Theology

Calvin’s Biggest Mistake

Why he assented to the execution of Michael Servetus.

Today, heresy is hardly an operative term in Protestant church life, but in Calvin’s day to deny the Trinity was tantamount to committing treason against the basic foundation of society itself. Servetus was a hunted man all over Europe. He had been burned in effigy by the Catholics before he was burned in reality by the Protestants, and it could just as easily have been the other way around. Calvin believed that the civil magistrate was the custodian of both tables of the law and should punish heresy, blasphemy, and idolatry no less than murder, theft, and perjury. Roger Williams, a 17th-century Calvinist who preached and practiced religious liberty in early Rhode Island, denied the state any role in compelling obedience to the first table of the law, securing a firmer basis for freedom of conscience.

Calvin worked with a more medieval understanding of the unitary nature of society and thus limited the degree of liberty he was willing to concede to religious dissenters. We can note that the Genevan officials who condemned Servetus to death were actually Calvin’s opponents, not his henchmen. We can also point out that religious persecution was commonplace in Calvin’s century: Mary Tudor sent hundreds of Protestants to their deaths in England, thousands of Huguenots were killed in the massacre of St. Bartholomew’s Day, and many more Dutch Calvinists were slain by the Duke of Alva.

All this is true, but the fact remains that Calvin should have known better. The logic of his own thinking could and should have led him to agree with Sebastian Castellio, his sometime friend and later critic, who declared: “To kill a man is not to defend a doctrine; it is to kill a man.”

Copyright © 2009 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.

Related Elsewhere:

This is a sidebar to today’s main article, “John Calvin: Comeback Kid.”

See also today’s other sidebar, “The Reluctant Reformer: Calvin would have preferred the library carrel to the pulpit.”

Also in this issue

The CT archives are a rich treasure of biblical wisdom and insight from our past. Some things we would say differently today, and some stances we've changed. But overall, we're amazed at how relevant so much of this content is. We trust that you'll find it a helpful resource.

Cover Story

John Calvin: Comeback Kid

God and Gays

Review

CDs on The List

Review

Finding God in the Dark

White Flag in the Mommy Wars

Grace Amid the Vices

Out of This World

Great Questions of the Bible

Readers Write

Review

Reframing Human History

Letting Words Do Their Work

More Than Profit

Reveling in the Mystery

The Art of Cyber Church

Review

Mr. Wilson's Wild Ride

Saving Witches in Kolwezi

Intensive Care Week

A New Way to Finance Education

Hard Choices For Higher Ed

Books Uncommon and Offbeat

Liberty Unbound

Past, Present, Future

A Common Hope

Theologian of the Spirit

Man of the Bible

Sex, Lies, and Abortion

The Reluctant Reformer

My Top 5 Books on Islam

Editorial

A Unifying Vocation

The Accidental Anglican

Q & A: Wayne Pederson

News

Sending Slowdown

News

Quotation Marks

News

News Briefs: August 10, 2009

News

Counting Controversy

News

Go Figure

News

Accountability Breakdown

News

Seminary Plants

News

Setting Up Camp Afresh

News

Passages

View issue

Our Latest

The Bulletin

Young Republican Texts, Anglican Split, and George Santos Released

Controversial Republican texts, Anglican Communion splits, and George Santos’s sentence is commuted.

Review

Do Evangelical Political Errors Rise to the Level of Heresy?

A Lutheran pastor identifies five false teachings that threaten to corrupt the church’s public witness.

Highlights and Lowlights of 1957

In its first full year of publication, CT looked at Civil Rights, Cold War satellites, artificial insemination, and carefully planned evangelism.

News

Will There Be a Christian Super Bowl Halftime Show?

Conservatives suggest country and Christian artist alternatives for game day.

News

As Madagascar’s Government Topples, Pastors Call for Peace

Gen Z–led protests on the African island nation led to a military takeover.

News

Amid Fragile Cease-Fire, Limited Aid Reaches Gazans

Locals see the price of flour rise and fall as truce is strained and some borders remain closed.

News

Federal Job Cuts Hit Home as Virginia Picks Its Next Governor

Meanwhile, the GOP candidate draws from Trump’s playbook to focus on transgender issues in schools. 

Religious OCD and Me

Scrupulosity latches onto the thing we hold most dear—our relationship with God.

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube