Jump directly to the content
magcover

Already a subscriber?

Home > Issues > 2010 > Fall > Pastoral Narcissism

It was a silly thing to do, but I couldn't stop myself. During a "get to know you" conversation with a few acquaintances and a man from the church I serve, we were talking about interests, passions, and areas of ministry. I tried to keep the focus on others at the table. But then it happened.

The man from my church made a statement that I interpreted as making light of me. The fuse was lit, and within a few moments I managed to work into the conversation the areas where I was leading and the wide impact of those projects. I subtly reminded everyone what our church had accomplished in the city. I even managed to throw in some attendance figures for good measure. I pushed everyone else out of the conversation's spotlight.

When it was over, I felt like I had binged on junk food. Self-loathing set in: I hate when I do this, and I hate it even more when I do it as a servant of Christ. Why do I keep falling into this temptation?

I've been through this cycle enough to know that when I feel my capacity or identity as a leader isn't sufficiently honored (and when, really, does anyone ever feel that?), I slip into the sin of self-promotion. But how do I stop?

T.S. Eliot wrote, "Half the harm that is done in this world is due to people who want to feel important. They don't mean to do harm, but the harm does not interest them … or they do not see it, or they justify it … because they are absorbed in the endless struggle to think well of themselves."

Although our mission in Christ is to do good in this world, we will actually do harm if our deeper mission is to feel important and "think well of ourselves." Eliot's words forced me to ask, How much harm do I do to my family, my friends, the people I am supposed to lead, all because I want to think well of myself?

Recently I came home to find my wife researching narcissism on the computer. We have been in counseling for a few years and during a session where we discussed my relentless ambition, the phrase "narcissistic leanings" came up. My wife was researching the concept to see if it fit me and what the implications might be for our marriage.

At first she was embarrassed that I caught her, but I was interested as well, so we read the characteristics of narcissism together on the screen.

My immediate thought was, This isn't a problem for me. Narcissism is the adulation of the self, the diminishment of others, and often expressed as reckless ambition. Nothing could be more inconsistent with the character of Christ—the self-sacrificing servant who sought only to do the will of his Father. How can I be a pastor, a servant of Christ, and struggle with this?

But as we read the definitions online, without saying a word we both knew we were reading an accurate description of me. I am a believer and yet I remain a sinner. I am a pastor and I'm often a self-promoter. I endeavor to serve Jesus and I also have narcissistic tendencies.

What I've come to see since that day, is that I am not alone. Many other church leaders share this struggle to one degree or another. We may not all be full-blown clinical narcissists, but we share that bent toward insecurity and selfishness. Most gatherings of pastors will usually include subtle or overt self-promotion. I'm not the only one who has used attendance numbers or new initiatives or "my vision" as a badge of self-importance.

PreviousFirstPage 1 of 4NextLast

From Issue:Ambitions, Fall 2010 | Posted: November 8, 2010

Also in this Issue: Fall 2010

Interrupted by a GorillaSubscriber Access Only

What happens when a teaching church becomes a calling church.

Sex Offenders: Coming to a Church Near YouSubscriber Access Only

How churches, ready or not, are ministering to society's most despised

Love the Ones You're WithSubscriber Access Only

Fantasizing about the congregation you wish you had isn't ambition, but sin.

The Particular CallSubscriber Access Only

Perceiving God's intention for my life.

Not a Subscriber?

Subscribe Today!

  • Monthly issues on web and iPad
  • Web exclusives and archives on Leadership Journal.net
  • Quarterly print issues

Print subscriber? Activate your online account for complete access.

Join the Conversation

Average User Rating:

Displaying 1–3 of 3 comments

jennifer

January 08, 2013  5:51pm

Thanks so much for your honesty. I have battled with narcissism for most of my life. Raised by two narcissistic parents who are pastors I wondered why I've always felt crazy. My parents were approval seeking and gaining approval and accolades was more important than family. the truth or anything else. We were a facade of perfection and superiority while hiding our negative, critical, judgemental loathing of anyone who might try to outdo us or not agree with our high opinion of ourselves. The christian church has a habit of either attracting narcissists or producing narcissists and I didn't escape, I have spent years in counselling and noone can work out what's wrong with me but I know all is not well, I am self promoting, successful, well liked, extremely sensitive to criticism and am cursed with a constant gnawing to prove my self worth to others. I have found answers studying narcissism, and have since been excommunicated from my family for being a narcissists nightmare..honest

Report Abuse

patricia

June 27, 2012  5:30pm

I commend you for your willingness to be real about the struggle with the reality of sin and self worship. I wish more pastors would confess their beggarly condition instead of always trying to appear as if they've reached a state of saintliness that results in deep resentment towards anyone who does not pay homage to their image of themselves. It shuts down truth and reality in church - church which is supposed to be a respository of truth in the inward parts and reality about the struggle with sin and depravity and a place of freeing humility. Instead its a place of denial and deceit and personal kingdom building. I am thankful for this work of the holy spirit in your life and pray for deep repentance in mine too. Without the Spirit, the scales would remain blithely in place and we would never see or want to.

Report Abuse

Sandy Shaw

June 22, 2012  1:45am

Quite right. All pastors are selfish egotist confidence-tricksters below the surface

Use your Leadership Journal login to easily comment and rate this article.
Not part of the community? Subscribe, or on public pages, register for a free account.
Editor's Pick
Where is God on Monday?

Where is God on Monday?Subscriber Access Only

Equipping the church for faith at work.
Sister Sites
Assess the Effectiveness of Your Women's MinistryBuilding Church Leaders

Assess the Effectiveness of Your Women's Ministry