Ideas

Church Divorce Done Right

Columnist

Denominational splits just aren’t what they used to be.

When I asked Orlando Sentinel religion reporter Mark Pinsky if he’d covered the February meeting where as many as 150 Presbyterian Church (USA) congregations made plans to leave the denomination, I wasn’t terribly surprised when he answered no.

The New Wineskins meeting was within walking distance from his office, Pinsky said, but “we sense some fatigue among general readers on the ‘maybe this mainline denomination will split’ story. Editors are saying, ‘Get back to us when there is a split.’ It’s the Lucy and the football thing from Peanuts.”

It’s a sentiment shared widely by religion reporters, including many of us here at CT. Rarely does a week go by that we don’t hear rumors of denominational departures. But discussion and dissatisfaction typically trump actual decisions to leave.

Not that the mainline exodus is a myth. Within the past year, entire regions of the American Baptist Churches USA, representing hundreds of churches, dropped their ties to the national body. Due to a few dramatic votes, the departures got more attention than 225 congregations that left the United Church of Christ (UCC). They left after the UCC adopted a resolution in July 2005 that endorsed same-sex marriage. The 67 “Faithful and Welcoming” orthodox churches who work from within the UCC face an uphill battle for mere tolerance: The denomination’s official blogger, on the UCC’s site, characterized one such group as dedicated to destroying the UCC from the inside.

Though not universal across the mainline, the exodus seems to be happening on a scale not seen since the fundamentalist-modernist battles of nearly a century ago. That’s fundamentalist in the historical sense, referring to the group of orthodox Protestants who opposed the rise of scientific naturalism in their churches and held to the fundamentals of the faith, like the reliability of the Bible and the reality of miracles.

When theologian J. Gresham Machen led traditionalists out of the Presbyterian Church, they created a new denomination: the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. But today, New Wineskins rejected such a plan and instead has begun negotiations to join the Evangelical Presbyterian Church.

Likewise, many churches that split with the Episcopal Church in earlier times accepted broken ties with the worldwide Anglican Communion. Today’s orthodox exiles, by contrast, make membership in global Anglicanism non-negotiable. A mélange of archbishops leads them from abroad. Thanks to these archbishops’ efforts, some of the earlier breakaway groups are now pursuing reunion with the global body.

It’s not that today’s evangelical evacuees are less entrepreneurial than yesterday’s; it’s that they’re less satisfied with independence and informal parachurch networks. Even those who form new networks don’t shape them like those of their fundamentalist predecessors, who equated leaving with disfellowshipping. Some fundamentalists attacked orthodox believers who stayed in denominations as betrayers and collaborators. By contrast, the new Cornerstone Church Network, the successor to the renewal group at the center of the American Baptist exodus, is open to both current and former American Baptist congregations.

There are many reasons for such magnanimity between the orthodox who leave and those who stay. Remembering the antipathy from earlier departures is surely one of them. But so is hope. The walkouts know that mainline renewal from the inside can be successful, as seems to be happening in the United Methodist Church, for example. And recent events in the Anglican Communion belie the narrative of continual decline toward liberalism.

Episcopal bishops’ reaction to the February meeting of Anglican primates may reveal the biggest difference between the fundamentalist exodus and today’s. Machen lamented that liberals of his day were dishonest in reciting “I believe” creeds they did not really believe. That’s still true. But now Episcopalians are complaining that they’re forced to choose between “staying true to our understanding of the inclusive gospel or staying true to our commitment to being a constituent member of the Anglican Communion.”

They’re starting to get it. It is they, not conservatives, who have been leaving all along.

Copyright © 2007 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere:

A version of this column originally ran in the March 2007 print edition of Christianity Today. The column “Tidings” was formerly called “Weblog in Print.” Earlier columns by Ted Olsen include:

Why Isn’t ‘Yes’ Enough? | The fuss over swearing-in ceremonies reveals a deeper problem. (Feb. 23, 2007)

Bottom-Up Discipline | What do you do when your pastor—or your entire denomination—strays? (Jan. 16, 2007)

The Year Conservatives Saved Christmas | We bullied stores out of “Happy Holidays.” Hooray? (Dec. 8, 2006)

What Really Unites Pentecostals? | It’s not speaking in tongues. It may be the prosperity gospel (Dec. 5, 2006)

Does Islam Need a Luther or a Pope? | American pundits debate whether centralized religious authority restrains violence. (Oct. 20, 2006)

Asylum vs. Assistance | Offering sanctuary isn’t about political protest. (Sept. 26, 2006)

We’re Not Spectators | Mideast Christians writing for our website expressed their anguish—and anger. (Aug. 28, 2006)

Latter-day Complaints | Mormons and evangelicals fret over movies, politics, and each other. (Jul. 6, 2006)

Peace, Peace | From the front page to the obits, one day’s news about Christian peacemaking. (Apr. 18, 2006)

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

Passion Takes It Higher

The Joy of Policy Manuals

News

Cleaning Up La Oroya

The Road to Healing

An End to the Creation/Evolution Wars?

Picture Christ

Declaration of Interdependence

Window into the Bible's Land

Islam's Silent Majority

A Manifold Resurrection

Resurrected Life

Henry Ward Beecher's Life and Times

News

Living with Islamists

Football Family Values

Desire Happens

Throwing Rocks at Israel

Review

Surfing for Spirituality

Relentless Pursuit

Bizzare-istan

News

Quotation Marks

Editorial

'Safe Sex' for the Whole Nation

News

Go Figure

Life, Liberty, and Terrorism

News

News Briefs: April 01, 2007

News

Nigeria's Touchy Transition

Learning to Cry for the Culture

News

Global Ultimatum

News

Love Your Muslim as Yourself

Ready to Implode?

News

'Destroy the Christian Religion'

CTI's Modest Dynamic Duo

News

Ireland's Evangelical Moment

News

Passages

Q&A: Albert Mohler

No Exceptions

Religion Sections Deleted

View issue

Our Latest

Inside the Ministry

The Next Generation Is Ready. Are We?

See how CT is investing in the next generation of the Church—and how you can, too.

The CDC Listened to Vaccine-Hesitant Moms in My Living Room

I was surprised to find myself hosting an off-the-record chat with people worlds apart on public health. But I hope that night was a seed of something new.

The Russell Moore Show

Listener question: Why Aren’t Christians Engaging in Humanitarian Aid?

Russell takes a listener’s question about the crisis of humanitarian aid and why Christians are not stepping in to help.

New Archbishop of Canterbury Steps into Anglican Divides

Conservatives call on Sarah Mullally, the first woman at the spiritual helm of the Church of England, to uphold biblical faith amid same-sex blessings debate.

News

FDA Approves Generic Abortion Pill

Students for Life leader calls the move “a stain on the Trump presidency.”

You Haven’t Heard Worship Music like This

John Van Deusen’s praise is hard-won and occasionally wordless.
Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube