Jump directly to the Content


US Catholics More Concerned About Climate Change Than Persecuted Christians

Most think persecution is severe, but only half are very concerned or strongly support asylum or financial aid.
US Catholics More Concerned About Climate Change Than Persecuted Christians
Image: Andreas Solaro / AFP / Getty Images
Rome's Colosseum was lit red last month in order to raise awareness of the persecuted church.

The Colosseum in Rome was recently lit up the color of blood.

“This is a symbol of the persecution of Christians in the entire world—those who suffer because of faith,” stated Alfredo Mantovano, president of the Italian chapter of Aid to the Church in Need (ACN), the global Catholic organization which sponsored the February 24 light display.

“We light up the Colosseum with red because their shed blood cannot leave us indifferent,” he stated. “We cannot wash our hands of the blood of this injustice as Pontius Pilate did 2,000 years ago.”

The reminder was a timely one for Catholics in the United States, according to a survey released this month. While 9 in 10 believe that persecution of Christians around the world is somewhat or very severe (51% and 40%, respectively), only half said they were very concerned (49%). Almost 1 in 5 said they were not concerned at all (18%).

Instead, the study of 1,000 Catholic adults (conducted online in January by ACN’s US branch and McLaughlin & Associates) found that they worry about other issues more.

More than 9 in 10 American Catholics worry about human trafficking (72% very concerned, 21% somewhat concerned) or about poverty (68% very, 26% somewhat). More than 8 in 10 worry about the refugee crisis (51% very, 36% somewhat) or about climate change (55% very, 28% somewhat).

Then comes Christian persecution (49% very, 33% somewhat). It’s close behind, but has the lowest level of concern out of the five issues surveyed, as well as the highest share of those with no concern: Christian persecution (18%), climate change (16%), refugees (14%), human trafficking (7%), and poverty (6%).

As John Allen, a veteran Catholic journalist and analyst, noted for Crux, the results reveal “a relatively low level of urgency among American Catholics about coming to the aid of persecuted Christians.”

Image: Aid to the Church in Need

“The survey reveals quite clearly that there is a need to increase the engagement level of the US Catholic Church when it comes to global Christian persecution—both at the grassroots and leadership levels,” stated George Marlin, chair of ACN-USA.

Three out of five American Catholics said that Christians experience less than half of religiously-based attacks around the world.

They’re incorrect: Researchers with Under Caesar’s Sword, a $1 million Templeton Religious Trust study, found that Christians experience between 60 to 80 percent of the world’s religious discrimination. (More of it is experienced by evangelicals/Pentecostals than by Catholics.)

American Catholics were more accurate when ranking the top five worst persecutors of Christians out of 16 nations. Their picks: North Korea, Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Pakistan.

Two of their picks match one of the most respected rankings, Open Doors’s World Watch List, which ranks the top 5 persecutors of Christians as North Korea, Afghanistan, Somalia, Sudan, and Pakistan. Iraq is No. 8, Iran is No. 10, and Syria is No. 15.

A majority of American Catholics believe diplomatic pressure is very important to save and protect beleaguered Christians (59%), as are economic sanctions (55%). But only half believe offering emergency asylum (50%) or providing financial aid (47%) are very important. And less than half believe military intervention (40%) or arming Christian communities (40%) are very important.

On a personal level, many said it was very important to pray (64%), to raise awareness at the parish level (56%), and to contact members of Congress (49%).

Image: Aid to the Church in Need

About half said it was very important to donate to agencies that help persecuted Christians (53%); more than half said they have done so in the past year (53%).

“Giving increases among regular Mass-goers,” the report stated. “The majority of those who do not regularly attend Mass do not give to any organization.”

Pope Francis often references the persecuted church, and American Catholics have noticed. Four out of five said he was very (49%) or somewhat (33%) engaged on the issue, higher than they ranked US bishops (27% very, 39% somewhat) or their local parish (24% very, 42% somewhat).

Image: Aid to the Church in Need

“There is a need to better inform and engage the Catholic audience,” Marlin stated. “There is an obligation to keep the spotlight on the topic and showcase the seriousness and pervasiveness of Christian persecution around the world.”

Other findings of the survey include:

  • Just over half of the Catholic respondents were white (55%), followed by Hispanic (37%), African American (4%), Asian or Asian American (3%), and other (1%).
  • 38 percent described themselves as “very devout,” 46 percent said they were “somewhat devout,” and 17 percent said they weren’t devout at all. The numbers correspond roughly to Mass attendance: 35 percent attend at least weekly, while 18 percent go monthly, 18 percent go only on Christmas and Easter, and 29 percent rarely or never go.
  • Politically and religiously, Catholics are spread across the conservative/liberal spectrum. About a third identify as Republican (28%), independent or other (33%), or Democrat (39%); in the same way, roughly a third identify as religiously conservative (34%), moderate (39%), or liberal (27%).
  • For news, American Catholics have the most trust in Fox News (29%), ABC News (22%), CNN (22%), or NBC News (20%). About 1 in 5 doesn’t trust any secular news companies at all (18%). For Catholic news, they have the most trust in their parish bulletin (32%), the Catholic News Agency (22%), the National Catholic Register (17%), or the National Catholic Reporter (16%). Meanwhile, 1 in 3 doesn’t trust any Catholic news source (33%).

Support Our Work

Subscribe to CT for less than $4.25/month

Read These Next