Violence Mars Bonnke’s Revival

Sixteen Nigerians die during opening rally

Sixteen Nigerians died and hundreds were injured during an opening rally for a five-day revival organized in October by Reinhard Bonnke.

Bonnke is head of the Germany-based Christ for All Nations ministry and one of Africa’s most active evangelists.

The deaths occurred in Benin City in southeast Nigeria when a surge in the crowd of 550,000 turned into a stampede. Despite the tragedy, crowds grew even larger in subsequent rallies.

In 1991, Bonnke’s mission to Kano in northern Nigeria sparked battles between Christians and Muslims, resulting in an undisclosed number of deaths.

“You have to be extremely careful when you do evangelism so you don’t offend the Muslim populations,” says Abe Vreeke, director of Christian Reformed World Missions in Nigeria, who adds that Bonnke’s open-air crusades in Nigeria were “probably more negative than positive.” Vreeke was barred entrance to Nigeria in 1992 as part of a missionary crackdown by the government after Bonnke’s 1991 crusade.

Bonnke bills his crusades—usually held in large and already heavily churched urban centers—as revivals rather than evangelistic rallies. They frequently draw crowds of more than a half-million people to a single meeting.

Despite the controversy surrounding his crusades, Bonnke is perhaps the only Western evangelist to work effectively with the African Independent Churches (aic), which account for more than one-third of active church members in Africa. He affirms aic’s experiences and practices, and he is a gateway to wider public acceptance of these largely charismatic groups. But members of mainline churches also flock to Bonnke’s crusades.

A vision for African missions haunted Bonnke from an early age. “Night after night I saw the entire African continent, washed in the blood of Jesus, country after country,” says Bonnke, son of a German Pentecostal preacher.

But when he arrived in Lesotho 32 years ago, Bonnke found himself preaching to five people Sunday after Sunday. In the depths of despair, Bonnke decided to rent the national stadium and stage his first mass campaign.

Ten thousand people turned up and for the first time, Bonnke saw hundreds of people running forward, responding to the call for salvation. “I wept like a boy and vowed to the Lord that in obedience I would move across the whole of Africa to bring the vision to pass.”

Generally, Bonnke’s crusades result in greatly energized churches. But a few of his more ardent followers have become a problem for local churches. They expect—even demand—miracles, and they insist that evangelism is the only acceptable task of the church. Some of Bonnke’s followers also demand evidence in fellow Christians of his list of spiritual gifts, including “excitement in the Spirit,” speaking in tongues, being slain in the Spirit and collapsing in a heap, laughing uncontrollably, and dancing in the Spirit.

Related Elsewhere

Bonnke’s web site, Christ for all Nations, has crusade reports, but not yet one for the Nigeria crusade.

Also in this issue

Hymns on MTV: Christian music has traveled a long way from the pages of the Bay Psalm Book to the charts of Billboard magazine. Now Jars of Clay is shaking up Contemporary Christian Music.

Cover Story

Hymns on MTV

by Randall Balmer

Graham Meets with Iraqi Leaders

Jar Boys Meet Sgt. Pepper

Randall Balmer

The Business of the Kingdom

Tim Stafford

God on the Gridiron

Mark A. Kellner

The Battle for the Inclusive Bible

John G. Stackhouse, Jr.

Running with Jonah

The Movie Missionary

Matt Donnelly

Are Christians Required to Tithe?

D. A. Carson

Classic & Contemporary Excerpts from November 15, 1999

Who Do Artists Say That I Am?

Karen L. Mulder

Take Ten Commandments and Call Me in the Morning

by Archibald D. Hart

New and Noteworthy: Theology

How to Silence Scripture

Scouts’ Dishonor

Conservatives Voice Support for Bauer

Jody Veenker

An Education with a Backbeat

Yvi Martin in Greenville

New Indictment in Fraud Case

Chuck Fager

In Brief: November 15, 1999

NBC Purchases Chunk of Pax TV

Malcolm Foster

Four Priests Resume Teaching Duties

Jody Veenker

Gun-Toting Missionaries Given Light Sentences

Odhiambo Okite

Vatican Amends Indulgences Doctrine

Jody Veenker

70 Christians Arrested While at Church

Compas Direct News Service

Evangelical Leader Leaves Wife for Man

In Brief: November 15, 1999

Neopaganism’s Bewitching Charms

Loren Wilkinson

Shopping for the Real Me, Part 1 of 3

Lee Knapp

Shopping for the Real Me, Part 2 of 3

Lee Knapp

Shopping for the Real Me, Part 3 of 3

Lee Knapp

NCC to Undergo Major Restructuring to Solve Financial Woes

Jerry L. Van Marter

New Laws Protect Homosexuals

Why I Hate The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc

Ronald F. Maxwell

1984 50 Years Later

John Wilson

NCC Celebrates 50 Years of American Ecumenism

Jerry L. VanMarter, Ecumenical News International, in Cleveland

Hindus Protest Papal Visit to India

Open-Door Policy Part 3

Sarah E. Hinlicky and Lauren F. Winner

The Greatest Pokemon Match Ever: Pikachu vs. God at the Cineplex

Steve Lansingh

Smile God Loves You!

Steve Lansingh

The Messenger: A Story of Joan of Arc

Peter T. Chattaway

Feed the Children Battles Controversy

Jody Veenker

Amassed Media: Hooray for Holywood

Turkmen Authorities Fine Release Baptist Pastor

Felix Corley, Compass Direct

Sydney's Archbishop Overrules Decision to Allow Lay Presidency

Jeannie Zakharov Ecumenical News International, in Sydney

Wire Story

Christians Protest Proposed Mosque

Religion News Service

America Legislates for the World! ' Part 1

Hazem Abdou

America Legislates for the World! ' Part 2

Dr. Hassan Abu Talib

Apologetics' Missing Links

Matt Donnelly

Letters to the Editor

Haunted by the Style Czarina

Michael G. Maudlin, Managing Editor.

Letters

Evangelism: To the Jew First?

Keith Hinson.

Sudan Oil Exports Draw Protests

Debra Fieguth.

Oregon: From Cult Site to Teen Camp

by Art Moore.

Intelligent Design: Searching for a Blueprint

Tony Carnes in New York City.

Editorial

The Wall’s Long Shadow

Editorial

Our Unoriginal Sin

View issue

Our Latest

The Light of Life

Joni Eareckson Tada’s Advent reflection on this dark-become-light season.

Christmas Tears

Jonah Sage

Christmas reminds us that God took matters into and onto his own hands.

The Christmas Cloud

Dave Harvey

Christmas feels decidedly unmerry when our emotions don’t align with truth.

Night Skies and Dark Paths

Scott James

God is our unwavering guide through incomprehensible darkness.

From Limping to Leaping

Jared C. Wilson

A story of cancer, calves, Christmas, and the coming of Christ.

Darkness, Then Light

Ronnie Martin

Introducing Christianity Today’s 2025 Advent devotional.

Let There Be Hope

Chad Bird

God is still at work amidst darkness.

Christmas in Wartime

Daniel Darling

How can Christians possibly pause for Advent in a world so dark?

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube