Church Life

In Secular UK, Evangelical Alliance Experiences Record Growth

Leader explains why the movement is seeing its biggest membership bump in 30 years and its mission for the years ahead.

Christianity Today April 17, 2024
Illustration by Christianity Today / Source Images: Getty

As CEO of the United Kingdom’s Evangelical Alliance (EA), Gavin Calver sometimes compares the organization to the polarizing British breakfast spread Marmite: You either love it or you hate it.

The EA hears plenty from its critics, taking hits for stances on issues like transgender identity, and is calling on Christians who love them from a distance to actually join.

“We’re asking, ‘Will you please stand with us as someone who loves Marmite, not dislikes it?’” Calver said. “In our culture, it makes it a little lighthearted, but it needs very little explaining. People get it quickly.”

More churches, organizations, and individuals are responding to the call, and after record growth in the past year, the tally of dues-paying individual members recently topped 23,000. The total is a signal of the group’s influence to government officials and societal leaders, allowing the EA to represent evangelicals more effectively in the wider culture.

Many of the new individual members signed up when EA representatives spoke at member churches, so much of the recent growth “reflects the constituency we already have,” according to Calver. Still, the EA’s membership is becoming more ethnically diverse and trending younger, he said, with most of its growth happening “beyond the southeast of England where we were strongest to start with.”

Calver recently spoke to CT about his vision for the EA, why so many new members are signing up now, and how evangelicals in the UK are staying united despite their differences.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

For readers outside of the United Kingdom, could you give a brief overview of the UK evangelical landscape?

The UK evangelical landscape is quite diverse. For example, 25 percent of UK evangelicals are people of color. Within the Evangelical Alliance membership alone, there’s 80 different streams, networks, and denominations of church represented.

One of the great joys in my job is I get to preach in lots of these places, and the first worship song on a Sunday morning tells you where you are: how charismatic an environment, how free an environment.

We have egalitarians as well as complementarians within our membership. There’s a great diversity within it. … Like many evangelicals globally, Bebbington’s quadrilateral kind of sums us up: Hold firm to Scripture; the death and resurrection of Jesus; we’re desperate to see people converted, to reach the lost; and we want to be active in making the world like the kingdom.

https://twitter.com/GavCalver/status/1780275019093868597

You recently shared that the EA had hoped to recruit 3,000 new individual members during its past fiscal year (which concluded at the end of March), but that membership had actually increased by over 5,000, the fastest growth since the 1990s. What factors do you think are driving this growth?

We’ve really started asking again. There was a while where the EA perhaps took its foot off the gas a little bit with this. Another factor is we can’t ignore the current landscape where you could argue that some parts of the church are baptizing the culture a little, and that means the distinctiveness that evangelicalism offers brings hope. I think we are clear on stuff.

Certainly, in the UK, our access to the corridors of power is amazing. I was at [the prime minister’s residence] 10 Downing Street last week. We’re in and out of Westminster and the four governments of the UK all the time. We get to take people’s voices to somewhere they wouldn’t get otherwise.

The EA here has only really existed for two things since 1846 when it was formed: unite the church in reaching the lost in every corner of the UK, and secondly, give the church a clear and effective voice into the corridors of power. I think a lot of people are wanting their voice to be heard, and by joining the EA, we add their voice as we go into those places.

Does this strong rate of growth change your vision for the EA in the coming year? Or in the next ten years?

It doesn’t change it, but it speeds it up. … Last year I said to my board, “If you let me set a ten-year direction for where we want to go, I’ll stay for a decade to see it through.” The plan can be summed up in one sentence, and that doesn’t change. Basically, we need to stand firm theologically, whilst going for it wholeheartedly in sharing the gospel.

I know people that are good at one of those: I know great theologians who don’t know a non-Christian. And I know people who say they want to share the gospel but don’t know Scripture. Those two must go together. We must hold our nerve theologically. Do not compromise on the things that matter in the Word of God, no matter what the price tag within your culture, and then go for it wholeheartedly in sharing the gospel. For me, that’s the next ten years at the EA.

Let me be honest, if we had gotten to 3,000 new members in a year, that would have been the most in a long time. With 5,000, the Lord’s blown out of the water what we thought was possible.

A year ago, you told the Religion Media Centre that more Anglican churches would probably join the Evangelical Alliance because of that communion’s debate over blessings for same-sex couples. The Church of England subsequently approved those blessings and began offering them for the first time in December. Have these developments in fact spurred more evangelical Anglican individuals and congregations to join the EA?

We’ve seen more Anglican churches joining us than normal, and when I’ve preached in Anglican settings, we’ve seen more individuals join us than normal. So, there is no doubt that for those who are wanting to stay within the Church of England, they’re also looking for a home with us as well, and that’s exciting. … There’s no happiness on our part that [these developments have] led to that, but we are here to serve and support.

A lot of our work is advocacy. You have [Church of England] bishops in the House of Lords here, so why would an Anglican church need the advocacy of the EA historically? Now they’re not sure that their bishop is always going to say what they believe. So yes, what we predicted a year ago has come to fruition.

The EA describes itself as an “evangelical unity movement.” Evangelicalism in the US has often seemed very divided in recent years. Do you think that UK evangelicals have been able to maintain a stronger sense of solidarity? If so, why?

Look, you can pick up the UK and drop it in Lake Michigan and it doesn’t touch the sides. So let’s be realistic about the scale of where we are. Because the nation is small enough, you can have the relationships, and there’s a unity. Also, in the UK, we’ve lost our churchgoing culture. We unite or we die, so we’re united. Is that pragmatic? Is it a message from the Lord? It’s probably a bit of both. But we can’t afford competition within the kingdom.

And we don’t have quite the same marrying between evangelicalism and politics. That is quite liberating. We have a member of Parliament for the Labor Party and a member of Parliament for the Conservative Party serving on the Evangelical Alliance council. Both are members of the EA, members of our council, and represent us more widely. I don’t think that would quite happen in the same way in some other parts of the world.

Previously, you led Youth for Christ in the UK and before that served as a youth worker with that organization. How did serving in youth ministry mold you as a leader?

I learned to preach in school assemblies (you can’t do those in the US, but we can go to schools and do assemblies) and youth prisons. When people ask now if I’m nervous about preaching to a large crowd, the answer is no. I was nervous about preaching to 1,000 teenagers at a school who didn’t want to listen, or to 50 teenage lads who were imprisoned.

So firstly, there was a real grounding to it. Secondly, in youth ministry, you have to innovate. The average church leader in the UK lasts seven to ten years. The average youth worker might last a couple of years. And the reason for that is youth culture changes four times as rapidly as adult culture. The most tiring thing in ministry is reimagining. It’s not about substance, it’s about contextualization. Reimagining to reach a [different] generation. I learned skills by doing that in youth ministry that are helpful to no end in what I do now.

When you work in youth ministry … you get empowered early. And that’s important, because when Jesus wanted to change the world he started a youth group, not an elder board. According to the late John Stott, the disciples were 15 to 22 years old. I think that’s really challenging to us, because sometimes in the church if you’re not old enough, you’re not good enough.

You have set a goal of having 50,000 total individual EA members within the next decade. What gives you confidence that this is achievable, and what potential obstacles do you see to reaching that target?

The last year gives us some confidence. I think the UK is crying out for a brave and kind Evangelical Alliance that can steer them through the storms, that can keep the main thing the main thing, which is about people meeting Jesus.

But we’ll also take stands on the important issues of our time from marriage to abortion to end of life care to racial injustice and everything in between. As long as we stay on mission, and we don’t drift, and we keep our focus, and we spend more time on our knees than on our feet, I’m confident that the Lord is with us and we’ll get there.

There are quite a few obstacles. We’re living in a secular tsunami. It’s a very contested culture. There are fewer Christians in the UK than before. I’m believing for a major movement of God, but we can’t currently claim to be in one.

Another obstacle is that the UK has an aging population. Let’s be honest, of the 23,000 members we currently have, how many of those will still be alive in ten years? I don’t want to start doing that math, but some are going out the back door as well as through the front door … I have confidence that the Lord’s got this, but only a fool would look at our culture and think there are no obstacles.

Church Life

Haitians Are Ministering at the End of the World

As Haiti is uprooted by violence, church leaders treat gunshot wounds, give up homes for strangers, and rescue dignitaries.

A man identifies a body after an overnight shooting in the Port-au-Prince suburb of Pétion-Ville in March.

A man identifies a body after an overnight shooting in the Port-au-Prince suburb of Pétion-Ville in March.

Christianity Today April 16, 2024
Odelyn Joseph / AP Images

Pastor Frederic Nozil has learned to keep his head down.

Last year, the year he turned 53, gangs attacked his neighborhood in Pétion-Ville, a suburb overlooking Haiti’s capital, Port-au-Prince. They ransacked the house Nozil was renting and set it on fire. Nozil moved with his wife and two daughters to a safer community a couple of miles away.

Still, he took few chances. This year, he turned 54 at home, quietly. A handful of people from his church brought a cake. They stayed no more than an hour. “Parties attract attention,” Nozil said. “You can’t celebrate too much.”

He schedules church activities to wrap up before a mandatory curfew. He will cut a prayer service short if he has a bad feeling about a police vehicle he noticed on the street. Some of his congregation risk their lives crossing gang checkpoints on their way to the church, the Centre Chrétien International Maison d’Adoration, so he knows to expect a smaller turnout.

Ministry looks different, he figures, at the end of the world. “We are living in an eschatological time,” Nozil said.

That’s how it felt in the early hours of March 18. It was a Monday, and the bespectacled minister should have been recovering from the usual slate of Sunday demands. Instead, he shut himself in his home for two days straight as heavy gunfire echoed through the hills.

Gang members in balaclavas wound past Nozil’s neighborhood in cars and motorcycles, ascending the main road into the mountains. They shot automatic weapons and left at least a dozen pedestrians dead in their wake. They stopped in a wealthy enclave called Laboule and laid siege to its walled residences. In one home, security cameras recorded armed young men with backpacks as they forced their way into a paver-stone courtyard and peered into parked SUVs.

In a home nearby, a man escaped the assailants, and then—because anything can happen at the end of the world—he made a desperate phone call to a pastor 1,600 miles away.

Roselin “RoRo” Eustache was driving home from Walmart when Miradin Morlan’s name flashed on his phone. Eustache had been stuck in Houston for months, staying with family, unable to return to Haiti because gangs have closed the nation’s main international airport and blocked every route to his home and the mission he runs there.

When he saw the call from an old acquaintance—the former head of the Direction Générale des Impôts, Haiti’s equivalent of the IRS—he picked up to hear a panicked plea: Pastor, save my life!

Morlan explained he and his wife were fleeing Laboule on foot. Gangs had broken into their home, held him at gunpoint, tried to kidnap him, and stripped the rooms bare. They stole his cars. His private security guards ran for their lives.

As he put distance between himself and his attackers, Morlan remembered the hospital at Eustache’s mission, a place in Haiti’s south where he had once had knee surgery. The pastor had helped him before; would he do it again? Eustache arranged for a driver to meet them.

The couple took a hired motorcycle over a mountain pass and along a road that in spots is little more than a hiking trail. At one point, Morlan’s wife fell and broke her arm. After hours of travel, perhaps 20 miles, they met the driver in a town called Seguin, at the piney edge of one of Haiti’s few national parks.

“I am still in shock,” Morlan said, days later in a countryside hideout where he was struggling to find even toilet paper. “It’s really incomprehensible.”

Except, tragically, it is not.

Forced displacements are ubiquitous among the nearly 4 million people in and around Port-au-Prince. Gangs control more than 80 percent of the city, where roughly a third of Haitians live. The bandits, as many Haitians refer to them, have killed more than 1,500 people in the first three months of 2024 alone.

At least 362,500 Haitians have fled gang violence so far, according to the United Nations. Gunmen have driven residents from slums. From rural villages. From gated communities. From farms.

Mass displacement is reshaping everyday life far beyond the violence-racked capital. Gangs have outgunned the national police and pushed north, to Haiti’s quilted rice fields, and west, toward horizons outlined by plantains and sugarcane.

The ongoing violence compounds a hunger crisis that has left more than a million Haitians at risk of starvation. It is wiping out families’ savings and straining resources in already stretched communities.

Last month was the worst yet: More than 53,000 Haitians were forced from their homes. For pastors like Nozil and Eustache and Christian leaders across Haiti, displacement—really, the upending of their entire universe—has come to redefine ministry.

“This is my whole life,” Eustache told CT. Some staff at his mission, Haitian Christian Outreach, have been displaced as many as four times, migrating between schools and other public facilities that have morphed into shelters as gang boundaries shift.

Local police have turned to the mission, one staff member said. Some officers have not been paid for months, and they are struggling to find food and beds for those who were sleeping on the precinct floor. The mission had helped in the past, even loaning police Land Cruisers when their vehicles were broken down.

“I need to do something,” Eustache said. “Because whenever we need them, they’re there for us.”

Haitians often vent their dissatisfaction with politicians through a saying: rache manyok. Translated literally, it means “tear out the manioc.” It’s what a farmer does when he grabs the long stem of the plant also known as cassava and wrings it from the red dirt, tuber to leaf.

For decades, rache manyok has been shouted in street protests and deployed against elected leaders on social media. So has a punchier, related word: dechoukaj, or “uprooting.”

But Haiti has no elected leaders now; it has not held elections in eight years. In that enduring power vacuum, experts estimate that as many as 200 gangs arose.

In February, many of the gangs cemented an alliance that enabled them to vandalize government offices and break open the nation’s two largest prisons. They have threatened to complete their conquest by occupying the main airport and the National Palace, Haiti’s iconic seat of government.

This week, a new nine-member transitional governing council is beginning the task it has been handed by the United States and the 15-nation Caribbean Community: quell the violence and, by some miracle, prepare the country for elections again.

They inherit a nation being uprooted.

If you wanted to mark the destruction in Haiti with pins on a giant map, you would probably start in Port-au-Prince. You’d stick a dozen pins on the pharmacies that gangs burned near the General Hospital downtown and most of its medical facilities, which are largely inoperative.

Eventually you’d put a pin in the former campus of the Evangelical Theological Seminary of Port-au-Prince, a rare wooded oasis with a gleaming academic building that was finally rebuilt after the 2010 earthquake, only to be seized by gangs three years later in 2020.

You’d pin churches that have been burned or had windows smashed, and factories and car dealerships. You’d pin the vandalized National School of the Arts and the looted National Library, a repository of historical documents from the world’s first Black republic.

After you covered most of the capital in well over a thousand pins, you could pick almost any route out of the city and trace the decimation along the way. If you took Route Nationale 1 for a few miles, you would tag several looted compounds of American missions groups.

Near the town of Titanyen, you’d drop a pin on the campus of Christian Aid Ministries, where a group of kidnapped Anabaptist missionaries were tearfully reunited with loved ones after escaping in late 2021 and where, only months later, gangs took control of the property. Next door, at the compound of a Mississippi-based ministry, gangs punched a hole in the concrete perimeter wall, emptying shipping containers and peeling solar panels from rooftops.

All of that pinning, and you would fail to even scratch the surface. You would still be five miles from the town of Cabaret, where the police station, like many police stations before it, burned in early March.

Cabaret is a small regional hub, a town shaped like an amphitheater at a crook in the highway. What people remember is that on March 3, no one’s phones were working—fuel shortages and roadblocks often prevent cellular providers from powering their towers.

Around lunchtime, a father in the market heard someone yell, “The men are coming!” He rushed home, grabbing his four children and running. As they sprinted through gunfire, his seven-year-old son was shot in the leg.

Oltina, one of the few Cabaret residents CT interviewed for this story who was willing to give her name, had fled another town less than a month earlier. She was outside when the shooting erupted around her. Racing to find her kids, she tripped on a pot of beans cooking over a fire and burned her foot in the boiling water. For several hours she hid with her two children in a garden.

Another woman said she watched bandits kidnap her husband as she escaped with their two-month-old son.

Houses burned. Stores and market stalls—the fruit of years of labor—were abandoned. Life savings and passports and family photographs were lost as an entire community fled into the mountains.

With no phones and no way to coordinate, the displaced scattered from Cabaret, heading wherever instinct guided them or wherever they thought they might know someone.

In a village roughly eight miles away, a young mother opened her door to an older woman she had never seen before. The stranger had four children in tow, and her husband had been fatally shot in the stomach trying to defend their home in Cabaret. Their relatives in the village had no room for them.

“Pretend this is your house,” said the young mother, who asked that neither she nor her town be identified for fear that gangs would target her neighborhood.

In the same community, another woman, a twenty-something who works at the American-run ministry Real Hope for Haiti, arrived home to find more than a dozen people from Cabaret. A friend suggested they would be welcome at her place.

The ministry employee hosted 17 refugees in her two-bedroom home. She gave up her own bed. She sleeps elsewhere for now, swinging by each day to pack the clothes she needs in a plastic bag. In the evenings she prays with her houseguests; one of them, a young girl, has been suffering from panic attacks.

“Taking in strangers is hard,” the woman said. “But if God welcomes everyone, we can welcome a few people who are trying to escape from gangs.”

An official in her town estimated that several thousand people have been displaced to the village over the last year. Locals have grown accustomed, to the degree anyone really can, to outsiders roaming their streets, asking for food or a place to sleep.

At the ten churches around town, pastors say attendance is up. Some services are overflowing, with worshipers bringing their own chairs. Churches have tried to adopt displaced families to care for. People have cut bananas and breadfruit from their gardens and brought them to the sojourners. They have donated rugs and woven mats for sleeping.

Church leaders across the country report similar situations, especially in the south, where the UN says most displaced people have fled to this year.

But Lori Moise, who directs Real Hope for Haiti’s clinic, cautions that people should not get the impression that some spiritual awakening is underway, like she remembers happening after the 2010 earthquake.

“There are many who wholeheartedly hold fast to God. Others have left the church because they don’t see him answering their prayers and the suffering is unrelenting,” said Moise, whose clinic has treated gunshot wounds in survivors from several communities in recent years.

“When the gang violence first started, people prayed more and spoke of God more. I see despair falling on most people now. One quality foreigners remark about the Haitian people is their resilience and hope. I sense both are waning.”

The number of internally displaced Haitians has grown, at least partially, because leaving the country has grown extremely difficult. The main international and domestic airport in Port-au-Prince has been closed since early March, after parked aircraft were struck with bullets. The neighboring Dominican Republic has shut its border to Haitian nationals.

But it is only a pause; the flight of Haitians abroad will resume as soon as airline ticket counters reopen.

Haitians who already fled to South and Central America are driving record asylum applications in Mexico. And in the United States, 168,000 Haitians have been granted temporary residency through a Biden administration humanitarian parole program that began last year. Among them are thousands of Haiti’s best and brightest.

Almost everyone has stories of those who have left: a church in the north where the whole elder board emigrated; a mission hospital in a central region now missing a third of its staff. Haitian Christian Outreach, Eustache’s ministry, has lost eight employees—including teachers and three doctors—to the program. Pastor Nozil’s entire music team is gone. Reginald Pyrhus, pastor of Église Baptist Bérée in Port-au-Prince, says that half of his middle-class congregation has left the country, many going to the United States.

And they are not the only brain drain underway. An entire generation of college-aged Haitians is currently not entering medical school or law school or other professional programs, or, at the least, have been forced to put studies on hold. Many of those who have completed coursework cannot sit for certification exams, because the exams are not being administered. So if and when medical facilities do reopen, there will be a severe shortage of talent waiting to pick up the mantle.

“This is a big problem,” Eustache said. “It’s going to take us time to find good doctors again.”

It will also be a while before missionaries and other aid workers return. Most pulled out of Haiti years ago, heeding escalating State Department warnings to US citizens. For the few hardy souls who stayed, the March airport closure was a breaking point. Missionaries told stories of evacuations at rural airstrips and helicopter rescues by a private group using the code words Operation: Rum Runner.

David Selvey, the American director of the Haitian American Friendship Foundation, a mission that operates in the country’s central plateau, got out with a group of missionaries who crossed a river into the Dominican Republic in dugout canoes. Someone put him in touch with a Dominican pastor who drove four hours across the country to collect them at the border.

“It’s just amazing to me how quickly God’s people will step up to help people in the family of God who are in trouble or have a problem,” Selvey told CT. “And you don’t have to know them.”

Don Allensworth would like to see a whole lot more people stepping up.

Allensworth is chief development officer of Mission of Hope, a ministry that long operated out of a compound in Titanyen, between Port-au-Prince and Cabaret. Nearby campuses were breached by gangs, so it relocated to Cap-Haïtien in the north.

The ministry’s partners across Haiti are texting reports almost daily. In Jérémie, a city in the southwest, people are waking up to find children and the elderly who died overnight from hunger.

“Haiti is facing the greatest humanitarian crisis in the history of its existence right now, and it is not okay for people to starve to death,” he said. “I don’t care if you’re a Christian or not. If you’re a human, it’s not okay for people to starve to death.”

Once one of Haiti’s largest facilitators of short-term mission groups, Mission of Hope now focuses much of its energy on food aid. With gangs blocking the country’s main seaport, the nonprofit has gone as far as approaching cruise lines to find new ways to ship in the hundreds of thousands of meals it distributes each month.

But Allensworth doesn’t want Mission of Hope to become known as a food agency. He wants the violence to stop and children to return full-time to school, and the organization’s Haitian staff to be able to work without fearing for their lives.

“The Haitian people just want an opportunity to live and make decisions about leading themselves,” he said. “They need to be free.”

To help Haiti’s police liberate the country from the armed groups holding it hostage, the United Nations has sanctioned the deployment of a multinational police force of as many as 2,500 officers. Roughly 1,000 would come from Kenya. Most Haitians support a limited intervention to help stabilize the country, and Haiti’s new transitional council faces strong international pressure to welcome the security mission.

But the operation has hit multiple delays; Kenya has said it will not send the force until partner countries, namely the United States, make good on their promises to underwrite it. Republicans in the US House and Senate have so far refused to approve the $40 million the State Department has pledged to help launch the Kenya-led mission.

“We need to figure out a way to get the dollars that have been allocated to Haiti, to get them there as quickly as we can,” Allensworth said. “Now is the time to write those letters” to senators and congressmen.

Eustache says he does not know how Haiti’s great uprooting will end, or when. He is homesick. He wishes he were back in his country, praying in person with Haitians who have nothing to eat, instead of being stranded in Texas trying to persuade Americans that they have too much to eat.

But the best plan he can formulate right now is to keep telling people how much it hurts to watch his world unravel.

When he speaks about it, he seems at times on the verge of tears. “We need to continue to do what we’ve been doing, making people aware of the situation,” Eustache said. “We cannot let our candle die on us.”

With reporting by Franco lacomini in Brazil and Espeson Toussaint in Haiti.

Andy Olsen is senior editor at CT.

News

Forgotten War: Sudan’s Displaced Christians Brace for ‘World’s Worst’ Hunger Crisis

Interview with leader of new evangelical alliance describes his escape from Khartoum and the pressure to pick a side.

Refugees fleeing from civil war in Sudan arrive at a transit center in South Sudan.

Refugees fleeing from civil war in Sudan arrive at a transit center in South Sudan.

Christianity Today April 16, 2024
Luis Tato / Contributor / Getty

Overlooked by crises in Gaza and Ukraine, Sudan has now endured one year of civil war. Nearly 16,000 people have been killed, with 8.2 million fleeing from their homes—including 4 million children. Both figures are global highs for internal displacement.

The United Nations stated that the “world’s worst hunger crisis” is looming, warning that one-third of Sudan’s 49 million people suffer acute food insecurity and 222,000 children could die of starvation within weeks. Yet an international emergency response plan, endorsed by UN agencies including the Cindy McCain-led World Food Program, is only six percent funded.

Sudanese Christians feel like “no one cares.”

Five years earlier, they had great hope. In 2019 a popular revolution overthrew longtime dictator Omar al-Bashir, wanted for war crimes against his people. The new civilian government repealed the law of apostasy, removed Islamist elements from the bureaucracy, and implemented other democratic reforms. But in 2021 the general of the army, in cooperation with the leader of the Rapid Support Forces (RSF)—a government-aligned paramilitary group accused of the atrocities in Darfur—deposed the prime minister.

Continuing negotiations with civilian leaders demanded a merger of the two armed forces, but neither general could agree on terms. And while it is not clear who fired the first shot, last year on April 15 the conflict exploded in the capital of Khartoum. Much of the North African nation is now a war zone.

Yet somehow, an evangelical alliance has formed and joined two regional bodies.

Rafat Samir, secretary general of the Sudan Evangelical Alliance, witnessed the outbreak of violence firsthand. Now resident in Egypt, he oversaw the dialogue between his own Evangelical Presbyterian synod and the Sudanese Church of Christ, shuttling between safe havens in his home country and in neighboring Ethiopia.

Earlier this month, these denominational partners, which Samir says represent at least 75 percent of Sudanese evangelicals, successively affiliated with the World Evangelical Alliance (WEA) regional associations for both the Arab world and sub-Saharan Africa. Catholics, Anglicans, Coptic Orthodox, and various Protestant denominations account for about 4 percent of the population of Sudan, which ranks No. 8 on the Open Doors World Watch List of countries where it is hardest to be a Christian.

CT asked Samir about the impact of civil war on the church, why its WEA identity exists in two directions, and why his only remaining hope is in God:

Where were you on April 15 last year?

My home is in the Bahri neighborhood, where both the army and the RSF have bases, and antiaircraft guns were firing right outside my bedroom window, with bombing campaigns morning and night. Electricity and water services were cut. As it was Ramadan, one day I went out at sunset to find food, thinking there would be a lull in the fighting. A bullet missed me by mere centimeters.

I wanted to flee immediately, but my brother preferred to wait it out, as we have witnessed clashes before, and he anticipated it would end after a few days, as previously. Bodies lie dead in the streets, and we covered them with sand to suppress the smell. But after enduring these harsh conditions with his wife and two daughters for 15 days, he agreed to leave when a bomb hit his neighboring house.

How did you escape?

We searched three days just to find a vehicle to get us out of the city, and eventually had to pay $500 USD to travel only two kilometers (1.2 miles). We then negotiated getting a small bus with 40 other people to take us to the Egyptian border, but then the driver upped the price upon our arrival to $10,000 total. We had room only for our personal documents, leaving everything else behind.

But leaving Khartoum was entirely dependent on God’s timing.

The battle was still raging, with barrel bombs damaging the road out of town. An earlier bus was stopped by the RSF, who killed the people and stole their money. We heard that, at an army checkpoint, a later bus experienced the same thing. We were lucky—soldiers only searched our vehicles for weapons and simply wanted a bribe to let us move onward.

A friendly family in the city before Egypt gave us a place to sleep and running water. But the next day, the border was so crowded it took us three days to pass through. Some slept in the mosque, others under the scattered trees. When I finally made it to Aswan, an Egyptian friend met me and gave me a place in the German mission hospital guesthouse. He cried when he saw me.

I didn’t know why until I finally settled in and looked at myself in the mirror.

Where are others in your church?

We have over 100 members in our Bahri church. Those who took shelter there were beaten by the RSF when they attacked our building, and they had to flee. Many went to Egypt, others to Ethiopia, Chad, the Nuba Mountains region, or to South Sudan. But there, it is expensive, so several traveled onward to Uganda. A few stayed in Sudan, but renting in-country is also expensive—and for those with children there is no school.

Even a bottle of water costs up to $10.

Everyone is making as much money off this crisis as they can. So, basically, people went where they had family, could find work, or get a visa. But outside of Khartoum, most churches are still functioning. They are not at peace, but they have no possibility to leave. Evangelicals are not from the elite—most believers come from war zones in Sudan. Many don’t have travel documents, and while they can work and eat, they remain poor.

The Church of Christ members are nearly all from the Nuba Mountains, which was at war with the government. Presbyterians are majority Nuba also, with 20 percent originally from South Sudan and another 20 percent from the various tribes. I am of Egyptian descent—others are from Darfur or the Arab north.

How do you manage this diversity?

Identity is a big problem in Sudan. Our country is African, but we speak Arabic. This is why we joined both regional alliances. If you say “Arab” to someone from the Nuba Mountains or South Sudan, it means the people who killed their families, raped their daughters, and tried to Islamize them. But in the north of the country, the Arab is his friend, family, and who he wants to bring to Jesus.

When we started reaching out to Muslims, some from the south resisted, saying: We don’t want to see them in heaven, they don’t deserve salvation. I understand this sentiment. But some of our congregations operate out of their tribal identity and refuse to speak Arabic.

For a long time, many in our country wanted to call ourselves an Arab republic. We are part of the Arab League, but when we need African help, we start calling ourselves Africans. But in the end, we are Africans who speak Arabic, multiethnic in our tribal makeup.

Sudan is a crossover country—some have origins from Yemen and East Africa—and most of us are of mixed heritage. Only the Nuba Mountains and a few others are not. We were even a Christian country until the 14th century, and in the 19th century an eschatological Muslim movement killed many Christians and forced others to convert to Islam.

Presbyterian missionaries came in 1899 and started the first schools for girls, agriculture, and vocational training. The Church of Christ was established in 1920 and is the largest evangelical denomination today. But Sudan is neither a Muslim country nor a Christian country, and likewise, neither Arab nor African entirely.

We joined the Middle East and North Africa Evangelical Alliance because we speak Arabic and face similar issues with Islam and government discrimination. We joined the Association of Evangelicals in Africa because we face the same issues with ethnic identity. I checked with WEA regional leadership—it is not a problem to belong to two alliances.

How has the church been able to help?

The main thing we did was help people escape and find shelter.

Our schools in Wad Madani (100 miles southeast of Khartoum) received families and provided basic meals and trauma care. All the homes are full of those displaced from Khartoum, but then when the war reached this area, many were dislocated again eastward to other cities and Port Sudan. We also helped 15 Muslim-background believers escape abroad, as they would not have been welcomed in their original villages.

We didn’t get much help from outside; a lot is funded from our own resources. This is why we haven’t been able to do much relief work. We pray and try to give hope to the people. We urge them to remain as salt and light and to keep their children from the fighting. The easiest way to make money is to join the army or the RSF and join in the looting.

But it is clear: Now is not the time for logic or reason. Bullets are talking.

Do the churches have a political opinion about the war?

Only that we will never support war—we want peace.

Last week officials approached me to make a statement in favor of the war. I told them it is not about the army or the RSF; it is about human life. We cannot support killing and destruction.

So then they went to the same Christians they used against us during the era of Bashir, who belonged to his political party and usurped leadership in our church councils. They took nice pictures with the army general.

Did the RSF reach out to you also?

As evangelicals, both sides hate us. They burned our churches. We know how the RSF killed our people in the Nuba Mountains and Darfur, so even when they were part of the post-revolutionary government, we did not deal with them. I have met with army leaders in the past, and I met our civilian prime minister and his cabinet. But we do not engage the RSF.

We are clear that we stand for life.

Security bodies approached the Church of Christ also, which faces the same problems we do. Refusing them may put us in a difficult position later on. But we cannot lie, we cannot forget who we are in Christ.

What would you like to say to those outside Sudan?

There is suspicious silence coming from the international community. The Arab League is not helping—even in Egypt they ask us if we are still in a civil war. Our issues are not on CNN, and no one pays attention to news from Sudan.

It makes the church feel like no one cares.

No one is standing up to say: Stop the war. We don’t hear that people are praying for us. We don’t see statements from churches to represent us before their governments.

To the Sudanese abroad, I say: Settle down, it will take a while before you can return. They are not settled in their spirit, but I tell them to wait on God and avoid being negative about their nation. Eventually, many will come back and bring with them the fruit from life in other countries. Others will stay and can support from the diaspora.

But we are all aliens and strangers in this world, like Abraham, living in tents.

Do you maintain hope in God?

We never lose it—we know that God is good.

From Deuteronomy, we know he can change a curse into a blessing. From Isaiah, we know he can change mourning into laughter. And from Romans, we know he will make all things work together for good.

Like with Samson’s lion, he can turn a carcass into something sweet.

This is the only hope we have. We know the situation now is not the end. God is working, we are safe, and we manage to have enough to eat. This is all a blessing from him.

But we have nothing we can do, except wait for God to move.

Pastors

Reflection: What Would Jesus Do (If He Were Totally Burned Out)?

It’s estimated that over 15 million WWJD bracelets were sold in the 1990s. Launching from a small church in Holland, Michigan, this line of Jesus merch quickly spread worldwide, spawning T-shirts, hats, and even a trio of movies. The popular acronym that stood for “What Would Jesus Do?” asked people to consider how Jesus might be calling them to act.

While most evangelicals have left their bracelets to gather dust, many—especially church leaders—still find themselves asking what Jesus would have them do. As cynicism and burnout continue to skyrocket, perhaps it’s time we ask a new question.

The key to understanding our calling is not to start with what a Christian would or should do but what Jesus Christ himself did.

As Jesus healed, taught, and served, he also retreated to pray, study Scripture, and worship. He devoted himself regularly to spiritual practices that drew no attention nor called for publicity. In doing so, Jesus allowed himself to be ministered to by his loving Father.

When the Crowds Clamored

Jesus stepped away to be with his Father—and not just once. “Jesus often withdrew to lonely places and prayed,” according to Luke 5:16. There were still people to heal. There were still masses eager to hear from him. And yet, Jesus took regular breaks from ministry to spend time aligning his heart with the Father’s.

In prayer, Jesus asked for relief and affirmed his submission to God’s will (Luke 22:42). He asked the Father to protect, unify, and sanctify the church (John 17). In prayer, Jesus modeled how to share the burdens and desires of his heart, trusting that communing with his Father would encourage and strengthen him for the work of ministry.

When Others Had Expectations

Jesus also turned to the Scriptures. At the age of 12, while his family traveled home from Jerusalem after the festival of the Passover, he remained in the temple courts. He sat among the teachers, Luke 2:46 reads, “listening to them and asking them questions.” While his understanding of the Hebrew scriptures was remarkable, perhaps what was even more remarkable was the posture of the Son of God to sit and listen.

Picture it: The one through whom the universe was created and in whom all things hold together placed himself under the teachings of Scripture. He sat. He listened. He, as Luke states, “grew in wisdom” (2:52). Though Jesus had every right and reason to act as the one with all the answers, he instead sat among wise teachers, engaging the Word of God together. And when his parents returned, riddled with anxiety in search of their lost child, he told them that he was where he had to be: in his Father’s house.

When There Were More Demands than Hours to Meet Them

Jesus routinely sought a quiet place for rest and encouraged his disciples to do the same (Mark 6:31). While a storm raged and his followers grew concerned for their safety as they sailed across the sea of Galilee, Jesus slept (Matt. 8:24). He did not push past his physical and emotional limits. Instead, he cooked breakfast on the beach (John 21:12). Tired, he sat by Jacob’s well and asked a Samaritan woman for a drink of water (John 4:6–7).

During every minute of Jesus’ ministry, people with pressing needs were calling for his attention. But as the one who sympathizes with our weaknesses (Heb. 4:15), Jesus embraced his mental, physical, and emotional limits. He poured out, yet knew that he needed to retreat and be filled back up. In doing so, he gives all whose weary hearts still long to minister permission to find the respite they so desperately desire.

Follow His Lead

What would Jesus do? Under the weight of ceaseless demands and world-changing responsibilities, Jesus sought solace in the Father’s presence. His life exemplified a rhythm of retreat and reengagement, a balance between pouring out and being filled.

It is a radical, essential act of faith to model this same pattern, to boldly declare dependence on God’s sustaining grace. Jesus’ example is not some distant ideal but a practical blueprint inviting us to consider: Are we willing to break from the cycle of constant doing to find restoration as Jesus did?

Pastors

Trinity Sunday

In the Beginning, not in time or space,

But in the quick before both space and time,

In Life, in Love, in co-inherent Grace,

In three in one and one in three, in rhyme, In music, in the whole creation story,

In His own image, His imagination,

The Triune Poet makes us for His glory, And makes us each the other’s inspiration. He calls

us out of darkness, chaos, chance, To improvise a music of our own,

To sing the chord that calls us to the dance, Three notes resounding from a single tone, To

sing the End in whom we all begin;

Our God beyond, beside us and within.

“Trinity Sunday” from Sounding the Seasons: Poetry for the Christian Year is copyright © Malcolm Guite, 2012, published by Canterbury Press and is reproduced by permission. All rights reserved. rights@hymnsam.co.uk

Pastors

Waffles and Discipleship

It was the smell of the toaster waffles that drew me in. This was the late 1980s and my dad was the pastor of our church, so attendance was obligatory.

Fortunately, I liked being there. I loved hearing my dad preach, even when he was asking my sister and me to stop talking from the pulpit of his small Methodist church in Towson, Maryland. We served in every capacity, from giving the announcements to singing in the choir to standing with the ushers. Raised in collective praise, we learned to honor God guided by wise elders and respected deacons.

But I was drawn to Sunday school by the appeal of the toaster waffles.

Every Sunday my family was the first to arrive, turning on the lights and readying the pews to receive worshipers. My dad would situate himself close to the altar as the first Sunday school attendees began to trickle in. While he always thoroughly prepared for the sermons, his passion came from teaching this class.

My sister and I headed to the basement for youth Sunday school with Mrs. Kathy, the church’s kindest woman. We would never see her come in, but we could smell when she was ready. Those morsels of yellow toasted love would be waiting for us on paper plates. After praying over our food, we would dive in with conversation, talking about what we looked forward to in school, what worried us about upcoming tests, and what friends were doing for fun.

Whether there were three or eight of us in the class, we’d always have seconds and then turn our attention to the lesson. Mrs. Kathy gently led us through Bible stories about loving others and taking responsibility. We’d draw pictures with animals from Scripture and play games with Bible names. At the end of our time, which always brought a little sadness, we’d close in “popcorn prayer,” bouncing among each other with whispered prayers to God as we prepared for service.

As a child, I thought the best part about church was the Sunday school food. As an adult, I realized that this small indulgence set the stage for a multisensory experience of discipleship. It was my earliest memory of structured church teaching and one of the few opportunities I had to learn from other Christians. The meager breakfast didn’t save me or lead me into the knowledge of Christ, but it was part of an intentional engagement that gave me something to look forward to.

With deep care for her students and a willingness to connect with them where they were, Mrs. Kathy created a bond with us that made room for real conversations. These early memories make me so grateful for the intimate community and the dedication of trusted volunteers. Even today, the memory of frozen waffles in the toaster brings thoughts of joy along with an undercurrent of grief for a time that may never be seen again.

In many ways, the waffles became a symbol of a humble community doing the faithful work of discipleship.

Opportunity in the Face of Loss

Sadly, my childhood days of Sunday school are long gone. I cannot help but be filled with nostalgic longing for the time when the church was synonymous with learning. But it’s not just the loss of Sunday school or Mrs. Kathy or the toasty goodness that I grieve. I miss the discipleship that happened in partnership with the worship experience. While this process of intentional Christian maturation is still happening in many spaces, those who choose to emphasize it are doing so in vastly different ways.

If discipleship, at its core, is about seeing people grow in their relationships with Christ, many pastors would argue that the sanctuary pulpit has taken the place of the classroom podium. If people are not willing or able to grow in a group, then preaching must be the way to bridge the gap.

Without organized Christian learning, how can we know what the Bible says? How can we raise our children with resilient faith if there is no place apart from the pulpit or the screen for them to learn?

The lack of processes to develop mature believers has resulted in a spiritual deficit. Without intentional and clear steps to grow in faith, both pastors and congregants miss out. But rather than sit in nostalgia, lament, and grief, we must ask ourselves what it looks like to turn this dire situation into a revival of reimagination. Pastors and leaders have an opportunity to reawaken a love for learning and growing together at a time when we are fractured and in need of wisdom.

Ancient Blueprint, Modern Revival

To effectively revive discipleship, we must remember what it is or why it matters. Fortunately, Scripture provides us with ample incentive not only to retain discipleship but also to reenvision it. The Old Testament bears witness to a God who cherishes being in relationship with his people (Zeph. 3:17). Despite numerous regressions and mistakes, Godrepeatedly promises his presence to guide his people, both physically and spiritually (Josh. 1:5–6, 9). His covenant with his people is initiated by his love for them and grounded in what he says to them by his Word. Outsiders knew who belonged to God by their obedience to his law and their connections within the covenantal community (Deut. 4:6–8).

In the New Testament, the themes of belonging by obedience and belief take on new terms through Jesus. From the coming of the Savior to the establishment of the early church, the New Testament consistently models the intentionality of God’s engagement. When John stated that “the Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us,” he emphasized an element of embodiment that shapes what it means to follow Christ (John 1:14).

The early church understood that Jesus came to be with mankind, and, as such, they prioritized communing with God and each other (Acts 2:42). But they didn’t study and serve for their own sakes—they did so because they were commanded to grow in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ (2 Pet. 3:18). Ultimately, the early disciples were willing to risk their comfort, money, families, affiliations, and even their lives for the sake of the gospel about a real Savior who was on his way back for them.

Quaint Rhythms, Collective Glory

In a world that is infatuated with comfort, it’s hard to imagine making such sacrifices. But following Jesus is a journey full of losses and risks that are backed by eternal purpose and reward. Being a disciple means regularly going beyond what is comfortable to do what does not come naturally: love our enemies, serve the least of these, and work for the glory of God.

If you want to help facilitate discipleship, create spaces for people to work through their faith commitments in the context of community. But these smaller communities must be courageous, because working through faith requires both conviction and consolation, confession and celebration. Within a community, we might discover the key to regaining our sense of wonder is wrapped up in some of the rhythms we are otherwise tempted to view as quaint or impractical.

Regardless of how and where these spaces are created—in the church or in homes, in groups of two or three or in groups of 200, online or in person—the goal is to design ways for people to encounter God for collective maturity and growth. Maybe it comes back to that circular toasted miracle of happiness. After all, people have been drawn in by far less than a toaster waffle.

Or perhaps it will be less about what you offer and more about where you offer it. Your next discipleship group might take place on the bleachers before parents cheer for the game. Maybe it will be at the local coffee shop, in your home, or over Zoom on a Tuesday after everyone gets off work. While the means of discipleship may change, the mandate to make disciples never will.

Engage people in God’s Word in community with others. Do not let the multiplicity of resources intimidate you. Don’t be put off by low numbers or overwhelmed by training volunteers. While the risk of following God can be a challenge, our willingness to remember and reimagine discipleship on a regular basis will give us a glimpse of the eternal glory that makes it all worthwhile.

Nicole Massie Martin, chief impact officer at Christianity Today, brings a unique blend of pastoral experience and trauma-healing expertise to her role. Her passion for faith and transformative leadership stems from years on the front lines, guiding individuals and communities toward wholeness. Prior to joining CT, Nicole served as the senior vice president of ministry impact at the American Bible Society. Overseeing various international and domestic ministries, including trauma healing, honed her skills in using Scripture to foster renewal and equipped her with a deep understanding of the human spirit’s resilience. Now, Nicole guides leaders to navigate complex challenges with wisdom and compassion, ultimately helping them build flourishing communities rooted in faith.

Pastors

The Transformative Power of Need

Someone recently said I was “stepping into midlife.” Hearing it put that way doesn’t really inspire passion about getting older.

When I was a kid, I was excited to grow up because I wanted to be a cool teenager, roaming the neighborhood with my buddies and playing football in the street. As a teenager, I was excited to grow up because I romanticized the independence that comes with being in your 20s. And as I sit here, a few weeks shy of turning 40, I’m still excited—but not to grow up. I’m excited to be exactly where I am.

Vulnerability and Value

“People were bringing infants to him so that he might touch them.” Luke 18:15, CSB

Over the course of 11 years, I planted and watered a faith community in one of the most beautiful neighborhoods in New York City. As a former pastor turned filmmaker, I know how hard it is for pastors—midwives to the emotional, social, and spiritual well-being of their people—to avoid external pressures and expectations. While we may heed the wisdom of CEOs, organizational leaders, church elders, and deacons, we must also recognize how it can overshadow the insights of artists, prophets, and especially the younger generation.

I’ve been studying the passage from Luke describing this meeting between Jesus, a crowd of adults, and a handful of children. Even from the first verse, I’m uncomfortable—in part because I know this ends with Jesus celebrating the posture of children, the powerless who serve as emblems of vulnerability.

Our transactional society, obsessed with productivity, shames people for owning their needs and limitations because it prizes infinite capacity above all else. In this world, the more I’m able to do, freely and independently, the more valuable I am. This association creeps into our relationships too. If we are giving more help than we receive, we may subconsciously believe that we’re adding more value than the other person.

But here we see Jesus welcoming and honoring those who are most limited, those with the greatest vulnerability. He spoke first to those who could contribute least.

Toppling the Power Paradigm

“When the disciples saw it, they rebuked them. Jesus, however, invited them: ‘Let the little children come to me, and don’t stop them, because the kingdom of God belongs to such as these.’ ” Luke 18:15–16, CSB

After a long stretch of teaching, healing, and traveling, the disciples assume that dealing with children is not what Jesus needs. It’s hard for them to see how playing with some kids could actually help in that moment rather than just requiring more of their spent leader.

Then Jesus uttered words so profound that to reduce them to promotional material for a VBS campaign would be to strip them of their power. Words so brilliant that they serve as a healing salve to an aging, callous-prone crowd: “Let the children come to me and don’t stop them, because the kingdom of God belongs to such as these.”

Translation: “You may have authority over these children, but don’t use that to keep them from me.” In this moment, Jesus is directly addressing the power disparity that exists between the capable and the less capable. He is reminding them that while children need adults to get to Jesus, adults need children to get to the kingdom. And Jesus knows that those words were needed for that moment and for generations to come, because power always feeds the illusion of self-sufficiency.

Just as those children taught the disciples about power and need, I too learned an important lesson from my five-year-old daughter, Hayden. After I preached two of three services at a friend’s church one Sunday, Hayden grew restless. Before the last service began, I gave her my phone to play some games and told her that if she needed anything, she could walk downstairs, come up on stage, and ask for help. About 20 minutes into my sermon, I heard her little feet echo in the sanctuary, and within seconds my daughter burst onto the stage mid-sermon, her big curls framing a determined grin, calling my bluff.

It didn’t matter who was watching; Hayden was able to be vulnerable. She knew she could be because I had given her permission to be. And this awareness of her need, not her confidence in her own ability, is what makes the kingdom of God belong “to such as these.”

Honest Ministry

Pastor, your calling accommodates your limits. And these limits keep your ministry honest, effective, and Spirit-filled. This moment in the Gospel of Luke is an invitation away from disguise and into deep-seated formation.

Because for Jesus, it was precisely his limits and vulnerability that gave birth to his resurrection presence. On this earth, it’s vital for pastors to continue to lead with clarity and confidence. But when God’s kingdom is fully realized and the banquet is set, pastors will join the table not as shepherds or rulers but, like everyone else, as children of God. Until then, may we all dare to embrace the transformative power of need, starting by simply acknowledging our own.

Rich Pérez is a Dominican filmmaker and storyteller. With nearly two decades of church planting experience in the heart of New York City, Rich has harnessed the power of narrative to cultivate spaces of hospitality and imagination. As he transitions into his new role at Christianity Today, Rich brings a unique blend of pastoral insight and creative storytelling to lead the content and strategy for CT Pastors. His mission is to inspire and equip church leaders, drawing from his experiences in church planting, counseling, and community engagement.

Pastors

Reignite Your Faith, Reawaken Your Church

Leading voices on revival, renewal, and joy.

As the gnawing sense of disenchantment deepens, many churches find themselves succumbing to spiritual fatigue. Feeling the weight of this reality, pastors yearn for revival, a spark to reignite the flames of faith within their communities. But where does the journey begin?

Here we gather insights from faith leaders who guide us toward answers. They explore ordinary practices—prayer, hospitality, worship, storytelling, silence, and sacraments—that can spark extraordinary transformation. Rediscover the joy, mystery, and wonder at the heart of Christianity, and prepare to lead your church into a vibrant, reenchanted future.

Sharon Hodde Miller

Sharon Hodde Miller leads Bright City Church in Durham, North Carolina, with her husband, Ike. She earned her MDiv from Duke Divinity School and her PhD from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, where she researched the topic of women and calling. Sharon writes for sites like Christianity Today, She Reads Truth, and Propel, and she is the author of three books: Free of Me, Nice, and The Cost of Control.

What advice would you offer to pastors who struggle to prioritize their own spiritual and emotional well-being after such a long season of feeling drained and discouraged?

A pastor’s personal faith and renewal must be our first and best work. It is the fount from which all our leadership flows. That said, pastors have been through the ringer. Seasoned, long-time pastors have told me that the last few years of ministry have been the hardest of their lives. I have spoken with countless pastors who have been rejected, betrayed, slandered, and accused by some of their longest-serving members and closest friends, and this takes a toll on a person. It also takes time to heal. I would encourage pastors to give themselves a lot of time and margin to rebuild what the last several years have torn down, and to make this a priority.

Jasmine Wood

Jasmine Wood serves as associate pastor at Lower Manhattan Community Church. Originally from Alabama, she infuses her messages with Southern warmth, emphasizing prayer and worship. Jasmine loves spending time outside in NYC with her husband, Brandon, and their daughter Trinity.

How can pastors measure the success of their efforts to foster spiritual renewal within their congregations, recognizing that spiritual growth can be subjective and multifaceted?

Eugene Peterson has done some work here that I found transformative. In The Jesus Way he writes about Christianity being an apprenticeship with Jesus. If we are developing as followers of Christ, shouldn’t we take a closer seat to observe him? Do we look like Christ? Does the congregation agree on the principles of what it means to be a disciple, and are they moving in that direction? If we, as pastors and leaders, are aware that more church members are actioning Jesus-centered ideas, we can rest assured spiritual growth is right there beneath the service.

Raymond Chang

Raymond Chang is the president of the Asian American Christian Collaborative. He has lived throughout the world, traveled to nearly 50 countries, and currently serves as the executive director for TENx10 and lives in Chicagoland with his wife, Jessica.

How can churches ensure that efforts toward spiritual growth and engagement are accessible and inclusive for individuals from diverse backgrounds and life experiences?

Design by centering the margins. One of the problems with the spiritual formation industry is that it is so focused on the individual that it never addresses the structural and social forces that alienate those who are considered the other (especially those from underrepresented and underresourced communities). Many Christians have told me that they do the work of evangelism, service, and discipleship among those who have been disenfranchised in our society only to have no church that they feel like they can entrust those marginalized groups to.

It often has nothing to do with doctrine but with culture—and cultural commitments that center those that have always been centered. One way you center the margins is by listening deeply in a nondefensive manner, seeking honest critiques of the status quo, and allowing others to speak into and shape the culture.

Courtney Ellis

Courtney Ellis is the author of Looking Up: A Birder’s Guide to Hope Through Grief (IVP, 2024). She and her husband, Daryl, pastor Presbyterian Church of the Master in Southern California, where they’ve served for ten years. They are raising three young birders.

What unexpected sources may have contributed to the church’s spiritual fatigue?

We’ve lost touch with creation. Natural theology points to the goodness of God, yet we design church life around explicitly religious practices (worship, Bible reading, prayer). As a result, the wonder, brutality, beauty, and awesomeness of the natural world are pushed to the background, creating a disconnect from the divine. I feel this most when I pray and words feel inadequate. But bird walks have become my solace, a spiritual practice that tethers me to the pleasure of God. Rather than dividing my life into secular and sacred, these moments remind me that the earth is the Lord’s and that I am invited to delight in his creation. Had my faith practices remained narrow and insular, too easily I would forget the vastness and complexity of creation—and of our Creator.

Trevin Wax

Trevin Wax is vice president of research and resource development at the North American Mission Board and the author of multiple books, including The Thrill of Orthodoxy, Rethink Your Self, and Gospel Centered Teaching. His podcast is Reconstructing Faith.

How can church practices cultivate a deeper awareness of the Holy Spirit’s presence and guidance?

There are many practices I could recommend that might help reinvigorate the church’s spiritual life—everything from frequent fasting to corporate prayer to a renewed emphasis on catechesis. And yet, too often we think it’s our activity that matters.

I’ve heard it said before that the most dangerous part of ministry is that you can learn to do it. And much of what passes for ministry today takes place without true dependence on the Spirit’s work. Were we to see our need, our dependence on the one who has called us, we would summon his presence with quiet desperation, begging that he might allow us to taste and see his goodness. The sidelining of God, as demonstrated by the absence of fervent prayer—surely this is the biggest obstacle to renewal today.

Collin Hansen

Collin Hansen serves as vice president for content and editor in chief of The Gospel Coalition, as well as executive director of The Keller Center for Cultural Apologetics. He hosts the Gospelbound podcast and has written and contributed to many books, most recently Timothy Keller: His Spiritual and Intellectual Formation.

How can churches create a culture of spiritual growth and engagement?

You don’t see revival without holiness and prayer, and renewal starts by going back to God’s Word with complete confidence in its truthfulness and sufficiency. Additionally, there are three shifts in thinking that, if understood and embraced, would greatly contribute to the spiritual vibrancy of a church:

  1. We shouldn’t have to agree with someone 100 percent in order to learn from them.
  2. We should be able to criticize and reject evil practices in the church, past or present, without either inciting a backlash or deconstructing our faith.
  3. We should be able to follow in the example and grace of Jesus Christ by being compassionate, courageous, and commissioned at the same time in our personal lives and in our churches, no matter our particular gifting.

Derwin Gray

Derwin Gray cofounded the Transformation Church in Indian Land, South Carolina, with his wife, Vicki Gray. He speaks at conferences nationwide and is the author of several books, including Building a Multiethnic Church.

As we think about fostering spiritual revival across broader communities, how can pastors look for, or create, opportunities for cross-denominational collaboration?

Sparking a spiritual revival can be catalyzed when pastors from different streams of the Christian faith see themselves as partners in the gospel, not competitors for religious consumers. This means they pray together, centering their ministries in the gospel of King Jesus. There must be a willingness to resource each other with best ministry practices, mentoring, and financial assistance.

In our ever-increasing diverse contexts, it is essential for pastors to model what it means to love the other relentlessly, listen to the other intentionally, and learn from the other continuously.

Pastors

Wonder Worth Wrestling For

How to keep God at the heart of worship.

What would happen next Sunday morning if God did not show up? Would the sermon still touch hearts and resonate with truth, if the Spirit of God didn’t illuminate the Scriptures as they are read and preached? Imagine a worship service where hands are raised but the music, absent of the Spirit dwelling richly, lacks its usual resonance. As people leave, would there be a noticeable void?

Perhaps the service would not look that different at all. That possibility is even more terrifying than the threat of God’s absence.

My journey into ministry began in 1999, in a small apartment gathering. As a group of displaced believers, we were spiritually homeless, seeking something we called “authentic spirituality.” Those simple meetings were some of the most spiritually enriching experiences of my life.

We would talk in an unstructured way with vulnerability about faith, doubt, loneliness, grief, and mental health. We would pray for one another and sing a hymn, chorus, or psalm. Rarely was there any formal teaching, yet we found ways to support one another.

Afterward, we could honestly say, “Surely the Lord is in this place” (Gen. 28:16).

From these humble beginnings came discussions about planting a church. Having outgrown the apartment, we eventually moved to an old church basement. The gatherings became slightly more formal as we grew, but the earnestness and simplicity remained. We prayed, sang, and supported each other through career decisions, relationships, miscarriages, and moves.

Several years later, the church resembled a large institution. The staff was splintered and exhausted as we launched our third capital campaign in five years. We faced a leaking roof and a sleep-deprived band. And yet we managed to conduct the service seamlessly. We could—almost literally—have done it in our sleep.

But does an altar call still draw people if the Spirit’s presence is missing? Even as we adeptly masked the behind- the-scenes turmoil, I wondered if our well-crafted services were as spiritually charged as those early gatherings.

Reflecting on these experiences, I often considered the difference between those days in the apartment and the realities of a larger church. It wasn’t just about being young and idealistic. Despite our lack of accommodations, we had an undeniable sense of God’s presence.

Yet, as time passed, the question of whether that same presence was as palpable in a much larger, structured church service often haunted me. I believe that both the simplicity of our early days and the complexities of our larger gatherings were authentic expressions of our faith journey, but there had clearly been a shift in my own sense of expectation and possibility.

The why behind that shift lies in disenchantment.

When Faith Became Functional

Max Weber, a 20th-century sociologist, was the first to describe the effect of modernity as disenchantment. As Weber saw it, a post-Enlightenment, post–Scientific Revolution world had been drained of mystery. One might board a streetcar, Weber said, and have no clue how it operates, but for a modern person, understanding is only a trip to the library (in his day) or a quick Google search (in ours) away. His point was that this default setting drains the transcendence from every moment. There are no mysteries in this world, only processes we do not yet understand.

Canadian philosopher Charles Taylor, building on Weber’s theme, suggests that modernity ushered in a pervasive skepticism, particularly toward the supernatural. Where belief in transcendence once underpinned daily life, with most individuals holding faith in God and acknowledging the existence of mysteries and forces beyond their control, the modern zeitgeist has shifted.

Today, much of the intellectual discourse within the modern world operates under the assumption of a godless reality, where everything can be explained through material means. Our understanding of the world has demystified many phenomena: Plagues are no longer the products of spirits or curses but the consequence of germs and viruses, and bad weather can be explained by air pressure systems, not acts of God. Much like Weber’s streetcar, even if we don’t understand the exact mechanics at play, we often believe there’s a logical explanation.

Christians, especially pastors and church leaders, share a common tendency to view spiritual life through a similar lens. We often frame religious experiences as the result of a process we can understand and manipulate. Anything that triggers a positive reaction in ministry, be it a Sunday service or a discipleship program, holds a particularly strong allure.

While this desire for control is understandable, it ultimately leads us down a path of pragmatism and, sadly, cynicism. Instead of seeking genuine spiritual growth, church gatherings become more focused on “meaningful moments,” by relying on evocative music or performative preaching. Worse still, congregations, starved for transcendence, readily accept and even reward these manipulative, emotionally driven gatherings.

This emphasis on production, performance, and energy can result in a hollow ministry that lacks several critical markers of health: spiritual maturity, wisdom, character, and love. As many large churches and denominations face the fallout of leadership failures, it’s worth asking, how did disenchantment lead to neglecting the character and spiritual development of leaders? And what price is the church paying for this oversight?

Burnt-Out Torchbearers

Imagining an alternative approach may seem daunting, but it starts by acknowledging the inherent doubt brought on by disenchantment. Not as a surrender, but as a challenge we must confront and grapple with. Only then can we lead our churches in ways truly reliant on the Holy Spirit’s active presence.

This is an invitation to switch from performance to presence. While the practicalities of ministry—like preaching, praying, leading worship, and visiting others—remain, we must learn to engage in these activities with an openness to the mysterious workings of God.

The good news is that this path isn’t shrouded in darkness. The Scriptures themselves resonate with this yearning for the divine. The psalmist’s words echo our own when he cries, “My tears have been my food day and night. . . . how I used to go to the house of God under the protection of the Mighty One with shouts of joy and praise” (Ps. 42:3–4). Our truest longing isn’t for a bygone era but for the presence of God himself.

Just as the psalmist sought renewal in moments of vulnerability, so too can we find our way back by nurturing spaces of personal communion with God. This quest, both individual and communal, lies at the heart of authentic worship in our disenchanted world.

Leading others toward wonder can feel like carrying a torch for an entire congregation. This burden underscores the need for pastors to carve out personal spaces for spiritual renewal and to pursue sanctuaries where they can shed the mantle of being a guide and instead take on the role of seeker. These safe spaces may not be grand cathedrals but rather small groups, friendships, or even quiet moments in a church basement.

Like all Christians, church leaders are susceptible to spiritual fatigue. These feelings, far from marking failures, mirror the struggles faced by countless prophets and saints throughout history. Recognizing this state is a step that aligns you with a courageous lineage of souls who sought God even amid doubt. The same is true for your congregations. Weariness and disenchantment don’t diminish faith or signal a spiritual deficit; rather, they present an opportunity for both leaders and congregants to seek understanding and renewal.

While there’s no magic formula for encountering God, actively seeking him is the lifeblood of faith. Caving to cynicism and stagnation means missed opportunities to experience the divine. But an open heart and vulnerable spirit can crack open the door to rediscovering the joy we yearn for. It’s in this intentional pursuit that the embers of enchantment are rekindled—not just for ourselves but for the communities we are called to lead.

The Death of the Hero

Many pastors have been cast as the hero of their church’s narrative by their members, mentors, and peers. They deliver inspiring sermons, offer wise counsel, and act as trusted guides. Playing that role can be emotionally rewarding for a time, but eventually it starts to wear thin—because when the church views you as the hero, the time may come when they start to wonder why you haven’t solved all their problems, and that pressure can take an enormous toll on your soul.

Instead, pastors need to rewrite the narrative. While Jesus is undeniably the overarching hero, framing it solely on that theological level won’t empower the church to overcome cynicism and disenchantment. The key lies in throwing out the hero paradigm and helping members understand their own roles as the protagonists in their spiritual journeys. Pastors, leaders, and mentors can illuminate the beauty of this journey and offer guidance through obstacles and challenges, but they cannot take or replace individuals’ own steps toward the kingdom of heaven.

Practically, this means inviting the church into a life of real, vibrant spirituality. It means equipping them with spiritual disciplines so that they can learn to pray, fast, and listen for the Spirit of God in silence and solitude. It means empowering them with tools and sending them out into the wilderness. It means embracing their own feelings of doubt and disenchantment and inviting them to pursue God through it.

As pastors, it also means putting to death some personal pride. Instead of chasing grandiose visions of “reaching the city” or “changing the world,” what if we welcomed the quiet moments of presence? Being there at a hospital bedside, celebrating life’s joys and sorrows, and encouraging church members to serve their communities in practical ways—these are the actions that truly matter. What would happen if we valued tears shed and meals served more than seats filled and dollars collected?

Of course, no one can guarantee a profound encounter with God. But that’s part of the point: We need to grow comfortable incorporating practices that rely on God to be actively present.

Only by learning to attend to God’s presence in a broken, hurting world can we find a sense of transcendence once we gather. Then, no longer arriving as individuals starved for something beyond ourselves but as people who have witnessed God’s presence in a myriad of ways, we can come together to share those testimonies through worship.

What if we traded standing ovations for the murmur of shared prayer in dim apartments? Not the performative prayer orchestrated with smoke machines and polished sermons, but the vulnerable kind that call back to the early days huddled together, seeking authentic spirituality. May our embers be fanned into a blaze that warms not just ourselves, but the world.

Pastors

Journey Within

Chances are that you have shelves filled with commentaries, a podcast app loaded with learning, and a calendar stacked with conferences—and we’re glad you do! Instead of adding more books or to-dos for your NONFICTION professional growth, these resources are intended to be invitations to rest and reflect. Enjoy a book in your favorite chair, listen to a podcast during an evening walk, or spend the weekend meditating on a retreat. Think savor, not study.

BOOKS

Nonfiction

Abba’s Child: The Cry of the Heart for Intimate Belonging by Brennan Manning (NavPress) From Burned Out to Beloved: Soul Care for Wounded Healers by Bethany Dearborn Hiser (IVP) Recapturing the Wonder: Transcendent Faith in a Disenchanted World by Mike Cosper (IVP) Revelations of Divine Love by Julian of Norwich (Oxford University Press) The Care of Souls: Cultivating a Pastor's Heart by Harold L. Senkbeil (Lexham Press) The Way of the Heart: The Spirituality of the Desert Fathers and Mothers by Henri J.M. Nouwen (HarperOne)

Fiction

I, Julian: The Fictional Autobiography of Julian of Norwich by Claire Gilbert (Hodder Faith) Peace Like a River by Leif Enger (Corsair) The Undoing of Saint Silvanus by Beth Moore (Tyndale) Watership Down: The Graphic Novel by Richard Adams, adapted and illustrated by James Sturm and Joe Sutphin (Ten Speed Graphic) When In Rome by Liam Callanan (Dutton)

Poetry

David's Crown: Sounding the Psalms by Malcolm Guite (Canterbury Press Norwich) Endless Life: Poems of the Mystics by Scott Cairns (Paraclete Press) ​​Now, Now by Jennifer Maier (University of Pittsburgh Press) Touch the Earth: Poems on The Way by Drew Jackson (IVP) What the Light Was Like: Poems by Luci Shaw (WordFarm)

Podcasts

Abide Daily Meditation (Abide) Common Prayer Daily (Michael W. Livingston) Daily Lectio Divina (Abiding Way Ministries) Life with God: A Renovaré Podcast (Nathan Foster) The Liturgy of the Hours: Sing the Hours (Paul Rose)

Albums

Abide With Me, Sara Groves (Sponge Records) Patient Kingdom, Sandra McCracken (Integrity Music) Psalms: The Poetry of Prayer, Caroline Cobb (Caroline Cobb) Sanctuary Songs, The Porter’s Gate (The Porter’s Gate) Yet Not I, CityAlight (CityAlight Music)

Retreats

Monastery of Christ in the Desert Abiquiu, New Mexico This Benedictine Monastery follows St. Benedict’s rule and asks monks to treat each visitor as Christ would be treated. Stay for a minimum of two days and two nights. The suggested donation is $90 per night. Meals are included. https://christdesert.org/visiting/

Our Lady of Guadalupe Carlton, Oregon This Trappist abbey offers a monastic guest house and retreat environment built on the Eucharist, the table of fellowship, and the table of welcome. Stay for a minimum of two nights, maximum of ten. There is a required donation of at least $80 per day. Meals are included. https://www.trappistabbey.org/booking-a-retreat

Society of Saint John the Evangelist Cambridge, Massachusetts SSJE features an Anglican monastery and guesthouse that offer spaces of silence, beauty, and simple comfort to guests. There are specific dates to choose from, with some retreats including topical workshops at an additional cost. The suggested fee for a self-led retreat is $120 per night, $50 for students. Meals are included. https://www.ssje.org/reservation

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube