News

10 Striking Biblical Archaeology Stories of 2025

Research and natural disaster uncovered exciting finds from the ancient world.

Workers from the Israel Antiquities Authority excavate a section of a city wall from the Hasmonean period in the Old City of Jerusalem.

Workers from the Israel Antiquities Authority excavate a section of a city wall from the Hasmonean period in the Old City of Jerusalem.

Christianity Today December 23, 2025
Leo Correa / Associated Press

Megiddo, site of the biblical Armageddon and home of the discovery that capped off our top 10 list last year, continued to yield noteworthy discoveries in 2025. 

This year’s archaeology stories highlight discoveries that have helped us learn more about the biblical world and the context that gave us the Bible. Some are controversial. Some are serendipitous.

The most important biblical archaeology discoveries of this year may not be known until months or years from now, as archaeologists study their findings in the lab, research them, and publish their reports in scientific journals. This list is the stories we learned about this year.

10. Megiddo Discoveries Linked to King Josiah’s Armageddon

Megiddo, the famous archaeological tel with 20 levels of ancient urban civilization, continues to be the nexus of archaeological discoveries in the Jezreel Valley of northern Israel. The earliest known Christian church was discovered in a nearby prison there, adjacent to a Roman legion camp uncovered in 2013. This year, one of the oldest dateable winepresses ever discovered in Israel was revealed.

A highway salvage and improvement excavation project along Israel’s Highway 66 nearby uncovered many exceptional finds from different periods, including the 5,000-year-old winepress as well as ritual Canaanite cult vessels from 3,300 years ago. 

On Tel Megiddo itself, where archeologists found unexpectedly large amounts of Egyptian and Greek pottery in a recently excavated building, research connects the finds to Judean king Josiah’s ill-fated attempt to stop Egyptian pharaoh Necho from coming to the aid of the Assyrians against the Babylonians. 

Josiah’s reforms following the reign of the idolatrous king Manasseh are praised in the biblical text: “There was no king like him,” 2 Kings 23:25 says (ESV). But verse 29 reports that this military blocking maneuver ended in his ignominious death at Megiddo. 

Necho is believed to have included Greek mercenaries as well as Egyptian soldiers in his army, thus accounting for the strange mixture found by the archaeologists. In the subsequent battle of Carchemish in 605 BC, Necho and the Assyrians were crushed by the Babylonian forces and the Babylonians became the dominant power in the region (Jer. 46). 

9. Hasmonean Wall Excavated From Under Herod’s Palace

One of the sturdiest walls that ever surrounded Jerusalem, 30 feet tall and 15 feet wide, was apparently dismantled from the inside. But Israeli archaeologists aren’t sure whether King Herod or one of his Hasmonean predecessors did it. 

This month, the Israel Antiquities Authority announced results of an excavation next to the Tower of David Jerusalem Museum at Jaffa Gate. One hundred years ago, a British-mandate prison covered the site. Many levels below, 2,000 years ago, Herod built his palace atop the ruins of this Hasmonean wall. 

The ancient Jewish historian Josephus reports that the Hasmonean leader John Hyrcanus I was forced to dismantle Jerusalem’s walls as a condition for ending a siege by Antiochus VII Sidetes in 132 BC. Alternatively, the Israeli excavators say that Herod himself could have demonstrated his authority in supplanting the Hasmoneans by taking the wall down to its foundations before rebuilding. 

The resulting new wing of the Tower of David Museum is being designed with a transparent floor, so that visitors will be able to see these archaeological remains below.

8. New Roman Roads Map Released 

As the apostle Paul so ably demonstrated, the web of well-constructed roads across the Roman Empire facilitated the spread of the Christian gospel. Now, we have a clearer picture of just how far those networks stretched: There’s a new road map

An international team of researchers combed archaeological reports, modern and ancient maps, historical accounts, satellite images, and other sources to develop a road database with 14,769 road segments. That’s a total of 185,896 miles, “more than seven times the circumference of the Earth,” according to one of the project’s leaders, Tom Brughmans of Aarhus University in Denmark.

As a testament to Roman engineering, a number of the ancient roadways are still in use, now covered by modern asphalt. The database is free and accessible online.

7. Samaria Gets Another Look and Stirs Controversy 

Samaria, the capital of the Northern Kingdom of Israel from 880 BC to 722 BC, has been largely off limits to archaeology for the past half century due to its location in the politically sensitive West Bank. An excavation that began this year is directed by the Civil Administration, through which Israel controls civilian affairs in Palestinian areas, rather than the Israel Antiquities Authority. 

Already, the project has discovered a stone pavement flanked by decorated columns that connected the heart of the city to the main gate. This street dates to the Herodian or New Testament period when Herod rebuilt the city and named it Sebastia in honor of the Emperor Augustus.

Controversy stirred later in the year when the Civil Administration announced plans to expropriate a 450-acre tract of privately owned Palestinian land to develop the site for a national park. Critics say both the archaeology and the land appropriation violate international law. Israeli authorities say the action was taken due to neglect and destruction at the site.

6. Egypt Nationalizes St. Catharine’s Monastery 

Egypt made the stunning announcement in May that it was nationalizing St. Catherine’s Monastery, a sixth-century complex in the Sinai on a site that memorializes the Ten Commandments given to Moses. It is a UNESCO World Heritage site and the oldest monastery still operating as a monastery. The Greek Orthodox monks who live there maintain a library that contains many of the world’s earliest Christian manuscripts.

In October, Greek prime minister Kyriako Mitsotakis announced that negotiations with Egypt had resulted in an agreement that “guarantees the character of the monastery in perpetuity” and will maintain its character as a place of Christian worship. Egypt says its plans for the site included enhancements to serve tourists.

5. Pottery Inscription Details Assyrian Threat to Ancient Jerusalem

A royal communication from the king of Assyria was discovered in 2025, in the form of a one-inch pottery sherd bearing a cuneiform inscription. The inscription says, “Dear King of Judah, send the tribute quickly before the first of Av. If not, the consequences will be severe.”

The clay seal had been attached to a letter or official dispatch and was dated to around 700 BC, a time when the king of Judah, perhaps Hezekiah, was a vassal of Assyria. It’s the only Assyrian inscription ever found in Jerusalem, discovered when refuse from a drainage channel near the Temple Mount was sent for wet sifting.

Though it’s impossible to know for certain, the seal impression could be evidence of Hezekiah’s resistance, as reported in 2 Kings 18:7: “He rebelled against the king of Assyria and did not serve him.” Petrographic analysis revealed that the clay’s mineral composition corresponded to the geology of the Tigris River basin, where Nineveh and other capital cities of Assyria were located.

4. AI Redates Daniel in the Dead Sea Scrolls

Artificial intelligence has bolstered conservative Bible scholars in the debate over the Book of Daniel. The prophecies in Daniel 11 so clearly describe events in the fourth to second centuries BC that liberal scholars maintained it had to have been written much later than the sixth-century-BC lifetime of Daniel. 

Scholars in the Netherlands submitted some Dead Sea Scroll documents to a special AI model for analysis, and most of them matched previous dating by paleographers. But 4Q114, containing chapters of Daniel that included a description of the Maccabean uprising that began in 167 BC, dated in a range between 230 and 160 BC. 

No one believes this is the original text actually written by Daniel. It’s a copy of generations of copies, going back well before the events prophetically described in Daniel 11. 

Artificial intelligence is giving historians many new documents to read by speeding up the translations from ancient languages. That also includes, as was announced this year, hundreds of thousands of pieces of medieval Jewish texts recovered from the geniza (storage room for retired documents) of a Cairo synagogue. They have all been digitized but most have not been read or studied yet.

3. Wildfire Reveals Much More of Bethsaida 

The loss of digging tools to a wildfire last July was tempered by the revelation of the widespread remains of a Roman-period village that surrounded the excavation at el-Araj, believed to be the site of Bethsaida, hometown of the apostles Peter, Andrew, and Philip. 

Archaeologists began work at el-Araj 11 years ago, convinced that Bethsaida was located along the Sea of Galilee shore and not at another site a couple miles away. With the revelation of the wildfire, little doubt remains that el-Araj was, indeed, Bethsaida.

The providential removal of the heavy foliage at the site did not damage the remains of a Byzantine basilica that was being excavated. Three years ago, a mosaic referencing the apostle Peter had been uncovered in the basilica, further evidence for the identity of the site.

Besides being the home of three apostles, the Gospels say that the feeding of the 5,000 and the healing of a blind man took place in Bethsaida. Jesus also castigated Bethsaida, along with Chorazin, for its lack of repentance (Matt. 11:21). 

2. Pool of Siloam Uncovered Behind a Dam

Unfazed by the inability to find the other three sides to the Pool of Siloam that matched some stone steps uncovered in 2004, archaeologists kept digging over the past couple of years and discovered the largest dam ever found in Israel, which is also the oldest in Jerusalem. It’s 40 feet high and 26 feet wide.

The dam was built around 800 BC when Joash or perhaps Amaziah reigned as king of Judah. It was designed to collect water from the nearby Gihon Spring as well as floodwaters from the Jerusalem hillside. Climate data from elsewhere in Israel indicates 800 BC was a time of low rainfall interspersed with intense storms, which could cause flooding.

The Pool of Siloam had been thought to have served as a mikvah, for ritual bathing. Jesus told a blind man he healed to wash the dirt and spit out of his eyes at that location (John 9:7). Some archaeologists have now suggested that the depth of the pool may have instead allowed Herod to stage mock naval battles, which were in fashion in the Roman Empire in those days.

1. Gihon Spring Cultic Center Announced

A curious discovery announced early in 2025 rates a closer look, not only for its timing but also for what the announcement didn’t say.

Fifteen years ago, researchers discovered remains from an eight-room cultic center near the Gihon Spring, Jerusalem’s original water source in the Kidron Valley. In the midst of still-standing walls, they found a small olive press and winepress as well as a standing stone, a masseba, to mark a holy spot. It’s the only one ever found in Jerusalem. 

The cultic center seemed to have been decommissioned during the eighth century BC, around the time of Hezekiah’s religious reforms described in 2 Kings 18 and 2 Chronicles 19. 

Eli Shukron, the director of the excavation, believes that with remains going back to around the 18th century BC, they could possibly link this cultic installation to the reign of Melchizedek.

Melchizedek is a mysterious kingly priest, prefiguring Jesus’ role as Messiah, who shared bread and wine with Abraham (Gen. 14:18). He’s mentioned again in Psalm 110:4 and Hebrews 5–7. The Melchizedek speculation was omitted from the news release in 2025, but Shukron shared his conviction of the connection in several online videos

Perhaps more importantly, the release also failed to mention any possible connection to the crowning of King Solomon and what it signified. 

On a chaotic day near the end of King David’s reign, his son Adonijah tried to assert his claim to the throne. The prophet Nathan and Queen Bathsheba conspired to make sure Solomon was proclaimed king instead. David instructed them: “Have Solomon my son mount my own mule and take him down to Gihon,” where he was crowned. (1 Kings 1:33)

The significance of Gihon was established in a day that came much earlier in David’s reign, however, when he brought the Ark of the Covenant to Jerusalem. Second Samuel 6:17 says he had prepared a tabernacle or tent for the ark, likely in the vicinity of the Gihon spring—and related to this cultic installation that existed for centuries before and after David. 

Some people informally refer to this as “temple zero,” in relation to the first temple built later by Solomon and the second temple built in the time of Jesus by Herod the Great.

So why the hush-hush about the two connections? Archaeologists are uncomfortable with the word likely. Untethered, it can lead to wild speculation. However, ancient cities had to be centered around a water source and a worship center of some type. This historical knowledge gives the discovery resonance. Perhaps further evidence to support the discovery is waiting to be dug up.

An official with the City of David Foundation (which controls much of this most ancient part of Jerusalem) indicated that the organization is still trying to figure out how to open up this tiny space to the legions of tourists and pilgrims who would want to see the site where Jerusalem first became a holy city.

Church Life

CT Media’s Favorite Podcast Episodes of 2025

A selection of notable conversations from The Bulletin, The Russell Moore Show, and some of our latest podcast series.

Images from three podcast episodes in the list.
Christianity Today December 23, 2025
Illustration by Christianity Today

The Russell Moore Show

Listen in as Russell Moore, CT editor at-large and columnist, talks about the latest books, cultural conversations, and pressing ethical questions that point us toward the kingdom of Christ.

As AI applications continue to become more present in our daily lives, Russell and Paul engage in a timely, bracing, unsettling, and oddly hopeful dialogue about how to remain human in an age increasingly hostile to humanity itself.

In this episode, New York Times columnist David Brooks joins to talk about what he calls one of the greatest ruptures of his lifetime: the implosion of the conservative movement’s moral center. The two take this a step further and turn toward questions of cultural repair and spiritual renewal: Is there any real possibility of revival—in literature, in politics, in faith? What might it look like to recover a moral vision strong enough to resist the acid of our age? And what role could Christians play in offering a better way?

The Bulletin

In CT’s flagship news commentary podcast, Clarissa Moll, Mike Cosper, Russell Moore, and special guests dive into current events and breaking news and share a Christian perspective on issues that are shaping our world.

This year was one of pushing the limits, both politically and technologically. In this episode of The Bulletin, David French joins Mike Cosper and Russell Moore to share how the courts can be a limit on President Donald Trump’s power; Bonnie Krisitan dives into whether AI should be used in a church context; and Knox Thames shares updates about Chinese persecution of Uyghurs. 

With the drastic changes to immigration policy and practice under Trump 2.0, the story of Nelson and Gladys Gonzalez’s deportation after a 35-year life in the US provides an insight into the complexity and humanity of those being deported. Their story is an example of what it looks like to love your neighbor, as they minister to others inside ICE detention facilities. Written and read by Andy Olsen.

Being Human

Steve Cuss, a former trauma and hospice chaplain, pastor, and leadership coach, guides listeners in a gospel-informed journey of discovery into the world of emotional health: everything from anxiety and reactivity to triangulation, overfunctioning, and the Enneagram.

Steve and Clarissa discuss how the pace of modern life can obscure God’s presence and how intentional pauses can restore spiritual clarity and resilience. The conversation dives into rumination, false needs like control and approval, and the role of prayer and journaling in nurturing healthier relationships.

Steve Cuss and psychologist theologian Chuck DeGroat work through the hidden dynamics behind pastoral burnout, narcissism, and the slow erosion of integrity. They explore how unexamined coping mechanisms shape identity, why church boards often miss red flags, and what it really takes to create a culture of safety and true accountability. Steve and Chuck offer tools for healthier leadership—inside and outside the church.

The Just Life with Benjamin Watson

The Just Life with Benjamin Watson is a thought-provoking podcast exploring what it means to live a life rooted in justice, faith, and human dignity. Hosted by Super Bowl champion, author, and justice advocate Benjamin Watson, each episode features candid conversations with leaders, thinkers, and everyday heroes who are confronting injustice and building a more equitable world. From race and religion to politics, policy, and practice, Watson engages guests with humility and boldness, asking the hard questions that lead to hope-filled action.

This episode with Lecrae dives into our current cultural moment of extreme division and political partisanship with an open conversation about how to graciously and truthfully live from a lovingly gospel-filled place as believers.

This year has been filled with devastating conflict within and outside of our country’s borders. This conversation with Stephen Enada sheds light on the horrifying crisis currently facing Nigeria’s persecuted church and provides practical ways we as Christians can support and provide aid to our brothers and sisters in Christ overseas.

Devil and the Deep Blue Sea

From the creators of the hit podcast The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill comes a new show, Devil and the Deep Blue Sea, which takes you back to the Satanic Panic that gripped America in the 1980s and ’90s. This limited series explores how hysteria gripped parents and teens through cautionary tales like Go Ask Alice, influenced notorious criminal cases like the West Memphis Three, and catapulted the political agenda of the Moral Majority.

We explore the strange and troubling era of the 1980s and ’90s when America—especially the evangelical church—became convinced that satanic ritual abuse and occult activity hid around every corner. From local news reports warning of dark rituals to churches hosting “record burnings” to purge secular music, fear of a hidden, demonic conspiracy dominated the cultural landscape.

The 1960s promised a revolution—civil rights, moon landings, and peace, love, and rock and roll. But it also brought riots, rising drug use, and missing kids. By decade’s end, American parents weren’t just worried—they were terrified.

News

10 Notable Christians We Lost in 2025

Remembering Kay Arthur, John MacArthur, Jennifer Lyell, and others.

Images from three articles in the series.
Christianity Today December 23, 2025
Illustration by Christianity Today

“All share a common destiny,” says the writer of Ecclesiastes (9:2), the complicated and the uncomplicated alike. Such were those we lost in 2025.

This year, the church laid to rest Christian leaders whose names were sullied by scandal and those whose persevering faithfulness will echo long after their death. Those whose public ministry mingled precariously with personal politics and those who stood against the majority to champion the voiceless. Their families and loved ones, churches and communities, miss them deeply.

In reviewing these names, we recognize both the equalizing fate of the grave and the energizing hope the Resurrection offers to each one who calls Jesus Lord. In alphabetical order, here are ten Christian leaders who died in 2025:

News

Kenyan Christians Wrestle with Boys’ Rites of Passage

Some pastors offer circumcision ceremonies as an alternative to older practices involving ancestor worship, misogyny, and dedicating children to demons.

Kenya boys and parents.
Christianity Today December 22, 2025
Image courtesy of Moses Wasamu

Twenty-five 12 and 13-year-old boys and their fathers huddled around a bonfire on a 64-degree November night in Nairobi, Kenya. They warmed themselves, ate goat meat, talked, and laughed. Their fathers prayed for them and offered them advice, readying their sons for a coming-of-age ceremony the next day.

For the previous ten days, the boys had stayed together at East Africa School of Theology, Buruburu, preparing to “graduate” into manhood. As part of that preparation, a doctor came to the campus to complete their circumcisions—a long standing Kenyan rite of passage. Program organizers then spent days teaching the boys about spiritual disciplines, Christian identity, sexuality, responding to peer pressure and drug abuse, and other topics.

Gregory Anemba signed his son up for this camp experience because he didn’t want his 12-year-old to participate in a traditional Kenya coming-of-age ceremony, which often includes tribal religion, chauvinistic views of women, and an introduction to alcohol.

“[Traditional circumcisers] invoke altars, and children are dedicated to demonic spirits,” said Anemba. Traditional ceremonies can also contain food and drink offerings to ancestors or Mother Earth.

Anemba said finding the Rites of Passage Experience (ROPES) program, which was founded in 1997 by five local churches, was providential. “I liked it because of the godly values that are taught there,” he said, pointing to the program’s focus on spiritual, emotional, and relational health.

Rites of passage practices are common in Africa and vary by cultural group. In Kenya, circumcision rites have marked the transition from boyhood into manhood for most men since time immemorable. Unlike circumcision in the Old Testament, the Kenyan practice serves as a time to initiate youth into adulthood and the identity and values of their community. While some parents quietly take their children to the doctor for circumcision, ceremonies are the norm.

Churches across Kenya are introducing more faith-based coming-of-age ceremonies in hopes of preventing families from turning to traditional spiritualist ceremonies or even leaving the church during circumcision season, which occurs in November or December once every two years.

Traditional rites begin at night with the boy’s maternal uncle slaughtering a cow and tying its entrails around the boy’s neck to symbolize his mother’s dowry—also a cow—returning to his family. Early the next morning, a traditional practitioner—usually without medical training—circumcises the boy and his peers by the riverbank. The teens live together during a 7-14 day healing period, then attend an initiation ceremony with singing, dancing, traditional liquor, and sometimes sexual orgies.

Caleb Wekesa, a pastor in Bungoma County in western Kenya, said boys and their families at his church receive cultural pressure to seek out traditional rites of passage. Wekesa said three men left his church because they wanted their sons circumcised traditionally, contrary to what the church advised. Even a deacon left, never to return.

“Sometimes when they leave, they go and join other churches where they are accommodated,” Wekesa said.

Tanari Trust, an organization founded and overseen by five Nairobi-area churches, started the ROPES program, holding their first camp in 1997. Since then, many other churches have adopted the concept and run their own versions.

Sasino Sijenyi, who has helped organize ROPES programs for Kenya Assemblies of God for the last four years, said more churches now recognize the importance of transition ceremonies for young people.

“The Church stepped in when they realized that parents were secretly taking their children who are in church to traditionalists for circumcision,” he told CT.

He explained that they support African cultural practices while rejecting the unbiblical aspects of the rites.

The ROPES graduation ceremony includes nods to Kenyan culture—such as singing, dancing, and cultural gifts—while keeping the message Christian. Organizers honor themes such as honor for parents and community responsibility, ideas valued in Christianity and African culture. During graduations, ROPES gifts each boy with a Maasai shuka (cloth wrapper) symbolizing protection, a traditional beaded multi-colored belt (to remind them to exercise self-control over their sexuality), and a rungu (club) to symbolize responsibility.

Churches receive pushback from traditionalists who want rites of passage to remain under their domain, not the domain of pastors and ministry leaders. Despite Christian alternatives, some parents still take their children to traditionalists.

“It seems that parents, even though they are Christians, still don’t get out of culture,” said Sasino.

Philip Kimone, a Christian and a father of three, supports rites of passage, but not by churches. He argued that even Jesus was circumcised in a Jewish cultural rite, so Kenyans should be circumcised according to their cultural traditions.

“The church cannot take over culture,” Kimone said. He also criticized church ceremonies, saying they only teach boys about the Bible and neglect to teach African history and identity: “That is where I divorce with the church conducting rite of passage.”

He also objects to single mothers participating in church graduations in the absence of the boys’ fathers. In Kenyan culture, only men typically attend coming-of-age ceremonies.

Sasino disagreed, saying churches draw from Jesus’ example in Luke 2:41-52, when both Mary and Joseph took 12-year-old Jesus to the temple and found him there again after leaving him behind.

Still, Sasino tries to find men who will stand in as fathers for boys who have none: “Some boys are embarrassed when their single mothers come during their graduation.”

Sasino hopes Christian-based rites of passage will provide a corrective to traditionalist views of circumcision.

“We remind them that circumcision is not what makes a man,” he said. “It is just a rite that reminds them of the event.”

News

The Last Christian Boarding Houses of New York

One of the lowest-cost housing options in cities once came from faith-based organizations. That has all but disappeared.

Residents and staff of Hephzibah House, a historic boarding house and Bible school on the Upper West Side.

Residents of Hephzibah House, a historic boarding house and Bible school on the Upper West Side.

Christianity Today December 22, 2025
Illustration by Elizabeth Kaye / Source Images: Courtesy of Hephzibah House, Getty

At Christmas, the Hephzibah House on the Upper West Side looks like something out of a movie. The first level of the historic brownstone has a cozy parlor with a Christmas tree, fireplace, twinkle lights, garland running up the wooden banister to the bedrooms upstairs, and warm smells of baked goods and brewing coffee coming from the kitchen.

Back in the 1920s, this was a Christian boarding house for women in New York City, where the women lived, ate, and studied the Bible together. Today it’s a Christian guest house, no longer offering long-term boarding, though photos from those days still hang on the walls. It is one of the most affordable spots for visitors to the city, and while guests accept inconveniences like sharing a bathroom, they enjoy the cheaper rate, gorgeous historic molding, and etched wallpaper.

Boarding houses were once some of the lowest-cost housing in cities, providing rooms for $100 to $300 a month—in today’s dollars—a number that even those considered below the poverty line could afford. Typically, in historic boarding houses, tenants rented bedrooms and shared common spaces like parlors and kitchens.

This type of affordable lodging has all but disappeared, though a few options survive in New York. Some urban Christians and an increasing number of political leaders want to bring back this type of affordable communal living, known today as single-room occupancy (SRO).

The problem of expensive housing has hit everyone in the US, but it is acute in cities like New York, where the median rent for a Manhattan apartment is $4,625.

Penelope Morgan, who runs Hephzibah House and lives there with her family, receives requests for long-term housing all the time from Christian parents who might not know the history of religious boarding houses but who want the same institution for their children arriving to the city in 2025.

The young people may be coming to the big city for an internship or new job and are looking for an affordable, safe place to land. Morgan tells them that Hephzibah House can’t host long-term.

“There are all these Christians from around the country who could come here and be an influence in our city,” Morgan said. “It’s very hard to get here now.”

Morgan has dreamed of acquiring another brownstone and turning it into that kind of housing. She already has a name for it in mind—“Hephzibah Haven.”

Christian organizations played a big role in establishing urban boarding houses in the 1800s, some intentionally serving poor people or immigrants and others offering basic housing to working-class men and women new to the city.

Before community sports and catchy songs, this was the mission of the Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA) as well. The YMCA was designed to “give young men moving from rural areas safe and affordable lodging in the city.” The Young Women’s Christian Association (YWCA) opened its first boarding house in New York in 1860 as more single women came to the city for work; eventually YWCAs spread like fire in other cities across the country. New Yorker Dorothy Day also started several Catholic housing initiatives for urban workers around this time.

In Chicago, most boarding houses for women in 1914 were associated with church groups, historian Jeanne Catherine Lawrence has documented. One Windy City offering was Eleanor Clubs, Christian boarding houses for women. The homes offered affordable rooms and communal living spaces, eventually housing 600 women at their peak. A form of the Eleanor Clubs existed until recently as the Eleanor Residence for Working Women and Students.

Philanthropist Ina Robertson, a devout Presbyterian who studied church history at the University of Chicago Divinity School, founded the Eleanor Clubs.

Robertson saw women who came from small towns to urban jobs “adrift,” as she said, and thought communal living would help them feel less isolated. They could also learn the Christian virtue of “love expressing itself in service,” wrote Lawrence, though Eleanor Clubs did not require attendance at worship services like the early YWCA did. Still, Robertson taught classes for Christian women at the clubs, specifically one for women training to be deacons.

The residents of Eleanor Clubs, Lawrence wrote, had a single or shared bedroom, parlors, reading rooms, sewing rooms, laundry, and big dining rooms for all the residents. Food and furnishings were simple, and the clubs had their own newspaper, the Eleanor Record.

“It truly is ministry to do that, especially for women—people who are often overlooked,” Christie Reves told CT.

Reves currently lives in one of the last remaining boarding houses in New York, Saint Agnes Residence. Saint Agnes is a Catholic institution for about 100 women on the Upper East Side. The rooms are small but affordable, and women have shared bathrooms and kitchens.

Reves’s room is spare: a twin bed with a crucifix hanging on the wall. But it suits her needs and is in a good location with a doorman. The building forbids guests, which makes Reves feel secure because she wouldn’t know who could be in her living space otherwise.

Reves ended up at Saint Agnes because she was moving to the city for work and was looking for an affordable, faith-based option. She remembered that when she was a student in Paris she had done a short-term stay at a Catholic boarding house there—and loved it—so she looked for one in New York when she arrived.

“Being completely new, I was looking at what can I find temporarily that lets me land and provides a sense of community and is maybe closer to work,” she said.

Even today, women’s wages are generally about 20 percent lower than men’s, so if they’re on their own, finding an affordable place to live is often more important, she noted.

“The times haven’t changed … if you look at why these [boarding houses] were founded,” she said. Affordable housing often has a “social stigma” and doesn’t always appeal to a woman on her own. But Saint Agnes has been a “safe and dignified situation.”

In the Saint Agnes communal kitchen, Reves has met younger and older women, including artists who might not have money for New York rents.

“I can start my job, build my relationships, figure out where I could live in the city,” said Reves. “It’s just a good place to land. It feels safe.”

Another remaining Catholic boarding house is St. Mary’s Residence on the Upper East Side, which offers rooms for women with shared bathrooms and kitchens for $1,224 a month. Regular housekeeping service is included.

Menno House, a home in Manhattan’s Gramercy Park, is not as old as other religious boarding houses in the city but has been providing low-cost communal living since 1997 for those pursuing Mennonite-related ministry or education. It has rooms for long-term residents at a steal for Manhattan: $881 a month. Residents share a kitchen and a garden out back that grows flowers and herbs for the house.

Also, a sort of boho, nonreligious boarding house model has popped up more recently, called Cohabs. The Cohabs homes have monthly house breakfasts and other events like yoga classes to help fight loneliness for the city’s newcomers. The company advertises its communal living as more carbon-neutral, with solar panels and rainwater harvesting.

New York once had 200,000 SRO units—basically boarding house rooms—in the mid-20th century. But in the 1950s and 1960s, politicians argued that SRO dwellings spread diseases like tuberculosis in shared bathrooms.

Cities also often banned the number of “unrelated” individuals who could live together, which had the effect of banning these religious dwellings. Zoning regulations, too, targeted SROs through setting minimum square footage for apartments, for example.

Now most of New York’s SRO stock is gone.

“Ironically, had SROs grown since 1960 at about the same rate as the rest of the U.S. housing stock, the nation would have roughly 2.5 million more such units—enough to house every American experiencing homelessness in a recent federal count more than three times over,” wrote Pew researchers in a brief on the issue.

Desperate for housing now, New York is considering a bill to allow the construction of SROs again. Some Western states have also passed legislation in recent years to expand the construction of these boarding home rooms. Perhaps the boarding house will return.

“Sometimes good policy is not brand new policy,” said Washington State Rep. Mia Gregerson, after the state passed a bill to expand SROs last year.

City planners think New York’s faith-based organizations could lead the way on building more communal housing.

The city’s religious groups own more than 92 million square feet of land, which is about 2.5 times the size of Central Park, according to New York University’s Furman Center. Much of that is permitted for residential use and is not built to its capacity; if it were possible to build out the maximum capacity, it would yield 98,000 homes, according to the center. But regulations are often a barrier, among other issues.

That land exists in part because of churches’ longevity and in part because they stayed when populations fled cities in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s, said Jonathan Keller, a longtime city planner in New York and a Christian. Churches who stayed could cheaply acquire properties in those times of urban blight.

“There’s so much need and there’s so much opportunity just from a real estate standpoint,” said Keller, who is the son of the late New York pastor Tim Keller.

He hopes to start a business one day to help churches learn how to navigate New York’s labyrinth of real estate systems and the financing for development projects on their land. Developing housing here requires lawyers, experts, and capital funds for pre-development costs before any building happens.

“Churches just don’t have that experience or institutional knowledge,” he said.

Keller is thinking specifically of New York, but there is a wider movement. Churches and other religious organizations have been pushing for zoning relief that allows churches to build affordable housing on their land. Called “Yes in God’s Backyard,” the movement was successful in California with the passage of SB 4 in 2023. The law allows churches to bypass zoning laws and build housing.

In Minnesota, churches have also started tiny home communities called “sacred settlements.” Other organizations have popped up to help faith-based organizations develop their land, including Bricks and Mortals.

Though single-bedroom rentals serve older and younger single people, they can help everyone. SROs and boarding houses simply introduced additional housing options, Keller said. More SRO housing stock for single people could free up other housing for families. “People need different options at different times in their lives,” he said.

“It’s helping the church inwardly, but it’s also an outward expression of what the gospel means for renewal of the city,” Keller said. “It would bring in a lot of Gen Zers and younger kids I think. They’re very spiritual and interested in faith but they’re very distrustful of institutions.”

A church offering housing “would be a great testimony that could get people interested in the church,” he added. 

History

A Time of Moral Indignation

CT reports on civil rights, the “death of God” theology, and an escalating conflict in Vietnam.

An image of MLK
Christianity Today December 19, 2025
Illustration by Christianity Today / Source Images: Getty

The passage of President Lyndon Johnson’s landmark civil rights bill did not end Black Americans’ struggle for civil rights. In 1965, Martin Luther King Jr. led a march from Selma to Montgomery, Alabama, to demand the right to vote. CT’s news editor reported from the scene

It was a varied multitude—young and old, white and black, educated and uneducated, a few beatnik types, and ministers in clerical garb. … Some in the line carried American and U. N. flags. The overall spirit was cheerful; disaffection was not noticeable and the torrential rains on the third day elevated, rather than depressed, morale.

Among those in line was a one-legged young man on crutches, two nuns, a number of clergymen, and numerous women and children. … The group developed a warm feeling of friendship and unity. Meetings were held at the campsite in the evenings, and occasional hymns added a devotional tone.

A Negro Methodist minister said that the march represented the American melting pot. He saw it as an expression of concern for constitutional rights. The ultimate solution, he declared, lies in the grace of God. He recognized the historic manifestation of grace at the Cross, yet felt it was being silently proclaimed at the march. …

Theological conservatives participated in the march. … The extent of evangelical involvement is believed to have been without precedent in the current civil rights movement. Never before have conservative Protestants identified themselves so demonstratively with the Negro struggle for liberty.

The unifying factor in the midst of the theological and social diversity was clearly the constitutional issue—protest against abridgment of the right to vote and peaceable assembly to petition the government for redress of grievances.

King called for clergy across the country to join the march. CT surveyed religious leaders’ responses and reported the views of white ministers in Selma. The magazine noted the political issue was intense enough to divide churches and denominations

The race problem in the United States, which promises little let-up in the months and years to come, may ultimately cause some major ecclesiastical realignments. It is already registering a serious impact. …  This spring saw several such disputes erupt into open dissension. … 

In Savannah, Georgia, the congregation of St. John’s Episcopal Church voted, 700 to 45, to withdraw from the Protestant Episcopal Church rather than admit Negroes to its regular worship services. Balloting was held at a meeting during which the Rev. Ernest Risley, rector, said he was renouncing the ministry. … 

In Texas, Dr. K. Owen White resigned as pastor of the 3,600-member First Baptist Church of Houston to take an executive post with the Southern Baptist General Convention of California. Just prior to the announcement of his resignation, the congregation voted 206 to 182 not to accept Negro members. White, past president of the Southern Baptist Convention, said he was disappointed in the outcome of the vote but insisted that it was not a factor in his leaving.

Billy Graham went to Alabama in 1965 to hold an evangelism crusade. The event was integrated, but Graham made it clear he wasn’t going to focus on civil rights

Graham announced at the outset that he had come, not to preach about racial problems, but to “preach the same Gospel I have preached all over the world.”

But he did indicate that outside his public meetings he wanted to talk with leaders of both races about the problems that have recently brought the state to the world’s attention. Graham told a reporter: “It is wrong for people in other parts of the country to point an accusing self-righteous finger at Alabama. To single out one state as a whipping boy often becomes just a diversion to direct attention from other areas where the problem is just as acute.”

Still some Alabamans accused him of coming “as President Johnson’s personal ambassador to soothe the feelings which Martin Luther King has ruffled.” …

Despite rampant rumors that preceded the opening meeting on Saturday night, April 24—including one of a bomb threat—Rip Hewes Stadium was half-filled with 5,500. The choir of 400 voices, about half Negro, sang with George Beverly Shea, and when Graham arose to speak all feelings of tension vanished as the presence of God was felt in the stadium. In response to the invitation, almost 250 of both races stood shoulder to shoulder in front of the platform to register decisions for Jesus Christ.

Christians were also concerned about changing sexual ethics in America. In 1965, CT published pieces on rising divorce rates, the “tide of obscenity,” and a syphilis epidemic in more than two dozen major metropolitan areas. Editor in chief Carl F. H. Henry said it was “A Time for Moral Indignation.” 

What America’s present moral situation requires even more than laws and their enforcement is the arousal of a tidal wave of righteous moral indignation against a wanton exploitation of sex. There are signs that such an indignation is smoldering beneath the surface. Every American dedicated to common decency must become morally indignant and let this indignation burn righteously in an articulate protest against an exploitation of sex that is unparalleled in the history of the world. Never before in human civilization has sex been so pervasively prostituted to financial gain, for the technological possibilities were not present until our time. Public opinion is still a powerful force for public righteousness. It can outshout all the sounds of modern communication if it finds its voice and in moral indignation lifts it high.

The millions of Christians in America have a special duty. They know that when anything becomes a national idol, it is because God has first been displaced and his moral law set aside. The final resolution lies with God, who alone can give purity of heart. But until such a time, Christians are summoned to reflect his holy wrath against every unclean thing.

CT editors also commented on the philosophy of the popular pornographic magazine Playboy

Now and then we read Playboy—not often, confessedly, but when Hugh Hefner, its editor, occasionally sends a copy hoping Christianity Today will debate his philosophy of sex. …. 

The “new morality” asserts that love alone justifies intercourse and that, if two persons intend to marry, love is the only other precondition for sex relations. Christianity does not say “No” to sex; it says “Yes” on the basis of divine creation. But it says “No” to premarital sex on the basis of divine commandment. The Christian view is that sex relations are legitimate only within the marital institution. …

The Christian emphasis on personal love in the very nature of God and on Christ’s love for his bride carries an implicit protest against the discounting of agape in the sexual life of the modern world. Our confused generation has lost the profoundly Christian meaning both of monogamous marriage and of love.

The magazine informed readers of developments in liberal Protestant theology, including the death of theologian Albert Schweitzer, the success of an Anglican bishop’s book advocating “secular theology,” and the emergence of a group of Americans proclaiming the “death of God.”

Can it be that the “death of God” writers have fallen into the trap (so common to purveyors of intellectual abstractions) of assuming that most people see the same and the only reality that they themselves see?

If the “death of God” position is, as seems most plausible, that God has died because men no longer find him believable or useful, then it must follow that God never really lived except in the imaginations of men. Apparently, these men are saying, not that God has died, but that he never really had an independent existence. These theologians never say outright that there is no transcendent, independently existing God. Rather, the essence of their argument seems to be that we cannot know or comprehend God because of our limited perceptual, cognitive, and intellectual abilities. …

What if they had made different assumptions or accepted the validity of different kinds of data or asked different questions?

Evangelicals were worried about orthodox Christian scholarship. CT polled the members of the Evangelical Theological Society and found “wide gaps” in contemporary research

The element missing in much evangelical theological writing is an air of exciting relevance. The problem is not that biblical theology is outdated; it is rather that some of its expositors seem out of touch with the frontiers of doubt in our day. Theology textbooks a half century old sometimes offer more solid content than the more recent tracts-for-the-times, but it is to the credit of some contemporary theologians that they preserve a spirit of theological excitement and fresh relevance. Evangelicals need to overcome any impression that they are merely retooling the past and repeating clichés. If Bible reading has undergone a revolution through the preparation of new translations in the idiom of the decade, the theology classroom in many conservative institutions needs to expound the enduring truths in the setting and language of the times. Unless we speak to our generation in a compelling idiom, meshing the great theological concerns with current modes of thought and critical problems of the day, we shall speak only to ourselves.

Internationally, CT reported on India and Pakistan’s war over Kashmir, checking on the Christians caught in the middle.

From Dr. Kenneth Scott, director of the Christian Medical College and Hospital in Ludhiana, India, came a cable: “Everyone fine. All remaining in Ludhiana. Psalm 68:19.” The Scripture cited reads, “Blessed be the Lord, who daily bears us up; God is our salvation.”

No missionary evacuations were reported. Korula Jacobs, secretary of the National Christian Council in India, said that more than sixty American missionaries were staying put on the plain of Punjab, where the fighting was concentrated. … 

The most extensive damage to church property appeared to be suffered by the Anglican cathedral at Ambala, India. It was struck by bombs from a Pakistani B-57 (American-made) jet. Observers indicated the building was a victim of its geographical location—a quarter-mile from an air force base.

Another ongoing Asian conflict grabbed headlines. The US government decided to send combat troops into the long-running war in Vietnam. CT reported that evangelical missionaries planned to keep ministering despite the increased danger of an escalating conflict.

As the hot jungle war of Viet Nam grows bloodier, missionaries with ears attuned to the cacophony of gunfire do their job but keep their bags packed. …

The Christian and Missionary Alliance’s 100 missionaries have had an emergency retreat plan ready for ten years but don’t expect to use it, reports the Rev. Louis L. King, the denomination’s foreign secretary. “We have known since February that the situation would become almost intolerably bad through October and have planned on it,” he said. Alliance workers, who once covered the countryside, are now specializing in city work, as symbolized by three new churches being built in Saigon. King said the war has meant more people listen to the Gospel more seriously.

When U. S. government dependents were sent home in February, officials asked Alliance workers to pull out but weren’t successful. King said Alliance policy is to leave only when the U. S. diplomatic corps does. If a withdrawal comes, he said, a strong indigenous church will remain with 350 pastors and 65,000 laymen who operate now without American money.

A second major group in Viet Nam, Wycliffe Bible Translators, has also withdrawn into defended villages in the past year. But it has taken natives along to speak the tribal languages so that the work of translating the Bible into these tongues can go on. The organization has forty-four persons assigned to Viet Nam, of whom nineteen are on furlough. All Wycliffe teams are “within the sound of gunfire,” said Dr. Richard Pittman, director of work in Asia. But there have been no casualties since two men and a baby were killed in 1963. Pittman said Wycliffe follows American and Vietnamese military advice on where to locate.

Evangelicals in America were not quite as prepared. The war in Vietnam would dominate politics for the next decade.

News

Amid Fear of Attacks, Many Nigerians Mute Christmas

One pastor has canceled celebrations and will only reveal the location of the Christmas service last-minute.

A burned church building in Mangu, Nigeria on February 2, 2024, following weeks of violence and unrest in the Plateau State.

A burned church building in Mangu, Nigeria on February 2, 2024, following weeks of violence and unrest in the Plateau State.

Christianity Today December 19, 2025
Kola Sulaimon / Contributor / Getty / Edits by CT

In past Decembers, pastor Paul Maina’s congregation at Church of Christ in Nations (COCIN) Njilang in Chibok, Borno state, Nigeria, spent the week before Christmas celebrating. They often went house to house, singing in the local Cibak language, dancing, bearing gifts, and sharing meals. Maina prepared a midnight Christmas Eve service at church. Non-Christian neighbors joined in the festivities.

“These were happy times,” Maina told CT. “But that is no more.”

The church began canceling festivities in 2020 due to terror attacks in the area. This year, the holiday will be quiet. His congregation won’t go caroling. He won’t hold a Christmas Eve service at his church. After his more than 20 years of ministry there, he said Chibok no longer feels like home because Christians live in fear.

Chibok is one of the few towns with Christian local governments within the majority Muslim state, and it has been a target of Islamic terrorist group Boko Haram’s violence against Christians and moderate Muslims. In 2014, Boko Haram infamously kidnapped more than 200 Christian schoolgirls from the area, including Leah Sharibu.

Leading up to Christmas, members of Boko Haram have visited villages in the Chibok area, seemingly looking for their next attack, Maina said. The visits have increased since November, prompting many residents to leave their homes.

“If you see a motorbike, if it’s not a soldier, it is Boko Haram,” Maina explained. “They use this to create fear and panic.”

It works. Most villagers sleep in the bushes instead of inside their homes, Maina said, as they fear nighttime attacks. Because churches are often exposed to violence—at least four area churches have been bombed or burned this year—pastors don’t dare hold services there. Maina gathers his 300-member congregation in open fields, but even that’s risky.

“[Christians] are careful with whatever we do during this season,” Maina said. “We are not free to celebrate.”

Like Maina, other pastors in Nigeria’s north and Middle Belt are also bracing for the holiday and canceling services. They fear attacks by Islamic extremists, who know churches will be packed, roads crowded with traveling families, and villagers distracted by celebrations. Militant groups, especially Boko Haram, have used Christmas attacks in the past to boost media coverage of their demands.

On Christmas Eve in 2020, Boko Haram militants attacked Pemi, five miles from Njilang, while the villagers prepared for celebrations. Militants killed at least seven Christians and burned down the Church of the Brethren alongside 10 houses. Survivors fled the community. Many never returned.

“The attacks are to make communities scared and to spoil the Christmas celebrations,” Christian clergyman Oliver Dashe Doeme told Aid to the Church in Need. “They don’t want Christians to enjoy Christmas.”

On Christmas Day in 2023, Islamic groups killed at least 160 and wounded 300 during a weeklong attack on at least 17 Christian communities in Plateau State in Nigeria’s Middle Belt. Last year, Christians in the Mkomon district of Kwande Local Government Area in Benue State were preparing their homes for Christmas lunch when attackers killed 11 people. 

Maina said the Nigerian military warned against any outdoor events between 7:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m. due to the recent threats, which is why he canceled his Christmas Eve celebrations.

Fear isn’t the only barrier to Christmas gatherings. Terrorist attacks disrupt food supplies for holiday celebrations, which for farmers in the north fall during the peak of the dry season, when they gather and store crops. Durning the dry season, clashes also intensify in the North Central region between armed Islamic Fulani herders and poorly defended farmers. As the herders move their cattle looking for pasture, they often ruin fields and set ablaze homes and barns.

In November, Yohanna Yakubu, a farmer and member of Church of the Brethren in Nigeria, traveled an hour on his bicycle to harvest maize on his rented farmland. He couldn’t find land closer to home. Yakubu plants low-maintenance maize, so he doesn’t have to risk traveling to tend it often. Harvest usually requires Yakubu and his hired workers to stay on the property for two or three weeks. He harvested early this year and hired extra workers to finish within a week, trying to avoid attackers.

“I had to harvest [quickly] because of the fear,” he told CT. “But some others cannot even go to their farm any longer. It is too risky.”

Yakubu, a resident of Mbalala, a town seven miles from Chibok, said villagers from outlying areas seek safety with other Christians in Mabala during Christmas. Last year, he hosted five people. “I am always willing to allow them [to] stay with me.”  

Boko Haram’s violence has forced some Christians to spend the holiday in camps for internally displaced persons (IDP) after fleeing their homes. Some nonprofits donate food, clothes, and medicine during Christmas, but the IDP camp in Chibok has no Christmas services.

Maina has already officiated or attended more than a dozen funerals of Christians killed by militants this year. He doesn’t want to bury more at Christmastime.

The national government has set up a barrack to protect the community, Maina said, but even the soldiers run away at the sight of the attackers, leaving the villages vulnerable: “The local government cannot do a thing because it’s beyond its strength.”

So Maina seeks strength from God, the testimonies of other local churches, and congregants who attend his services despite the threats. “It is encouraging that they do not give up,” he said.

From the pulpit he warned church members against unnecessary travels this season and assured them he will hold a Christmas Day service, though he’s not sure when and how. He’ll let church members know at the last minute.

He’s afraid but said the church is used to Boko Haram’s threats: “We will meet no matter their plan.”

Books

A Heartwarming Book on Sin

Three books on theology to read this month.

Three book covers.
Christianity Today December 19, 2025
Illustration by Christianity Today

This piece was adapted from CT’s books newsletter. Subscribe here.

Alan J. Thompson, A Basic Guide to Biblical Theology: Nine Themes That Unite the Old and New Testaments (Baker Academic, 2025)

Fitting the whole Bible together can be challenging. Many readers are familiar with some of the most dramatic stories and most famous wisdom verses but would struggle to put them all in sequence—let alone assemble them into an overarching story that makes theological and narrative sense.

That is why basic introductions to biblical theology can be so helpful. Summarizing the story of Scripture, showing people what to look for as they read it, and helping them visualize how it all hangs together can help readers find their feet in God’s Word and can give them tools to make sense of it.

Sydney Missionary and Bible College New Testament scholar Alan Thompson does this thematically. Nine biblical themes receive a chapter each—Creation and Fall, covenant, Exodus and tabernacle, Law and wisdom, sacrifice, kingship, prophetic hope, kingdom of God, and Holy City—topped and tailed by discussions of how to put the Bible together as a whole.

The clarity and simplicity of these themes is a strength of the book, as is the frequent use of diagrams to illustrate them. Thompson’s tone is also helpful. His hermeneutic is unapologetically Baptist, but he gives his reasons and highlights areas where people disagree, explaining differing positions fairly.

In places, the book is not as basic as its title suggests, with less storytelling and more jargon (and mentions of the millennium) than we might expect. But this is a short, clear, fair, lucid, and well-researched introduction to biblical theology will serve plenty of students and serious laypeople well.

Timothy Keller, What Is Wrong with the World? The Surprising, Hopeful Answer to the Question We Cannot Avoid (Zondervan, 2025)

It is not easy to write a compelling, heartwarming, devotional book on sin. The subject lends itself to treatments that either breathe fire or water things down, depending on the audience. It’s hard to get to the heart of human sinfulness in a way that both exposes and explains, confronting the sin while comforting the sinner. The fact that Tim Keller has done both in What Is Wrong with the World? is testimony to his remarkable preaching ministry and to the skill with which his wife, Kathy, has posthumously presented it.

Keller’s approach is to show us seven ways in which the Scriptures picture sin, each rooted in a different biblical narrative. In the story of Cain, sin is a predator crouching at the door. In the story of Saul, it shows a frightening capacity for self-deception. In Jesus’ parables, sin is leaven, quietly but inevitably spreading until it is rooted out. To Jeremiah, sin is mistrust; with Jonah, self-righteousness; with Naaman, leprosy; with the Israelites in the wilderness, slavery.

Each picture receives a chapter full of biblical wisdom, psychological insight, practical illustration, and gospel hope, and each impressively reads like a book chapter rather than a transcribed sermon, which makes it a refreshing joy to read (also impressive, given the topic). The book concludes with two chapters on true repentance drawing from Psalm 51. Highly recommended.

Blaise Pascal, Pensées (1670)

Blaise Pascal (1623–1662) was a genius. He gave his name to a philosophical dilemma, a unit of pressure, and a mathematical triangle—and he only lived to the age of 39. But he was also a deeply thoughtful Jansenist theologian whose blend of biblical observation, cultural analysis, apologetic wit, and charismatic experience makes him fascinating to read on nearly any topic.

Many of his theological arguments have extraordinary sticking power. The Pensées (literally, “thoughts”) are an eclectic assembly of them, in the form of aphorisms, one-liners, paragraphs, short essays, and personal testimonies. Yet they still sparkle nearly four centuries later.

Some have become familiar. Many readers will have come across his wager about betting on God’s existence or his quip that the sole cause of humanity’s unhappiness is that people does not know how to stay quietly in their room. (For Pascal, the reason for leaving his room is that if he stays there quietly, then he thinks about death, so he fills his life with diversions instead.)

His evangelistic method has also been highly influential: Since people despise religion and are afraid it might be true, we have to first show that religion is worthy of respect, then make good people want it to be true. Only then do we show that it is.

But the book also fizzes with humor, penetrating apologetics, and biblical insight. (I will never read the Joseph story the same way again.) Most of all, Pensées displays a deep love for Jesus.

Andrew Wilson is teaching pastor at King’s Church London and author of Remaking the World: How 1776 Created the Post-Christian West.

Theology

Come, Thou Long-Expected Spirit

The Holy Spirit is present throughout the Nativity story. So why is the third person of the Trinity often missing from our Christmas carols?

A picture of a dove flying in light.
Christianity Today December 19, 2025
Vlad Georgescu / Getty

My New Testament professor Gordon Fee said something in class that sticks with me to this day. “Let me hear you sing. Let me hear you pray,” he said, “and I will write your theology.” His point was that Christians, as a matter of conviction, typically set to music the things they most cherish about God. What we cherish about God on the evidence of our Christmas carols, however, should make us wonder.

In carol after carol, we sing “of the Father’s love begotten” and we extol the one in whose “name all oppression shall cease.” We sing our praises, that is, of the Father and the Son but rarely of the Holy Spirit. In the second stanza of Charles Wesley’s 1744 hymn “Come, Thou Long Expected Jesus,” we petition Christ’s “eternal Spirit” to rule in our hearts alone. And that’s just about it. The Holy Spirit is breathtakingly absent from our canon of carols.

Our Christmas hymns give glory, laud, and honor to the first and second persons of the Trinity, but we fail to give similar praise to the Third Person. In doing so, we not only fail to give honor to whom honor is due; we also fail to bear faithful witness to the record of Scripture. If our music gives evidence of what we cherish most about God, the God of our Christmas carols is binitarian, not Trinitarian.

Why is there such a stark absence of the Spirit in our repertoire of carols? How does this stand in contrast to the witness of Matthew and Luke? And what might we do about it?

First, the majority of our carols come to us by way of the medieval age, with the exception of a handful of 18th-century hymns. Medieval Christianity placed a dominant emphasis on Christology, and Franciscan piety prioritized an affective encounter with the events of the manger. Mary’s tender love, the shepherd’s astonished faces, the angels’ celestial acclamation, the noble adoration of farm animals?

These images of Christ’s birth captured the imagination of the poets of this age. The prior events, such as Mary’s Spirit-overshadowed pregnancy or Zechariah’s Spirit-inspired song, remained offstage and secondary to the main-stage events.

A second reason is cultural. Our usual celebration of Christmas in America is shaped less by the accounts of Matthew and Luke and more by the stories and songs of 19th-century Western life, as I’ve written previously. Many of our most beloved carols, including “It Came upon the Midnight Clear” by Edmund Hamilton Sears and “Do You Hear What I Hear?” by Noël Regney, were penned, in fact, not by Trinitarian but by Unitarian Christians.

The carol “O Holy Night,” which Unitarian minister John Sullivan Dwight translated into English from the poem “Cantique de Noël” and which remains a beloved favorite on Christmas Eve services, was originally written by a French poet who later apostatized.

Charles Dickens, while officially Anglican, attended a Unitarian chapel while he wrote A Christmas Carol, and for him, it was the spirit of Christmas, not the Spirit of Christ, that ought to mark the celebration of the season. Such a conviction echoes the desire of many Americans today. They’re happy to sing about peace on earth and joy to the world, but only because these things are generically religious goods. It’s much harder to sing about the Prince of Peace who endures the Cross for the joy set before him (Heb. 12:2). Such a song would be scandalous rather than innocuous. 

Christians often tag along with this way of thinking about Christmas music, because they too love the “traditional” songs. They clamor for “The First Noel” and “Silent Night” on Christmas Eve because they say, “This is what we’ve always done.” Except that we haven’t. The way American Christians have typically celebrated Christmas is only 150 years old. It is not a terribly long tradition, and it is not fully biblical, at least not as it relates to the ministry of the Holy Spirit, and it owes more to the market than to our theological convictions.

The “canon” of Christmas carols is closed because the market says so, and with it any possibility that the Holy Spirit might gain entrance into our habitual practices of communal singing. That’s the third reason: the market is the boss, not our biblical faith.

When we look at how Matthew and Luke tell the story of the Incarnation, however, we see that the Spirit plays a central rather than peripheral role. Luke writes that John the Baptist “will be filled with the Holy Spirit even before he is born” (1:15). In the same chapter, the angel tells Mary that the Spirit will come upon her and, as at the beginning of all things, the power of the Most High will hover over her (v. 35).

In Luke 1:41, Elizabeth is filled with the Spirit the moment she hears Mary’s greeting. In Luke 1:67, the Spirit fills Zechariah in order that he might prophesy to the Lord’s future doings through his son, John. In Luke 2:25, we encounter an elderly man, Simeon, upon whom the Spirit rested. And in Matthew 1:18–20, finally, the angel reassures Joseph that what Mary bears in her womb is the Holy Spirit’s doing.

All this Spirited activity has its roots in Isaiah’s vision of what was to come, and it climaxes in the events of Pentecost. In his 2017 essay “The Holy Ghost of Christmas Past, Present, and Future,” John Witvliet reminds us of the Book of Isaiah’s status as “the fifth Gospel,” for it is here that we read of the role the Spirit of the Lord would play in the Messiah’s life. All the Old Testament prophets, in fact, who bore witness to this future Messiah did so because the Spirit of Christ was within them (1 Pet. 1:11).

Witvliet summarizes Luke’s gospel this way:

Luke depicts the entire Christmas drama as fully Trinitarian, involving God the Son, who was born in a manger, God the Father, who sent him, and also God the Holy Spirit, who was mysteriously active in so many moments in the drama.

To put the matter bluntly, there is no Incarnation apart from the power of the Holy Spirit. There are no miraculous births without the work of the indwelling Spirit. There is no ability to confirm or to recognize the true identity of the Christ child apart from the illuminating ministry of the Third Person of the Trinity. The Spirit is very much visible, not invisible, in the Nativity narratives, and an active rather than passive agent in Luke’s “account of the things” (1:1).

For the Gospel writers, this isn’t a negligible or dismissible matter. The Spirit’s presence in the Nativity is emphatically newsworthy. Luke especially magnifies the Spirit of God in his tale of Christ’s birth. Why do we not also?

One thing we could do is to recover and repurpose ancient texts. This might include medieval hymns, such as “Creator of the Stars at Night,” with its sixth stanza that gives explicit praise to God the Spirit:

To God the Father, God the Son,

And God the Spirit, Three in One,

Praise, honor, might, and glory be,

From age to age eternally.

It could include the hymn by the fourth-century poet, Prudentius, “Of the Father’s Love Begotten,” with its robust witness to the Holy Ghost. A second thing we could do is to set to music a greater number of Charles Wesley’s Nativity hymns. This might include Hymn 8 with these lines:

And while we are here,

Our King shall appear,

His Spirit impart,

And form his full image

of love in our heart.

Or these lines from hymns 9 and 17, respectively:

And meekly in his Spirit live

And in his love increase! …

His Spirit is our surest guide

His Spirit glimmering in our hearts.

The other way forward is to sing new songs. It is extraordinarily difficult to find such songs—songs that are suitable, that is, for congregational worship. If Spirit-themed songs have been written about the Nativity story, they’re usually of a devotional sort, suitable for personal or nonliturgical enjoyment.

Who then will write the hymns that will help us magnify the Holy Spirit? Who will raise a hallelujah to the comprehensive ministry of the Third Person of the Trinity in the stories of the Gospel writers?

Which singer-songwriters will help us to sing of the God who chooses to use the most unlikely characters, not just the teenage Mary or the doubting Zechariah, but also tax collectors and sinners, the grafted-in Gentiles, and the one-time-violent figure of Paul?

Which church musicians will help us to sing of the God who did the impossible through the wombs of both Mary and Elizabeth and who continues to do the impossible by healing the sick and the traumatized, raising the dead to life, and causing our wildernesses to blossom with life?

Which worship leader will help us to sing of the God who inspires prophetic speech that bears witness to the divine promise to raise the lowly, scatter the proud, fill the hungry, and extend mercy to all those who sorely need it?

Songs such as these will not only do our faith good, they will offer us a chance to acclaim the person and work of the Holy Spirit with all our heart, soul, mind, and strength, in the manner of the ancient hymn:

Christ! to thee with God the Father,

And O Holy Ghost, to thee,

Hymn and chant and high thanksgiving

And unwearied praises be,

Honor, glory, and dominion,

And eternal victory—

Evermore and evermore.

Amen and amen.

W. David O. Taylor is associate professor of theology and culture at Fuller Theological Seminary and the author of Open and Unafraid and Prayers for the Pilgrimage. He posts about art and theology @davidtaylor_theologian on Instagram.

Church Life

Who Writes History When There Is No Winner?

Lebanon’s civil war is a taboo subject. A group of Christians and Muslims is broaching it.

Two men sit at a table in what remains of their devastated Beirut apartment in 1984 during Lebanon's civil war.

Two men sit at a table in what remains of their devastated Beirut apartment in 1984 during Lebanon's civil war.

Christianity Today December 18, 2025
Peter Charlesworth / Getty

Eight somber Muslims sat around white plastic tables on the gold-tinged red carpet of Sayyida Aisha Mosque in Sidon, Lebanon. Arabic sweets beckoned, but few partook. The seriousness of the occasion—reviewing their memories of Lebanon’s 15-year civil war that ended in 1990—seemed to make several uneasy. They did sip their tea.

Four were Lebanese native to Sidon. Four were Palestinian refugees. Several wore beards, some long and scraggly, others short and trimmed. One was a former fighter in the war. Another lost family members when a Christian militia massacred inhabitants in Tel al-Zaatar.

Beginning in 1975, Christians, Muslims, and Palestinians plunged Lebanon into a regional conflict that included Israel and Syria, leaving 150,000 dead. Those convening the meeting, a Lebanese evangelical and a Druze follower of Jesus, hoped to unravel the reasons behind the highly contested conflict. Their host, chief judge for the Sunni Muslim court in Sidon and imam of the mosque, lent his legitimacy to the sensitive proceedings.

As participants received a 12-page document presenting Lebanese history that preceded the war, they were taken aback by reading a fully Christian perspective. But then the story shifted to Muslim perspectives, divided between Lebanese and Palestinian views. Three versions of history, none legitimized over the other.  

Many Christians do not call Lebanon’s tragedy a civil war. They emphasize how Palestinian refugees brought local destruction in their fight against Israel. Meanwhile, Palestinians emphasize displacement from their homeland and their need for a base from which to fight Israel. Lebanese Muslims sympathized with Palestine but aimed to change a sectarian political order that disproportionately favored Christians.

When the group finished reading the document, the evangelical stood up.

“Which narrative do you sympathize with the most?” he asked.

Martin Accad, president of the Beirut-based Near East School of Theology, spoke in his capacity as founder of Action Research Associates (ARA), which is working on a project that presents civil war history through multiple narratives. Cofounder Chaden Hani took notes. Their project is unique because, in schools, history books end shortly after the country’s independence in 1943 and avoid discussion of the sectarian struggles that followed.

A few participants dominated the mosque conversation with their viewpoints. An elderly Palestinian former fighter mostly sat silent. Accad asked about their emotions, which prompted different responses. “Sadness at what happened,” said one. “Fear it might happen again,” said another. A third noted, “I am happy we are finally trying to talk objectively about what took place.”

To move on from the conflict, Parliament passed a general amnesty law in 1991 that pardoned all political and civil war–related crimes. Former militia leaders became politicians and ignored the peace accord to write a unified history textbook as each sect clung to its narrative.

In 1997, Lebanon mandated a new educational approach. After three years of work, the cabinet formally adopted the history curriculum. But it was never implemented due to political interference behind the scenes.

“History is written by the winners,” said Accad. “But there was no winner in Lebanon.”

Christians and Muslims fought each other, and as allegiances shifted, each religion split into rival factions that clashed as well. Accad said history became too sensitive a subject for postwar leaders, as each feared being cast as a villain. A multinarrative approach sidesteps this issue, Accad believes, as every religious community can voice its own perspective.

Accad noted that this historical retelling should not gloss over criminality, which he personally lived through. While many people left the country during the war, his father, an evangelical leader, insisted they remain and serve in their Muslim-majority neighborhood. When Accad was 13, his parents allowed a displaced family to stay in their home during a summer trip abroad—but when they returned, the family refused to leave. They became displaced in turn, forced to relocate to Christian-majority East Beirut.

Accad later became a leader as well, serving as academic dean of Arab Baptist Theological Seminary. During that time, he discovered the power of empathetic listening as he pioneered evangelical interfaith work. He learned that by genuinely listening to another person’s story, participants win the right for their stories to be heard. As Lebanon again spiraled into political and economic chaos in 2019, Accad resigned his position and founded ARA to heal the wounds left by the civil war.

ARA’s initial work was archival. After collecting facts, images, and conflicting versions of events from the sectarian press, ARA presented its findings to leaders of the different factions in the civil war. Accad focused on Christians, while Hani won the trust of Muslim groups with her Druze background and similar history of displacement. After recording responses and crosschecking perspectives, they carefully crafted each side’s narrative.

Then the hard work began. For each of the project’s four modules, ARA convened about a dozen focus groups with a maximum of 10 people and a mix of age brackets, religions, and political orientations. Accad and Hani then read—and, as necessary, explained—the narrative of the sect opposite their own, modeling empathy for the other.

Younger groups born after the war confessed they knew only the narratives of their families and sects. Those who lived through it as youth were more familiar with other narratives, as they had lived in mixed Lebanese society, but they had no idea what had really happened. After hearing facts and testimonies that clashed with what they had been taught, they often concluded, If we cannot trust our leaders about our history, why do we trust them with our politics today?

Older groups, meanwhile, recounted emotionally charged stories of victimhood alongside more muted tales of wartime combat. When a Muslim recalled the horrors of crossing a checkpoint—where militants killed civilians from both faiths simply for the religion printed on their ID cards—it matched Christian terror evading sniper fire. For the first time, many heard directly how the actions of their community hurt others. But their conclusions were personal: What did we get out of this war?

“Seeing themselves as both victims and perpetrators created empathy,” said Hani. “This is necessary to help our many sects live together as one people.”

One Druze participant, Arij Koukash, a 23-year-old independent journalist from Aley, Lebanon, said that growing up, he heard from his grandfather that Christians wanted to drive the Druze from their homes in the mountains. His grandfather was a simple man, a lifelong fighter for the Druze militia, and Koukash’s role model. In return for his grandfather’s service, the primary political party of his sect took care of family needs and would eventually ensure Koukash’s employment as well.

Koukash first began to doubt the Druze version of history in 2019 during an ultimately unsuccessful nonsectarian protest movement as he met members of different sects who similarly wished to address Lebanese corruption. A few years later, he met Hani, who invited him to an ARA focus group exploring the Palestinian massacre of Christians in the village of Damour.

Impressed by ARA’s academic professionalism and fairness in listening to all sides, Koukash shared at home what he had learned. You didn’t live the war, his grandfather said, rebuking him. But when a relative demanded Koukash remove a Facebook post criticizing a Druze leader accused of corruption, his father defended him. The family lost its life savings during the banking crisis that followed the 2019 uprising, and his parents, he said, now understand that the country must change.

“I love my grandfather,” Koukash said. “But what I learned was propaganda.”

Last April, ARA invited Koukash to speak at a commemoration of the 50th anniversary of the civil war, which featured Lebanese prime minister Nawaf Salam as well as a discussion moderated by Accad on the multiple-narratives approach to dealing with the past.

Salam and President Joseph Aoun assumed their positions early this year. Outsiders of the traditional political elite, they promised reform. Accad and Hani hope the reform will include education.

In 2022, the Ministry of Education and Higher Education announced an overhaul of the entire curriculum beginning in 2026. The effort involves the Lebanese Association for History (LAH), which hopes to shift education from rote learning to critical thinking, said its president, Leila Zahoui. LAH also supports multiple-narrative approaches to teaching about the civil war, and it created a less-controversial module on the daily life of women.

The newly appointed minister of education asked all public schools to include it and similar LAH lesson plans during the 50th anniversary week, Zahoui said, the first time the government ever authorized the teaching of civil-war material. She hopes this will lay the groundwork for future efforts to tackle the highly sensitive conflict.

“The multiple-narrative approach is gaining traction,” Hani said.

But while it may attract the attention of the philosophically minded who can place their national identity above the sectarian, Hani emphasized that the Lebanese have yet to become one people. Latent hostility still divides many. During the focus groups, one Muslim redirected Lebanon’s problems to the colonial divisions imposed on the Middle East. One Christian could only repeat his party’s political verdict about the war. Even the participant who most clearly articulated why the Lebanese could not trust their leaders then immediately walked out of the focus group, frustrated.

Many felt such frustration during the discussions.

Saeed Tuhami, the elderly Palestinian fighter in the Sayyida Aisha mosque, maintained his quiet posture at home, while his wife, Bader, spoke with animation about their family history. Tuhami was born in 1946 before the creation of Israel. His family became refugees who settled in the Mieh Mieh Palestinian camp outside Sidon. A building contractor, he married Bader, a Muslim Palestinian born in the Christian village of Mieh Mieh. Residents invited her father to live there in 1958 to escape sectarian tension.

Once married, Tuhami lived with his wife and six children in the camp and maintained good relations with Christians. Even after a Christian militia bombed the camp and displaced Palestinians during the war, he rented a Christian-owned second-floor apartment down a narrow alley in Sidon’s old city center.

But Tuhami was already a militant before the civil war started, clashing with Lebanese police he viewed as oppressive and discriminatory against Palestinian refugees. His faction smuggled rifles in a vegetable cart. During the war, he served in military intelligence, scouting the geography of southern Lebanon for fighting against Israelis, Shiites, or Christians as shifting militia alliances dictated.

“We and our neighbors shared the same water and bread,” said Bader, recalling her prewar friendships. “Those were good days, but the politicians divided us.”

She was adamantly in favor of the multiple-narratives approach, believing global media is biased against Palestinian voices. Tuhami was less sure. Why should we bother teaching our children about who killed whom 50 years ago, he said, when Gazans are being killed today?

If Christians had participated in the Sayyida Aisha discussion, Tuhami would have told them they are good people—but their leaders weren’t. He was always a faithful Muslim. But as he and Bader went back and forth about history, he noted the conflict’s many layers of complexity. Some of his own faction’s leaders were Christian, while many of his colleagues took drugs and drank alcohol. Others were motivated by Marxist ideology.

Tuhami and his fellow militants fought for their people. But as the war became increasingly sectarian, he watched Palestinian and Lebanese Muslims become more religious, believing they were fighting for Allah. Tuhami’s son thought that finding faith, at least, was positive. Yet his father remembered the horror of checkpoints where innocent people were killed for their religious identity. And on one occasion, he pleaded with fellow fighters not to take revenge against the Mieh Mieh family of an officer accused of massacring Muslims. They didn’t listen.

He lamented that if the conflict is not taught in its complexity, 70 years of history will be lost.

“Students today have to read all three perspectives,” Tuhami concluded. “If you want to have a future, you have to know your past.”

Apple PodcastsDown ArrowDown ArrowDown Arrowarrow_left_altLeft ArrowLeft ArrowRight ArrowRight ArrowRight Arrowarrow_up_altUp ArrowUp ArrowAvailable at Amazoncaret-downCloseCloseEmailEmailExpandExpandExternalExternalFacebookfacebook-squareGiftGiftGooglegoogleGoogle KeephamburgerInstagraminstagram-squareLinkLinklinkedin-squareListenListenListenChristianity TodayCT Creative Studio Logologo_orgMegaphoneMenuMenupausePinterestPlayPlayPocketPodcastRSSRSSSaveSaveSaveSearchSearchsearchSpotifyStitcherTelegramTable of ContentsTable of Contentstwitter-squareWhatsAppXYouTubeYouTube