‘Credibility’ Gap Worries Evangelists

What does the person on the street associate with the word evangelist? “Fanatic,” “pontificating,” and “fascist” were some responses in a recent informal survey, perhaps recalling the religious con artist played by Steve Martin in the film Leap of Faith who offered “miracles—reasonably priced.”

George Barna, author and pollster, recently found out that “credibility” and “relevance” were two of the top needs of evangelists in North America. In July, 2,500 men and women evangelists, their spouses, and others gathered in Louisville, Kentucky, to address those top two needs. Convened by the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association with 40 denominations and fellowships, the first-ever North American Conference for Itinerant Evangelists (NACIE) drew from nearly every state and Canadian province.

With headliners Graham, Luis Palau, Charles Colson, and E. V. Hill, NACIE sought to encourage, equip, and strengthen. Special minority-interest seminars dealt with reaching Black Muslims, Native Americans, and the physically challenged.

Personal integrity was a major concern. Conceding that evangelism’s image has suffered, Graham said the evangelists he knows are godly people. “One of the greatest needs in the church today,” he declared, “is to recognize the gift of the evangelist.”

Participants indicated their lives are sometimes lonely and painful. Evangelist Joe James of Mule Shoe, Texas, felt the NACIE encouragement was greatly needed. “It sets people free. It’s a hard world out there.” James Barker, a minister of evangelism in Winnipeg, Manitoba, concurred: “The evangelist has been belittled and made fun of and criticized to a point where he is feeling pretty low.”

Florida-based Arthelene Rippy often speaks at conferences exhorting pastors to avoid moral failure. “We’ve got to preach the pure Word,” she explained. “The life of the evangelist should back it up.”

NACIE will distribute to evangelists nationwide a document, “Biblical Standards for Itinerant Evangelists,” incorporating pledges of integrity in finances, ministry, and family and personal life. Conference leaders expect these accountability standards to become part of many denominations’ processes for accrediting evangelists.

Colson noted that while in 1976 it was “fashionable to be born again,” a 1992 Gallup poll found the group most feared in the United States was “fundamentalists.”

Youth and family outreach specialist Ron Hutchcraft stressed relating to a hurting but resistant audience. “People are drowning,” he exclaimed. All too often, “we lifeguards stay on the beach singing lifeguard songs and having lifeguard meetings.”

Copyright © 1994 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

Making Radio Waves: The tumultuous rise of Christian talk radio

Cover Story

Mixing Politics and Piety

John W. Kennedy

The Upside of Pessimism

German Reunification: One-Way Street?

Bill Yoder

Martyrs' Lost Plane Recovered in Ecuador

Kenneth D. MacHarg

A Russian Call to Repentance

Peggy Jackson, with reports from TASS News Service

Christians Blamed for Temple Arson

Global Praise Event Draws 12 Million Believers

Staff reports with News Network International

Prominent Iranian Church Leaders Slain

staff reports with New Network International

CRC Vote Overturns Women's Ordination

Randy Frame

Church, Synagogue Build Together

Sexuality Draft Draws Criticism

Timothy C. Morgan

Judge Finds Evangelist Degrauded Heiress

John Stewart in Los Angeles

War Chest Adds Funds Quickly

Tainted Funds Must Be Returned

Soccer Outreach Has Higher Goal

Andres Tapia

News

News Briefs: August 15, 1994

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from August 15, 1994

Paul's Prayer Priorities

Homosexual Healing

Refocusing the Family

Tim Stafford, reviewer

Abortion and the Failure of Democracy

Harold O.J. Brown, TEDS, reviewer

Why Christ Was Expelled

Roger Lundin, reviewer

Dr. Death's Dreadful Sermon

Peter J. Bernardi, Catholic priest

Why Jesus' Disciples Wouldn't Wash Their Hands

Networking for Peace

Randall L. Frame

America the Brutal

Caleb Rosado

Behind South Africa's Miracle

Michael Cassidy, African Enterprise

Pro-lifers' New Legal Nightmare

Steven T. McFarland, director of Center for Law and Religious Freedom

Stop Bashing the Christian Right

William Bennett, former sec of education and codirector of Empower America

ABC's Peggy Wehmeyer: On the Faith Beat

View issue

Our Latest

News

Facing Arrest, Cuban Christian Influencers Continue Call for Freedom

Hannah Herrera

Young people are using social media to spread the gospel and denounce the Communist regime.

Public Theology Project

Against the Casinofication of the Church

The Atlantic’s McKay Coppins told me about problems that feel eerily similar to what I see in the church.

Wire Story

The Religion Gender Gap Among the Young Is Disappearing

Bob Smietana - Religion News Service

Women still dominate church pews, but studies find that devotion among Gen Z women has cooled to levels on par with Gen Z men.

Just War Theory Is Supposed to Be Frustrating

The venerable theological tradition makes war slower, riskier, costlier, and less efficient—and that’s the point.

The Russell Moore Show

Karen Swallow Prior on Birds, Bees, and Babies

How should the church address infertility and childlessness?

Will the Church Enter the Guys’ Group Chat?

Luke Simon

Young men are looking for online presence. The church needs to offer more than weekly breakfasts.

Attempts at Cultural Crossover

From Pat Robertson’s soap opera to creation science, CT reported evangelical efforts to go mainstream in 1982.

Wire Story

Young, Educated, and Urban Pastors Are Most Likely to Use AI

Aaron Earls - Lifeway Research

A survey found denominational differences in pastors’ use of the technology, as well as widespread skepticism about its reliability.

addApple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseellipseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squarefolderGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastprintremoveRSSRSSSaveSavesaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube