As I watched, I thought of a different trend I and others have witnessed in evangelical churches during the past decade: I have seen the Bible given a less important place than it deserves in public worship. For example, my wife attended a service in the Midwest in which no Bible reading of any kind was a part of worship, and the preacher himself made casual mention of Scripture only a couple of minutes before the end of his sermon. My wife wondered if anyone else had noticed this glaring omission.
An isolated case? A minister friend on vacation attended a congregation that advertised itself on the front lawn as a "Bible church." He was surprised that at no time was the Bible read except for a few verses before the pastor preached. While speaking to a denominationally diverse class at Northeastern Seminary in Rochester, New York, I asked, "How many of you lead or attend a church where there is no separate Scripture reading as an act of worship?" Nine of the 19 raised their hands.
The first time I heard this trend explained several years ago, I was told that our worship services should be designed with seekers in mind, and that unchurched people have neither the attention span nor the interest to give to the reading of Bible passages. The idea was that you had to give them a contemporary and, above all, relevant service.
The reason for deleting Scripture-reading from worship, however, may be more serious than merely the shortness of the modern attention span. The omission may expose to the light a great reduction in the authority we grant the Bible, an authority such as the sexton enacted in the Presbyterian church.
The daily news reminds us regularly of the authority crisis in the homes and schools of this country. Since the authority of the Scriptures has been passionately asserted by classical Protestantism, what but a reduction of that authority can be suspected when the Word of God is both diminished and diluted in public worship in favor of a greater outpouring of the words of man?
This is no mere issue of taste in public worship. A recent national survey by Barna Research Group reports that 86 percent of teenagers claim they are Christians. Three of five teenagers say they believe the Bible is totally accurate in all that it teaches. Yet, two-thirds said that Satan is not a living being but merely a symbol of evil; six of ten said that a good person can earn eternal salvation through good deeds; and a majority (53%) said that Jesus committed sins while he was on earth.
Longer Bible readings in worship may not cure biblical illiteracy or heresy, but the evident slippage should prompt us to ask questions.
If the slippage can go so easily unnoticed in public worship, what place is Bible-reading getting these days in the family life of Christians? Is biblical content really being addressed in Sunday schools? Are children led to memorize Scripture? Do pastors show evidence of wrestling with Scripture in preparation for preaching?
We may not want to copy the early Presbyterian way of symbolizing the authority of Scriptures in worship, but the omission of reading the Bible as an act of worship is a symptom of a serious problem that we must address.
Donald N. Bastian is an emeritus bishop of the Free Methodist Church and lives in Brampton, Ontario.
Copyright © 2001 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.
The August 9, 1999 issue of Christianity Today had two articles on biblical illiteracy, "The Greatest Story Never Read | Recovering biblical literacy in the church" and "I Love to Tell the Story to Those Who Know It Least | Biblical preaching in a post-Christian culture.
"Conversation about faith or morals is often blocked by the other's misunderstanding of what the Bible says or what the Christian faith teaches," lamented former Christianity Today columnist Frederica Mathewes-Green in a Feb. 7, 2000, piece chronicling biblical illiteracy in the media and society at large.
A Barna Research Group study released in July 2000 found that 75 percent of Americans agree with the statement, "The Bible teaches that God helps those who help themselves." But that's not all. Barna's group questioned people on 14 different items. "Only 3 of the 1002 adults interviewed—less than three-tenths of one percent—had both a firm and biblically-consistent opinion for all 14 of the items," Barna reports.
The Boston Globe's language columnist, Jan Freeman, lamented biblical illiteracy in the December 19, 1999, edition of the newspaper. The article, "Bible Quotes that Miss the Boat," is still online, but you will have to pay to read it ($2.95 between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. EST weekdays, and $1.50 at all other times).
The Web site of the Free Methodist Church in Canada offers a photo and e-mail address for Donald Bastian.
Have something to add about this? See something we missed? Share your feedback here.