Jump directly to the content
Jump directly to the content

Ryan Gosling, Romance Novels, and the Dangers of Fantasizing


Apr 5 2012
The problem isn't that we long for something better. It's that we long for too small of things.

It's 5 o'clock and you're stuck in traffic with hungry kids in the backseat, and no dinner waiting for you once you get home.

Hey girl. It's cool that you made a three-course meal for the mom in your co-op that just had a baby—then hit the drive-through on the way home to feed your own family. I kinda like room temperature fries.

Or maybe it's only 11 o'clock on Tuesday morning and you've already gotten three urgent projects you hadn't budgeted time for, and the coffee machine is broken and you're afraid that guy on the train who coughed in your face gave you a cold because now your throat feels weird.

Hey Girl, I know you ain't feelin' it today. That's why I'm so proud to see you at that desk, doing what you do best. Cheers.

Whether you're a homeschooling mom, a feminist, a knitter, a literary agent—or one of many other types of women—there's a message from indie actor-heartthrob Ryan Gosling meant just for you. In each blog post, Gosling is there to be handsome while he offers understanding and consolation for your mundane but particular drudgery or disappointment.

In some ways, the online meme is fairly innocent. And in their tendency to highlight various frustrations and minor grievances common to particular subcultures, these faux Goslings can even create a sense of shared experience, along with the release of laughter and pleasure of seeing the handsome Canadian actor in various poses.

But if even one of those wishes came true, and Gosling suddenly stood beside us, actually saying what we wish he might, would it put doctors out of business, stop all earthquakes and volcanoes, suck up all the venom beneath our tongues?

Of course not. And that's one of the problems with escapist fantasies. Though we almost always turn to them when life's brokenness has reasserted itself, such fantasies represent the wrong kind of change.

Don't get me wrong—to sense that the world is not as it should be is the right response to sin and the fall. And it's right and good to long for restoration. But fantasies like Ryan Gosling addressing you as "Hey girl," or the newest romance novel topping the NYT bestseller list, or the Lucky Vanous Diet Coke breaks of yesteryear, don't do anything to help advance the change that's really needed. They just fleetingly numb our individual pain.

The first time I indulged a fantasy of this sort toward the end of high school, as I waited for my ride home from a job at the mall. As I sat there on the cold cement curb, fending off the advances of loneliness, the thought came to me: Oh, if only my crush were to drive by, see me here and offer a ride.

Comments

Displaying 1–10 of 23 comments

Sandra E. Harshman

June 09, 2012  11:02am

Together with college or university grants, suitable single moms can take benefit from federal government grants for homes for unmarried mothers. An application for any real estate federal grant can save a lot of your efforts, while you take care of all the other necessities regarding your children.

Report Abuse

Robyn Widmer

April 17, 2012  4:36pm

Samantha, FTW!

Report Abuse

Don Clements

April 15, 2012  6:29pm

http://theaquilareport.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=7053:ryan-gosling-romance-novels-and-the-dangers-of-fantasizing&catid=79:commentary&Itemid=137 Congrats - your blog article made the top ten list for last week in our magazine. Our readers have been largely men since we opened shop 2 1/2 years ago, but articles like this are atracting a broader constituency.

Report Abuse

Samantha

April 14, 2012  10:37pm

I think this meme is interesting because it illustrates how women really do desire men who "live with them in understanding" (1 Peter 3:7), and really, many men (even "good Christian men") don't do this very well - not that we are such great wives all the time, either. Such is love in a fallen world ;-) But you hear so much about how we women have to be sure to meet our husband's "needs" (wink, wink) lest they stray, but I know a lot of wives live with husbands who really display little or no interest in them as people, which might be a temptation for the women to stray. So, I really don't think this is about celebrity fantasies so much as a desire for relationships with men that care enough to pay attention to what is important to their wives, and what interests them. That's what we expect from friends, and we want our marriages to go beyond sex and gender roles and have a real element of friendship. I realize some women might see Mr Gosling as a "sex symbol", but I don't think that is the real underlying message...but there is definitely truth to the idea that most women probably feel more sexually drawn to a husband who actually likes them and finds them interesting.

Report Abuse

Doreen Ashley

April 14, 2012  12:34am

While this meme just strikes me as funny and is not even something I doesn't function in any way as fantasy to me, I really appreciated your point. I was single until I turned 30 - never even dating anyone seriously. And since I was in 2nd or 3rd grade I would lose myself in the exact same daydreams of the boy I had a crush on just happen to drive by (well, riding with his mother-ha!) and decide to stop for a visit or pick me up. I can remember sitting in my 8th grade class and imagining a boy I had been in a wedding with a year earlier who lived states away, driving up in a red sports car and whisking me away to the envy of all my friends. It sounds fairly innocent, but I spent a good 15 years imagining other people and romantic circumstances everywhere I went - few times was I satisfied with just what was. I loved your idea of wishing for better, setting our sights higher. Now as a stay at home Mom, I find myself using Facebook, TV or even food to escape the sometimes overwhelming drudgery of everyday. Just the past couple of weeks I have been trying to practice turning to God when that impulse to escape strikes, but am often finding it incredibly difficult - not only to do, but to WANT to do in that moment. I will keep trying and am inspired by your message that we will find the most contentment and fulfillment the more we live fully in the present with Him. Thanks for your post!

Report Abuse

Denise

April 13, 2012  11:49am

I LOVE that you wrote about this. I read a quote by G.K. Chesterton this morning: "Every time a man knocks on the door of a brothel he is looking for God." How true that is for women with these escapist fantasies--even when they are seemingly non-sexual in nature. (Ryan Gosling--perfect case in point. He's not naked in shots, and he's simply giving a validating compliment. Very easy to categorize as "harmless.") Something that encourages me greatly and freed me years ago, is when I am faced with this sort of temptation I acknowledge to God that somewhere beneath this desire is a legitimate need He intends to fill in His way and in His time. And that shame-free acknowledgment seems to be at least half the battle.

Report Abuse

Kathleen

April 10, 2012  11:11pm

Am I the only one who saw this as a parody skewering celebrity-fixated culture and social-media-fed delusions that movie stars speak directly to you? And, seriously Anna, looking to male celebrities for approval -- what part of that do you consider 'feminist'?

Report Abuse

Kathleen

April 10, 2012  11:11pm

Am I the only one who saw this as a parody skewering celebrity-fixated culture and social-media-fed delusions that movie stars speak directly to you? And, seriously Anna, looking to male celebrities for approval -- what part of that do you consider 'feminist'?

Report Abuse

kumunik8or

April 10, 2012  2:54pm

Part of wisdom may come with age, or from learning from God's inspired word. You have to come to priorities in your own life so you know where to focus your time, skills and imagination. Everything you do is done for God, so of course your family, be it the first one you are born into, or the one you create when you marry, is first in your life. Your friends and neighbors rank high on the list, some of them come to be like family. For me, I have spent much of my time learning things that allow me to grow as a servant in many areas, learning the meaning of the scriptures and how the Bible came to be compiled in modern form, how to serve the church and the community, how to lead and serve in schools, leading sectarian youth groups, like scouting, doing everything I can to help children and young people grow into mature adults. If you follow what you see as the talents God gave you, you really have your own imagination to take you where you need to go. I enjoy some fictional works but not sheer romance novels. I would rather learn about history or biography, so that I can learn from others mistakes or successes. My children and now grandchildren entertain me. I am thankful to have moved into senior apartments where I am one of the youngest and can look forward to living out my life here. I can visit with all my neighbors daily, participate in activities, set up my own Bible studies, lead Great Books courses (I am a trained leader), so much opportunity, so little time. God directs each of us if we only let Him.\

Report Abuse

JANE HINRICHS

April 10, 2012  11:25am

This post made me feel a bit OLD -- I am guessing Ryan Gosling is the dude in the picture. Books have their place. Movies have their place -- the best place for them is where we can go and get refreshed and come back charging to serve Jesus even more in our lives. If what we spend our time with is doing this then it is okay. If what we spend our time with makes us discontent with what we have and where God has put us then we ought to rethink it all.

Report Abuse

 *

1000 character limit

* Comments may be edited for tone and clarity.

See All 23 Comments
To add a comment you need to be a registered user or Christianity Today subscriber.
Login
or
Subscribe
or
Register
More from Her.menutics
The Real Value of Sex

The Real Value of Sex

Examining the lies that sex is worth nothing or sex is worth everything.
Suburbia Needs Jesus, Too

Suburbia Needs Jesus, Too

A woman's take on the New Radicals.
Angelina Jolie's Breasts and the Bravery of Letting Go

Angelina Jolie's Breasts and the Bravery of Letting Go

Refusing to let beauty become a trap.
Auditing America's Political Integrity

Auditing America's Political Integrity

The IRS scandal, Benghazi incidents, and the disappointment of dishonorable leadership.
Get Instant Access
Christianity Today Magazine
Subscribe now for a year (10 issues) at $24.95 for print, iPad, and instant web access.

International Orders

Include results from Christianity Today
Browse Archives:

So Hot Right Now

Are Women Really Saved through Childbearing?

Mother's Day, infertility, and redemption.

Follow Us

What We're Reading

CT eBooks and Bible Studies