Stephen O'Shea, on the other hand, is only too kind.
"Kill Them All"
By Elesha Coffman, associate editor of CHRISTIAN HISTORY
Though almost no one refers to the entire medieval period as the "dark ages" anymore,
the years from the fifth through the fifteenth century were often gloomy. Western
Christendom battled Islam to the south and east, barbarians to the north and
west, and plagues, famines, and feudal warfare at home. Then there was the problem
of heresy, sprouting both local varieties and exotic foreign species.
Of the former strain, thirteenth-century
Catharism was viewed as perhaps the most poisonous. At least it elicited the
fiercest response. First the Cathars weathered a particularly vicious crusade:
20,000 people were slaughtered in the city of Beziers alone after the monk in
charge of the assault, when asked how to distinguish heretics from Catholics,
replied, "Kill them all, God will know his own." Surviving Cathars then became
the original targets of the Inquisition.
The Cathars receive much
nicer treatment from journalist Stephen O'Shea, who traces their history in
his lively new book The Perfect Heresy: The Revolutionary Life and Death
of the Medieval Cathars (Walker & Company). He labels them "a pacifist brand
of Christianity embracing tolerance and poverty" and groups them with the pre-Protestant
Waldensians as legitimate challenges to an authoritarian church. However, he
also admits that they were "well and truly heretical, by every definition except
their own." Let me just say that I appreciate his narrative more than his judgment.
There's no doubt that the
Cathars, who called Languedoc (now southern France) home, were revolutionary.
Dissatisfied with a church accumulating temporal wealth and authority, they
adopted a gnostic dualism: matter was evil, and salvation lay in sloughing off
the mortal coil after achieving perfection, which might require several reincarnations.
Because matter was evil, everything associated with it was also evil, including
creation (and therefore the Creator of the Old Testament, along with the Old
Testament itself), procreation (and therefore sexual relations), and the Incarnation
(they believed Christ had only a ghostly body). Other church teachings related
to the material world, such as tithing, physical hell, the Resurrection, and
the sanctity of marriage, were at best irrelevant, at worst pernicious.
O'Shea makes sure we understand
the appeal of such notions to those deprived of property and privilege in the
feudal system—especially women. "Not since the time of the gnostics had women
had such a say in the affairs of the hereafter," he writes. "Simple credentes
[Cathar believers who had not yet achieved perfection] could bask in the glory
of their stronger sisters and, more important, take solace in the knowledge
that they were not some sort of afterthought of the divine mind. In any event,
the Evil One had created the world, so the shibboleths of its organization—including
its sexual pecking order—were there to be endured, not endorsed."
While O'Shea can imagine
the frustrations of the Cathars, he cannot comprehend, except in a political
or economic sense, why the church came down so hard on them. He writes that
the Cathar god, "unconcerned with the material, simply didn't care if you got
into bed before getting married, had a Jew or Muslim for a friend, treated men
and women as equals, or did anything else contrary to the teachings of the medieval
Church." Obviously O'Shea doesn't care either, nor does he care what the Christian
God might really be like. What interests O'Shea, and what he does a good job
relating, is the fascinating story of the Cathars and their unorthodox beliefs,
which also now interest groups as diverse as feminists, pacifists, New Agers,
members of the Order of the Solar Temple, and French tourism promoters.
Next week: Sailing to Byzantium,
or, "Who are you calling a heretic?"
Elesha can be reached at
Copyright © 2000 by the author or Christianity Today/Christian History magazine.
Click here for reprint information on Christian History.
Browse More ChristianHistory.net
Home | Browse by Topic | Browse by Period | The Past in the Present | Books & Resources