Subscribe to Christianity Today
Subscribe to Christianity Today
Donate to Christianity Today
login | my account
February 9, 2012

Home > 2008 > March (Web-only)Christianity Today, March (Web-only), 2008
Theology in the News
Black Power from the Pulpit
In wake of Obama's speech, author talks about The Decline of African American Theology.




Sen. Barack Obama sought in his speech Tuesday to answer critics who have called on the Democratic presidential candidate to account for his former pastor's anti-American sermons. Jeremiah Wright, longtime pastor of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, is a leading proponent of black liberation theology. On the church's website, Wright says that Trinity's vision statement is based on the systematized liberation theology found in James Cone's 1969 book, Black Power and Black Theology. According to Cone, "The concept of liberation is not one among many themes in the biblical tradition; it is rather the essence of God's revelation in history, and other emphases should be interpreted in light of liberation."

CT editor-at-large Collin Hansen interviewed Thabiti Anyabwile, author of The Decline of African American Theology, about the appeal of black liberation theology.

What did you think when you first heard the sermons from Sen. Obama's former pastor. Jeremiah Wright?

Actually, I had two reactions. First, I thought they were fairly typical kinds of comments whenever African American pastors begin to whoop on political issues. One thing the viewer needs to keep in mind is that in terms of sermonic style, Wright appeared to be in the almost-always-dramatic climax of a typical African American sermon. Those parts of the sermon tend to have great emotional effect, as evidenced by the shouting crowd, but are very often not the main point of the sermon. Second, I reacted like most other people, thinking, Ouch. That's gonna leave a bruise for everybody concerned — Wright, Obama, Trinity, and most viewers.

Has anything surprised you about the wave of indignation that has followed news of these sermons?

I've been surprised that so much effort has been made to saddle Obama with the views of his pastor, and that not as much attention seems to be given to equally controversial remarks made by white pastors. Rod Parsley's comments about Islam barely received a nod.

I've also been surprised at how deep the ignorance of the African American church and its preaching tradition goes. Anyone with a passing familiarity with the church in either its historical or contemporary form would recognize Wright's preaching in style, and sometimes in content, as essentially what has been preached for at least 100 years in African American churches. There's much to object to in some of the language. But it's essentially what is shared in a lot of churches whenever the comments turn political.

How would you describe the attraction of black liberation theology?

Black liberation theology has its origins in the Black Power movement of the 1960s. Its founder, James Cone, was looking for a theological orientation to explain the aims, ethos, and anger of the 1960s revolution. So, not surprisingly, black liberation theology concerns itself with the political aspirations of African Americans from a fairly radical bent by most standards. It's an effort to do theology from the vantage point of the marginalized and the oppressed. Its main benefit is that it does raise questions that aren't often addressed by most theologians. Its main failure is that it either supplants or equates the biblical gospel with a concern for temporal politics, particularly politics viewed from a politically liberal and self-consciously black perspective.

Liberation theology in Latin America is slightly older than that among African Americans. And expressions of black liberation theology are found in South Africa as well.





Christianity Today


  


Subscribe to Christianity Today and get 3 free trial issues. No credit card required.

Please allow 4-6 weeks for delivery. Offer valid in U.S. only.

If you decide you want to keep Christianity Today coming, honor your invoice for just $19.95 and receive nine more issues, a full year in all. If not, simply write "cancel" across the invoice and return it. The three trial issues are yours to keep, regardless.


Click here for international orders2-for-1 Gifts!

Displaying 1–5 of 39 comments

TBetts

April 02, 2008  11:53am

The issue is neither Barack Obama nor Jeremiah Wright. As stated in this excellent interview, the issue is a gospel other than the gospel of Jesus Christ. Such a gospel may invoke emotional responses and facilitate a temporal sense of excitement in the Sunday morning experience amidst the local congregation, but it has no effectual power to save souls, change hearts or any of the eternally significance. Our agenda should not be pro-black, pro-political party or even pro-church at the expense of relegating Christ to a secondary or tertiary position. Chirst is all or nothing at all.

Scott

April 01, 2008  7:48pm

The only thing I got out of this piece is that Jeremiah Wright, who I first saw in person when he came to to Fuller Seminary to speak when I was a student there, is on target. The white evangelical church is so captive to the gospel of America that it cannot hear the Bible. What Wright says is what I hear when I read Jeremiah, Amos, John the Baptist and our Lord Jesus Christ. Juat as the false prophets and the people wanted to hear messages that simple upheld national exceptionalism and salvation, white evangelicals tend to have "itching ears." It will take nothing less than the judgment of God to shake them out their idolatry, just as the Exile and destruction of Jerusalem did for the Jewish psyche.

Carlos

March 31, 2008  6:33pm

I concur with the general position of Mr. Hansen's article. To the question, is black liberation theology biblical or not? No, it most certainly is not, because the problem of SIN, which permeates the entire human 'race' has no 'color' whatsoever. Jesus did not come to liberate us from political, social, or ethnic prejudice, but, from the UTTER BONDAGE of SIN, which affects all men. To the extent that a man, regardless of color, is truly set free from the bondage of SIN, is the extent to which he/she will relate to his brother/sister, regardless of color. What I believe, is not been dealt with in this age long problem, is the distinct, historic, cultural 'habits' and traditions, which is expressed in very different ways, from culture to culture. I.e., Spanish people, express themselves entirely different to Chinese, so do whites from blacks, this is not necessarily wrong, or bad, but because of 'SIN' it sometimes can have a very negative impact. The Gospel of Christ, must remain!

cjs58

March 28, 2008  1:26pm

If you take Mr. Hansen's article on face value and leave out all the political junk tossed in in the comments section, you are left with a fairly interesting critique. Is black liberation theology biblical or not? That's the central question. Mr. Hansen seems to believe it has strayed too far from the Bible. I would tend to think you can make similar arguments about any Christian tradition that tries to put too much of an emphasis on politics.

Moses

March 28, 2008  10:42am

Rev. Wright preaches out of the bible and prophetic tradition. When he sees the sins of a nation, he condemns it as Rev. Pat Robertson, the late Rev. Jerry Fallwell, and Rev. Hagee do. Do you think his comments are out of line? Read Isaiah 10:5-11 where God uses one of Israel's enemies against Israel. Read the call of Isaiah in ch. 6 where God cals Isaiah to preach "until cities lie waste without ininhabitant . . ." Read Jeremiah 4:16 where Jeremiah preaches judgement against Jerusalem. Hosea chastises Israel in ch. 9:1, equating Israel with a whore. Just as the prophets loved and condemned Israel, Rev. Wright loves and condemns America to get this country to confess its sins to God. Barack should not be villified for having Rev. Wright as his pastor. Barack's call for racial and economic equality, health insurance for all, among others, is a result of being at a church that not only preaches the Word of God, but embodies it. "Faith without works is dead," says James 2:17.

You must be a Christianity Today subscriber or have created a FREE registration to post comments
[Browse More Christianity Today]



Search
Search
Search
Scripture Search
Go Deeper

Books & Culture
Christianity Today
Church Law & Tax Report
Church Finance Today
Leadership Journal
Men of Integrity
Kyria.com
ChristianityTodayLibrary.com
PreachingToday.com