Legal setback: Messianic Jews lose exclusive rights to use menorah symbol.

Official mark status revoked for Chosen People Ministries’ design

The Canadian branch of Chosen People Ministries (CPM), a messianic Jewish group based in New York, says it will appeal a court decision revoking “official mark” status for its menorah design (ct, June 10, p. 20).

Lawrence Rich, CPM’s Canadian director, says the ruling should concern other international religious charities with branches in Canada. “What was and is at stake,” he says, “is which groups can use symbols or images found in the Old Testament to represent themselves.”

The federal court in Toronto said in June that CPM is “an American charity with operations” in Canada. Thus, the court said, it is not eligible for protection under Section 56 of Canada’s trademarks act. Chosen People Ministries works in the United States, Canada, Germany, Israel, and Ukraine.

The court also said that because “official marks” carry more exclusive rights than trademarks, CPM could conceivably deny use of the menorah to Jewish groups.

Justice Pierre Blais wrote, “The menorah [has been] the official emblem of the Jewish faith and its people since antiquity. It would be counterproductive to prohibit Jewish organizations and associations from using and adopting a mark such as the menorah, since it [has] always been historically associated with the Jewish culture.”

Rich says CPM does not want legal rights to all menorah designs—just to its own.

The Canadian Jewish Congress, a Jewish advocacy group, charged that Chosen People Ministries cannot use any version of a menorah because it is a Christian group. It argued that cpm’s use of the menorah in its logo is “scandalous, offensive to Canadians, and deceptive.”

Merve White, the attorney who argued the case for CPM, disagrees. He says the menorah captures the group’s corporate belief that Jesus is the Messiah prophesied in traditional Jewish teaching. White says that cpm’s members use Jewish symbols during their worship services because they are Jews.

Copyright © 2002 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere

Christianity Today’s previous coverage includes:

Menorah WarsCanadian Jews sue Chosen People Ministries over use of ancient symbol. (June 5, 2002)

The ruling is available at the site of the Federal Court of Canada.

The official Website for Chosen People Ministries offers more information about the organization.

The Canadian Jewish Congress Website has an archive of press releases and resources on various issues.

Related CJC press releases and news articles include:

CJC pleased with menorah case ruling—Canadian Jewish Congress (May 30, 2002)

Chosen People defends use of menorah as official markThe Messianic Times

CJC Challenges Claim To Menorah As Christian Trademark—Canadian Jewish Congress (Jan. 7, 1999)

Also in this issue

Doors into Islam: September 11 has made Muslim evangelism even more dangerous and still more rewarding.

Cover Story

Doors into Islam

Netherlands: Devout Christian becomes prime minister.

Quotation Marks

Letters

New Top Anglican Receives Mixed Reviews

God's Funeral

Matters of the Heart

Standup for Jesus

Saving Africa

The Long View: Globalists R Us

"Children First, Schools Next"

Transcending Security

Darkness at Jesus' Tomb

Expecting a Flood of Tourists

Pocket Idolatry

Doctrine Still Matters

Columbia: terrorist kill two more evangelical pastors.

News

Go Figure

Spain: Christians fear AIDS media campaign may ignore how people get the disease.

India: Christians reach out to war-weary Muslims in Kashmir.

Evolving standards: Intelligent Design advocates ask Ohio to broaden origins discussion in public schools

Navy wins suit: Pentecostal chaplain plans to appeal discrimination case ruling.

Freedom fighters: Groups protest Sudan policy stalemate.

"Southern Baptists: Interfaith activity will cost D.C. Convention $476,000 in denominational funding."

"Cloning: President's Council on Bioethics recommends a partial ban, disappointing some conservatives"

Vietnam's Hidden Tragedy

You Can Take the Boy out of the Barrio…

No Dissing This Learning

The Little School in the Living Room Grows Up

Deconstructing Islam

View issue

Our Latest

Justices Debate Christian Therapist’s Challenge to ‘Conversion Therapy’ Ban

Colorado evangelical Kaley Chiles calls the law a violation of her free speech.

Wire Story

Tony Evans Will No Longer Pastor Dallas Megachurch After Restoration

Oak Cliff Bible Fellowship announced that its pastor of 48 years won’t return to leadership. The church expects son Jonathan Evans to succeed him.

You Don’t Have to Be Radical

Most Christians aren’t monks, missionaries, or martyrs. We’re unimpressive and unsatisfactory—yet saved by God’s scandalous grace.

From a Village of Bandits to a Village of the Gospel

Stuartpuram in India’s Andhra Pradesh was once known for its armed robbers. Then the gospel changed them.

Preservation Grants Help Black Churches Hold On to Their History

Over a hundred congregations have received up to a half-million dollars to repair deteriorating buildings and restore their place in their communities.

Four Truths About God for Children Who Can’t Sleep

And for the grownups—that’s all of us—who never outgrow their need for his presence around the clock.

News

Two Years After October 7, Christians See Fruit amid the Suffering

Churches in Israel and Egypt provide food, aid, and a listening ear to those scarred by war.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube