Cult-Watchers: Cult Watchers Adopt Guidelines

Evangelical Ministries to New Religions (EMNR) has adopted a comprehensive manual that establishes guidelines in theology and ethical conduct for member organizations of the countercult network.

“We want to set some standards for the people who are involved in representing the gospel of Christ to people who hold different gospels, to non-Christian groups,” said James Bjornstad, president of emnr, which met in Saint Louis for its annual conference in September.

Leaders said the manual upholds adherence to an accountable Christian lifestyle and the essentials of the faith as outlined in the International Congress on World Evangelization in Lausanne, Switzerland, in 1974.

“We’ve developed ethical standards as well that deal with one’s life, and with their relationship with the church,” Bjornstad said. “We would like to see people in countercult ministries functioning and working within the church.”

The manual includes hypothetical illustrations to guide members, along with procedures to resolve conflicts. Generally, EMNR would recommend a mediator for most disputes. However, EMNR would investigate charges of immorality or ethical misconduct against a member, Bjornstad said.

“This is a mechanism, a way in which we can police ourselves, to make sure we’re not becoming what we’re out to try to correct,” said G. Richard Fisher, a board member for both EMNR and Personal Freedom Outreach (PFO), which cosponsored the annual conference.

Adoption of the guidelines comes after controversies involving several top evangelical leaders in the cult-watching community.

To date, EMNR has not addressed allegations raised a year ago against fellow cult watcher Hank Hanegraaff and the Christian Research Institute he heads in Irvine, California (CT, Nov. 13, 1995, p. 73).

EMNR has also not addressed a dispute that arose after author and cult-watching leader Ron Enroth characterized Jesus People U.S.A. (JPUSA) leadership as overly authoritarian. Enroth is one of emnr’s founders, and Eric Pement, editor of JPUSA’s Cornerstone magazine, is a longtime emnr board member.

If the charges are revisited now and brought before EMNR, the manual’s procedures will be implemented, Bjornstad said.

EXTRABIBLICAL ALERT: At this year’s “The Culting of Christianity” conference, Fisher said the church is losing the knowledge of a systematic study of Scripture. “Hermeneutics today is reduced to one sentence: The Spirit told me,” Bjornstad said.

Many in the church no longer view the Bible as “adequate for godliness and maturity,” Fisher observed. Consequently, he said, the door is opened to thought that relies on extrabiblical experiences.

Fisher referred to some authors on demonology who reason that it cannot be biblically proven that Christians can be inhabited by demons. These authors use clinical psychological evidence to back up their assertions.

“The term ‘clinical evidence’ is shorthand for their experiences,” Fisher said, “or their interpretation of their experiences.”

EMNR workshops discussed the growing number of dangerous alternatives to biblically based teachings. Stephen F. Cannon, a PFO board member, noted aberrations in the International Churches of Christ, formerly known as the Boston Church of Christ movement.

The group, founded in 1979 and led by Kip McKean, claims to be alone in teaching the “correct gospel,” he said. “They have a very strict hierarchy, they have an absolute leader,” Cannon said. “They teach basically salvation by works: You have to be making disciples.”

Al Baird, one of the elders at the affiliated Los Angeles Church of Christ, disputed the allegations that his group is cultic, that 42-year-old leader McKean is abusively authoritarian, and that the movement follows a salvation-by-works doctrine.

“We believe there is an accepting of Jesus that involves more than praying Jesus into your heart or more than praying a ‘sinner’s prayer,’ ” Baird told CT. There are 255 International Churches of Christ in 97 nations, with more than 133,000 attending Sunday services.

Overall, Bjornstad said EMNR wants to maintain a loving relationship with those it finds to be off base. “We’ve been able, sometimes, with the groups, to effect some change,” he said. “And that’s really what we’re looking for.”

Copyright © 1996 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Last Updated: October 10, 1996

Also in this issue

When God Declares War: The Violence of God can only be understood in the shadow of the Cross.

Cover Story

When God Declares War

Daniel G. Reid and Tremper Longman III

College Pays Millions in Taxes

Voucher Opponents Vow to Gut Cleveland Program

Beijing U: China Educators Launch First Religion Department

Tony Carnes in Beijing

Why Not Gay Marriage?

CHARLES COLSON & Nancy Pearcey

Muslim Separatists Sign Peace Accord

David Reid Miller in Manila

Ecuadorian Martyrs Story on Stage

Habitat Builds 50,000th Home

John W. Kennedy

Court Voids Holiday Exemption Law

Timothy C. Morgan

Call to Renewal: Does Call to Renewal Skirt Partisan Politics?

Richard A. Kauffman in Washington, D.C.

New Film Lionizes Hustler's Flynt

Julia Duin

Pizza, Baptism Don't Always Mix

Richard Abanes

Grace Note

Learning to Love Israel's God

William H. Willimon

The Gospel Bassoon

J.I. Packer

The Possibilities of Imperfection

Tsvi Blanchard

Why We Worship

Kathleen Norris

News

News Briefs: October 28, 1996

Christian Coalition: Christian Coalition Moves Ahead Despite Political Growing Pains

Kim A. Lawton in Washington, D.C.

Congress: Clinton Signs Law Backing Heterosexual Marriage

Kim A. Lawton in Washington, D.C.

Churches Fight Overseas Child Labor

Ethics and Business:Holding Corporate America Accountable

Dale D. Buss

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from October 28, 1996

Elizabeth Dole’s Fishbowl Faith

Kim A. Lawton in Washington, D.C.

The Living Bible Reborn: Tyndale's 50th Anniversary

John Wilson

Bill Moyers's National Bible Study

Indiana Jones and the Gospel Parchments

Gary Burge

Our Lifeline

J. I. Packer

Editorial

Why We Still Need Luther

Editorial

Butt Out

Letters

News

News Briefs: October 28, 1996

View issue

Our Latest

The Bulletin

Sunday Afternoon Reads: Lord of the Night

Finding God in the darkness and isolation of Antarctica.

The Russell Moore Show

Why Do Faithful Christians Defend Harmful Things?

Russell answers a listener question about how we should perceive seemingly harmful political beliefs in our church congregations.

The Complicated Legacy of Jesse Jackson

Six Christian leaders reflect on the civil rights giant’s triumphs and tragedies.

News

The Churches That Fought for Due Process

An Ecuadorian immigrant with legal status fell into a detention “black hole.” Church leaders across the country tried to pull him out.

The Bulletin

AI Predictions, Climate Policy Rollback, and Obama’s Belief in Aliens

Mike Cosper, Clarissa Moll, Russell Moore

The future of artificial intelligence, Trump repeals landmark climate finding, and the existence of aliens.

Troubling Moral Issues in 1973

CT condemned the Supreme Court ruling in Roe v. Wade and questioned the seriousness of Watergate.

Ben Sasse and a Dying Breed of Politician

The former senator is battling cancer. Losing him would be one more sign that a certain kind of conservatism—and a certain kind of politics—is disappearing.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastprintRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube