Truth-Telling on Trial

Will racial reconciliation move beyond amnesty for those who admitted their errors?

Shortly before the election of Thabo Mbeki as South Africa’s new president, evangelical leaders asked for his support in making the country’s historic efforts at racial reconciliation more than amnesty for those who publicly confessed their misdeeds.

Led by Moss Ntlha, head of the Evangelical Alliance of South Africa (TEASA), the team urged Mbeki, a suave, scholarly technocrat who in June succeeded the revered Nelson Mandela as South Africa’s second black president, to maintain the climate of truth-telling. They urged him to maintain the momentum for national reconciliation, not just among the races, but also among social and economic classes.

The truth and reconciliation process, South Africa’s bold Christian experiment for finding healing instead of chaos from its violent past, has received worldwide praise (CT, Feb. 9, 1998, p. 18).

But evangelicals think Mbeki can improve on this achievement of Mandela’s five-year rule. “Reconciliation,” Ntlha says, “is not cheap grace, but is attended by a willingness to suffer in solidarity with victims.”

Ntlha believes the “burden for the nation’s reconciliation project was inordinately carried by the poor and most vulnerable victims of apartheid.”

It favors those who need amnesty, he argues. Amnesty was specifically mandated by the 1993 interim constitution; reparation was not. The process has been effective in achieving truth-telling and amnesty, and in giving priority to reconciliation rather than revenge.

But some African victims of apartheid see the process as a political mechanism for peace at the expense of justice. “Dreams of revenge,” observes Cindy Easterday, an American Presbyterian on the staff of African Enterprise, “costly as they may be, are hard for a newly free people to forgo.” The task involves “hardwiring reconciliation into a society that had internalized injustice and brutality for so long,” she says.

MAKING REPARATIONS: Evangelicals want the country to go the second mile on reconciliation and rescue it from its purely political meaning. “Politics has a tendency of emptying the term reconciliation of its rich spiritual significance, which would include confession, repentance, restitution, and reparation,” Ntlha says.

As with many Christian and political thinkers, Ntlha, a leader among the emerging Christian economists in South Africa, finds the process one of the most dramatic and hopeful signs of an au then tic Christian contribution to political life to emerge in many years.

He also knows it was the vision, courage, and international reputation of South Africa’s triumvirate of Nobel Peace Prize winners—Mandela, Anglican Archbishop Desmond Tutu, and the man who oversaw the orderly demise of apartheid, former President Frederick de Klerk—that helped the process achieve the success it now enjoys.

But Ntlha wants the South African experiment to withstand the winds of change. He says that although South Africa’s evangelicals were collectively slow in embracing the antiapartheid movement, they have now taken the lead in establishing a reparation fund to assist victims of human-rights violations in the apartheid era. This should be a uniting and enduring “contribution to the reconciliation process.”

Ntlha says he was very disturbed by one opinion Mbeki expressed at the meeting. “In his view, those who fought for freedom, and in the process got crippled or died, were not doing it for pay, and for them freedom is a worthy result of their struggle,” Nthla told CT. “For me, this sounds rather aloof for the plight of victims.”

Through the reparation fund, TEASA has brought the plight of victims closer to the churches and has made it possible for local churches to respond pastorally in acts of mercy and service, Ntlha says.

Ntlha acknowledges that legislative measures taken in the past five years have sought to bring about the transformation of society from one based on white supremacy to one based on equality. In five years, 500,000 housing units with electricity and running water have been built in townships and rural areas. But he says large sections of the people are still waiting for the promises of the new South Africa.

While evangelicals are engaged in the process of political reform and advocacy for the poor, they have not deserted the church’s spiritual mission. More than 1,000 congregations formed teams to pray and fast around the clock for three months before election day.

“Extraordinary circumstances demand extraordinary methods,” Jericho Walls, a national newsletter, declared. “Christians are praying that justice and forgiveness will replace bloodshed, and that God will … bring revival to the nation.”

Copyright © 1999 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Also in this issue

The Triumph of the Praise Songs: As praise bands and worship teams replace organs and choirs, the boomer tastes that reshaped our society are ruling our worship as well.

In Brief: July 12, 1999

New Song, Familiar Tune

Lauren F. Winner

New & Noteworthy: Biography

Karon’s Agenda

Lauren F. Winner. Quotations are drawn from an article in The Living Church, a magazine of Episcopal life.

Writing the Trinity

Christian Coalition Loses Exepmt Status

John W. Kennedy.

Praying for Movers and Shakers

Wiccans Practice on U.S Bases

Mark A. Kellner.

Voucher Plan Draws Mixed Reviews

Kenneth D. MacHarg in Miami.

God Speaks to Commuters

Jody Veenker.

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from July 12, 1999

Religious Liberty Bill's Passage Uncertain

Bountiful Believers in the Bayou

Doug LeBlanc.

Fidelity Urged to Fight AIDS

Odhiambo Okite.

In Brief: July 12, 1999

Evangelicals Resent Abandonment

Anglicans Recognize Papacy as 'Gift'

Slave Girls Find Redemption

Christians Held As Hostages

John Maust.

The Triumph of the Praise Songs

Michael S. Hamilton

Letters

Pain Relief

Gayle White in Atlanta.

The Ministry of Safe Play

Clem Boyd in Columbus.

Indianapolis: Graham Touts Muscular Christianity

Jody Veenker in Indianapolis.

Southern Baptists: City-Focused Evangelism Launched

Eric Reed in Atlanta.

The Biotech Temptation

A Christianity Today Editorial

Editorial

There Is Room in the Inn

Balkanized by Music

The Profits of Praise

Steve Rabey.

We Are What We Sing

Mark A. Noll

One Church, Two Faiths

Art Moore in Seattle

Integrating Mars and Venus

Rebecca Merrill Groothius and Douglas Groothius

Coming to a Neighborhood Near You

Peri Stone

Stuck on the Road to Emmaus

Escape from Fantasy Island

A Cracked Code

Ben Witherington III

View issue

Our Latest

The Bulletin

The Bulletin Remembers 2025

Mike Cosper, Clarissa Moll, Russell Moore

Mike, Russell, and Clarissa reflect on 2025 top news stories and look forward to the new year.

Strongmen Strut the Stage

The Bulletin with Eliot Cohen

Shakespeare offers insights on how global leaders rise and fall.

The Russell Moore Show

My Favorite Books of 2025

Russell shares his favorite reads of the year.

Evangelism and All That Jazz

In 1966, CT reported on church activities but also on LSD, The Beatles, and the war in Vietnam.

Why The Body Matters

Justin Ariel Bailey

Three books on ministry and church life to read this month.

Hark! The Boisterous Carolers Sing

Ann Harikeerthan

I grew up singing traditional English Christmas hymns. Then I went caroling with my church in India.

“Christian First, and Santa Next”

Even while wearing the red suit, pastors point people to Jesus.

How Pro-life Groups Help When a Baby’s Life Is Short

Adam McGinnis

Christian groups offer comfort and practical support for expectant families grappling with life-limiting illness.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube